How to identify types of insulation used in buildings & their mechanical systems:
This series of articles provides details about all types of building insulation, identifying each type of insulation.
We illustrate and include photographs of insulation materials that would not be expected to contain asbestos as well as asbestos-containing materials.
This document assists building buyers, owners or inspectors who need to identify building insulation & those who need to recognize asbestos-containing materials (or probable-asbestos) in buildings by simple visual inspection.
InspectAPedia tolerates no conflicts of interest. We have no relationship with advertisers, products, or services discussed at this website.
- Daniel Friedman, Publisher/Editor/Author - See WHO ARE WE?
On this page we provide a list of links to a comprehensive list of building insulating materials.
Each of those links provide photographs, uses, & properties of that insulating material.
[Click to enlarge any image]
While an expert lab test using polarized light microscopy may be needed to identify the specific type of asbestos fiber, or to identify the presence of asbestos in air or dust samples, many asbestos-containing building products are obvious and easy to recognize.
But since there were not other look-alike products that were not asbestos, a visual identification of this material can be virtually a certainty in many cases.
ASBESTOS-FREE INSULATION MATERIALS contains our complete list. These non-asbestos insulations include cellulosic insulations such as loose-fill cellulose and balsam wool batts, cotton insulation, fiberglass insulation, mineral wool insulation, slag wool insulation, and rock wool insulation.
Photo above: Demilec spray foam insulation fragment.
Watch out: don't confuse the R-values per inch versus specific product R-values given for insulation products discussed in this article series. For example, Thermablok® Thermal Insulation is described as having an R-value of 10.3/Inch; the product thickness is 0.4 inches so it's effective R-value when used in a single thickness is R 4.12.
Quoting R-values as R per Inch is helpful for comparing the innate insulating values of various products but to find the actual product R-value you need to find its actual thickness.
See details at INSULATION R-VALUES & PROPERTIES - R-values & U Values of various materials
Also any insulation product's installation details can completely swamp it's R-values, in particular if the installation suffers significant air leakage.
See details at INSULATION AIR & HEAT LEAKS
Prehistoric insulating materials included animal skins,fur, wool, and plant products such as reed, flax, and straw, while for greater warmth and protection from weather builders used natural shelters (caves), stone, and earth or soil.
Photo: Straw bale house in San Miguel de Allende, Guanajuato, Mexico, photographed by the author.
Some sources describe earth as having excellent insulating materials but in our opinion the benefit is better described as having good thermal mass so that temperatures inside the structure changed slowly.
The houses in the Neolithic village of Skara Brae (Orkney Island, Scotland) are the oldest known – nearly 5.000 years old – earth-sheltered, green roofed dwellings in the world. (Bozsaky 2010)
Natural materials used for insulation included vegetable fibres (eelgrass, reeds, wheat straw (cf thatched roofs), and by the 1800s, reed panels that were decay resistant but needed to be coated with tar or similar materials to resist moisture.
Other building or home insulating materials that people have used include cork (Romans, 23-79 AD, wall panels, 1870), straw bales (U.S. Nebraska 1880s), compressed straw, and "wood wool (1842 von Pannewich) and wood waste-based insulation (1920s in Scandinavia) that should be considered early instances of "balsam wool" and "jute-flax" insulation described on this page. (Bozsaky 2010)
When insulating living space or buildings, insulating material can be faced with problems of suitability to the specific application, cost to produce and install, decay, insect and rodent attack, mold contamination, moisture, rot, compression, loss of insulating value and fire hazards.
As you will read in the descriptions of each insulating material, each has its strengths and its vulnerability.
Aerogel materials are made from silica or silicate materials and are properly-called silica-aerogels, a material first produced by Kistler in 1931.
Above: a common form of asbestos insulation found in older buildings is an asbestos-based corrugated paper insulating wrap used on pipes.
Below: less common: an asbestos mix insulating plaster used in an older home,
described in more detail at
See details about actual building insulation made of or contaminated with asbestos, discussed
at ASBESTOS BUILDING INSULATION.
Also see ASBESTOS FIREPROOFING SPRAY-On Coatings
Also see ASBESTOS PIPE INSULATION - asbestos used on heating or plumbing pipes.
Because asbestos was used in many other products found on or in buildings, also
see ASBESTOS INSULATION for a complete guide to all forms of asbestos insulation found in or on buildings.
"Balsam Wool" is a wood fiber product or "cellulose" insulation that was widely used in homes and in a variety of other applications in the U.S. from at least the 1930's.
See BALSAM WOOL BATT INSULATION for details.
Brick wall "insulation" or brick nogging may be found in wood framed buildings built up to about 1900. Usually these homes have exterior clapboards and interior plaster walls.
See BRICK or BLOCK WALL CAVITY INSULATION
Bubble insulation combines the properties of a radiant barrier with bubbled plastic (basically bubble wrap) to achieve both a limited R-value and a reflective barrier value.
These insulating products are often used in metal buildings and in some RVs or similar vehicles in lieu of alternative insulation products like fiberglass that may trap and hold condensing moisture.
Similar to air bubbles trapped in plastic and faced with a reflective barrier, often polyethylene, are foil-faced closed-cell polyethylene foam insulation products.
Both provide a flexible insulating material but the thickness, density, and R-vales differ between these two approaches. Both products combine features of
1/4" to 5/16" thick double bubble layers faced with an aluminum-polyethylene reflective barrier on both sides; also sold as a single-bubble layer insulation. The company's website does not quote an R-value. Typical R-value for double-bubble insulation is R 1.1 per layer or about R 4.4 / Inch.
Ecofoil describes the insulation product shown above:
This insulation is constructed of a double layer of polyethylene bubble insulation, bonded to two radiant barrier metalized sheets. The insulation not only works well to reflect radiant heat, but it also works as a vapor barrier, preventing condensation which can cause mold.
EcoFoil Double Bubble Foil Insulation is primarily used for pole barns, metal buildings, basement walls, crawl spaces, and storage units.
Our insulation can be used for both new construction and existing buildings. - EcoFoil, https://www.ecofoil.com/products/double-bubble-foil-insulation-foil-both-sides-4-x-75-300-sq-ft
The "double bubble insulation" foil faced on both sides shown above is also discussed in a roofing repair question cited originally at ROOFING INSPECTION & REPAIR
Our photo above is of blown-in cellulose insulation.
See CELLULOSE LOOSE FILL INSULATION for details.
Concrete block walls are most-often insulated by the addition of foam board placed on the outside of the wall in new construction, or on the inside of walls in an insulation retrofit job.
However some builders may construct a concrete block wall adding foam or loose fill foam beads in the hollow spaces afforded by the concrete blocks, or by using pre-fabricated concrete blocks that are sold with a foam insulation core. Examples of these products are given in detail
Other forms of insulated concrete block are blocks made of lightweight concrete.
See those "insulated concrete block" details
at CONCRETE INSULATION & ICF CONSTRUCTION [just below on this page]
Both lightweight concrete block and panels may also be manufactured as lightweight cellular concrete shown here, without the concrete "skin" on the lightweigh concrete blocks shown above. (Illustration below adapted from Alibaba's oniste store, September 2023).
Above are examples cross-section of a lightweight panel distributed by Jinquang and building construction using those panels, cited in more detail below.
See details about lightweight concrete construction and also ICF construction at
CONCRETE INSULATION, LIGHT WEIGHT
Shown above: lightweight concrete in panel form.
Below: ICF Insulated concrete form construction: concrete is placed between or inside of pre-fabricated insulating forms that are left in place to set the R-value for the wall (illustrated below).
Above, James Hardie provides a general example of how the company's siding products should be attached to ICF or Insulated Concrete Form constructed buildings. Cited below in this discussion.
The ICF Block illustrated below, from AMVIC, is an EPS (expanded polystyrene) foam "block" with polhypropylene webs that is filled with concrete, to provide an insulated concrete wall.
This is an EPS (expanded polystyrene) foam "block" with polypropylene webs that, at the jobsite, is filled with concrete, to provide an insulated concrete wall.
INSULATING CONCRETE FORM (ICF).
A concrete forming system using stay-in-place forms ofrigid foam plastic insulation, a hybrid of cement and foam insulation, a hybrid of cement and wood chips, or other insulating material for constructing cast-in-place concrete walls.
In that same model code, ICF design and construction are regulated in the model codes such as the International Residential Code or IRC (2006) in
You can see an example of this building code as adopted by the U.S. state of Maryland in
Also see discussions of the use of lightweight concrete found at
ENERGY SAVINGS RETROFIT OPTIONS includes ultra lightweight concrete insulation, insulating forms for concrete foundations
STRESS SKIN / STRUCTURAL INSULATED PANELS (SIPs)
[Photo examples of ICF construction and lightweight concrete construction are needed, please use the page top or bottom CONTACT link]
Our photo above is of cotton batt building insulation.
See COTTON INSULATING BATTS for details.
Below, an older crepe paper building insulation product, followed by a modern version of crepe insulation.
Below: modern Kraft paper insulation
are described in detail at KRAFT PAPER INSULATION CREPE KIMSUL
Above: rigid fiberglass liner of an air handler or blower unit return air plenum. Notice the leak stains.
Below: round fiberglass HVAC duct section - note that both of these installations expose the fiberglass surface to accumulation of dust, debris, and potentially more troublesome particles or substances.
Below: water leaks, probably from condensate, stain the aluminum foil cover of this air handler unit floor.
See
Above: a home made supply plenum insulation job using fiberglass batts and chicken wire. This is not a proper nor safe duct or HVAC insulation approach.
Below: fiberglass flex duct
Our discussion of eelgrass insulation is now found at
Fiberboard insulating sheathing board was used and continues in use as a structural wall sheathing board 15/32-inches thick (one board was 1/2") and with R-value of about 1.5.
Fiberboard insulating sheathing was and continues to be made of plant cellulose such as wood fibers, combined with a binder, a water-resistive coating or component (such as paraffin and/or asphalt), and other treatments.
Our photo is of a fiberboard building sheathing / insulating board product. See Sheathing Celotex Homasote & Other brownboards discussed
at SHEATHING, FIBERBOARD for details about insulating sheathing used on both the exterior (under siding) and interior of buildings.
See FIBERBOARD SHEATHING IDENTIFICATION where we include identification photos and historic details and insulating properties of all of the current and prior brands and tupes of fiberboard panels.
Example: CELOTEX CemestO BOARD HOMES
See FIBERGLASS INSULATION IDENTIFICATION & PROPERTIES - properties for a key to identifying fiberglass building insulation brands & products.
Fire-block foam is a fire-resistant foam spray used to seal building floor, wall, or ceiling penetrations, especially in new construction or a spray-foam insulation retrofit job.
See FIRE-BLOCK FIRE RETARDANT FOAM SPRAY BUILDING INSULATION
Please see this separate article that sorts out all of the various types of foam insulation
FOAM SPRAY INSULATION TYPES including both modern sprayed in place foam insulating products including SPF (Spray Polyurethane), or
ICYNENE FOAM SPRAY INSULATION) and older
sprayed UREA FORMALDEHYDE FOAM INSULATION, UFFI.
Also see FORMALDEHYDE HAZARDS
Our photograph shows icynene spray foam building insulation.
See ICYNENE FOAM SPRAY INSULATION
and also PHENOLIC FOAM INSULATION
and POLYISOCYANURATE FOAM and IAQ for details.
Above, a photo of jute insulation placed between rafters of a North American home built in the 1920s, courtesy of an InspectApedia reader.
See details at HEMP / JUTE INSULATION
Mineral wool is produced by melting rock and slag to produce a mineral fiber that may be aggregated and bound by a resin for use as building insulation.
Mineral wool, also called "rock wool" or slag wool or stone wool may be found in buildings as chopped loose-fill insulation, as longer twisted ropy loose fill insulation, or as insulating batts such as the Gold Bond Rock Wool insulating batt shown in our photograph.
See MINERAL WOOL - ROCK WOOL INSULATION - home
Above and below: While mineral wool insulation may be white, gray, black or even pink, it most-often looks like either the photos just below.
See all of the MINERAL WOOL APPEARANCE VARIATIONS in our separate photo guide to the different versions, colors, and textures of mineral wool, rock wool, or slag wool insulation.
Moss has been used as building or shelter insulation [research in process - Ed.]
Our photograph shows perlite insulation.
At least an an experimental level, thermal insulating panels made of polyester fiber have been produced from recycled post-consumer PET bottles. Details are in this studh:
We are starting to look into getting some new insulation and facing put in our shop. The current product is at least 15-20years old. We were going to just carefully wipe down the dirty putter facing and postpone this project for another year or two, but that job in itself quickly became a hassle.
As we are currently looking into which insulation and facing we will replace it with, we are trying to figure out what kind of insulation facing was originally put on that we have right now. The facing itself is exposed on the walls and ceiling besides the first 8’ of wall cover at the bottom.
Do you know of anyway to determine what type of facing we have? I attached a few pictures of it in case you might be able to help out with any guesses...
Thanks a lot for your help! - Anonymous by private email 2018/02/10
The facing is a polypropylene product from Lamtec, to be specific, Metallized Polypropylene reinforced with Tri-directional Fiberglass/Polyester. See the attached sheet from Lamtec.
Unfortunately I can't read all of the details on your insulation labels nor can I see what's inside that plastic bag.
I'd send your photos directly to your insulation supplier to ask about the insulating material itself - I couldn't make much out in the photo.
Your supplier is still in business: Bay Insulation Supply, Website: http://www.bayinsulationsupply.com/
It's useful to know where the insulation was installed in the building: roof, walls, ducts, on equipment, etc.
Let me know what you're told and we can take it from there.
See
See POLYISOCYANURATE FOAM BOARD
Our photograph shows indoor use of polystyrene foam insulating board on the inside of a basement foundation wall - notice the absence of a suitable fire-resistant covering?
This installation probably violates local building codes. Foam insulating boards do not contain asbestos but can present a fire hazard because they give off dense smoke and possibly toxic fumes in a fire.
Other older building insulation materials such as corn cobs, newspaper, bricks, and simple reflective barriers using aluminum foil also would not be expected to contain asbestos.
Our discussion of seaweed and seagrass insulation is now found at
Sold in the U.K. as shown here, SheepWool® insulation is sold in a 50mm thickness, in lengths of 9m (rolled up) at 380mm wide, and is described by the UK Vendor cited below as follows:
Sheep Wool Insulation Optimal is a range of grey coloured sheep's wool insulation rolls offering high thermal and acoustic. Optimal rolls are suitable for use in floor and ceiling level applications and are available in a variety of convenient dimensions.
Details are at SHEEPS WOOL INSULATION
- Source: The European Reaction to Fire classification system (Euro classes), Fire Safety explained, retrieved 2019/01/04 original source: ROCKWOOL Ltd /Rockpanel Customer Services/Sales Support Advisor Wern Tarw Pencoed Bridgend CF35 6NY Tel.: +44 (1656) 863 210 Fax: +44 (1656) 863 611 www.rockpanel.co.uk http://www.rockpanel.co.uk/technical-support/fs-xtra/euroclass/
Starch foam, originally produced for use in bio-degradable packaging and as an alternative to polystyrene foam insulating products, is described by Siverstein (2007):
Starch foam was made already in 1989 as biodegradable packaging, and is an alternative material to the traditional polystyrene foams. Starch is a polysaccharide made up of glucose units linked by glycoside linkages, and its length is generally between 500-2000 repeat units.
Starch is made up of amylose and amylopectin Amylose is more linear and gives the foam flexibility and keeps the density low, while amylopectin is highly branched and makes the product more foamable. Starch can be extracted from for example corn or potatoes.
Starch foams are produced by extrusion where the starch is melted and mixed with a blowing agent. The blowing agent for starch is often water or methanol, which is turned into steam when the system is heated and forms air bubbles within the starch matrix.
The extrusion process is a continuous, low-cost method that is easy to use. It is still hard to make the foam smooth and have a high number of closed cells. The use of thermoplastic polymer additives can help even out the surfaces, but can also decrease the degradability of the foam by incorporating slowly degrading or non-degradable polymers. - Siversten, 2007
Starch has been used as a binder in "super green" building products, including some insulation products or bio-fiber insulation products, possibly including cellulose or wood fibers, ("bico fibers") installed in North America beginning in about 1985, using starch extract from corn, beans or other sources. - Bomberg
Here we describe less-common shredded materials found in buildings as insulation, such as this woody or plastic-like insulating material provided by an InspectApedia reader.
Note that other more common shredded insulations are shown separately at
What is this insulation that looks like shredded paper?
what kind of isolation is this? looks like a shredded paper. - On 2021-05-01 by Rafal -
Reply by (mod) - Tips for identifying shredded insulation
@Rafal,
That's an insulation product that I have not seen although we did come across a shredded plastic material it looked similar.
Are you sure that the fibrous material in the stitched inslation blanket is shredded plastic and not seagrass or seaweed insulation?
Compare what you have there
with SEAWEED INSULATION
Can you tell me the country and city where the building is located and the building age?
Shredded paper is another reasonable possibility or some other shredded plant or industrial waste material. Cardboard?
Look closely at some of the fragments for printing or for variation in color and try posting a sharp close up photo.
If you see actual printed letters and/or inks of various colours then it's probably shredded paper or newsprint.
But as I've not seen paper (cellulose) insulation quite like this, the jury is out for the moment.
See CELLULOSE LOOSE FILL INSULATION for examples of identifying that material.
This seems to be shredded plastic "insulation"?
Found this behind lath and plaster. Any idea what it is? Thanks ! - On 2020-09-15 by Billy J. -
Reply by (mod) -
Coarse black fibrous insulation identificationBilly
Thank you for the photo and question;
Like the Poughkeepsie Police desk sergeant told our tenant Anna M. when she called to say she wanted the cops to tell the railroad engineers not to blow their horns at night, .... "Well that's one I've never encountered before".
That looks like plastic or other fibrous shards. What's the texture? It could be a wood or paper product. I'm researching further.
Thanks for the reply! feels like plastic or maybe rubber. Just want to know if it’s safe to work around !
Reply by (mod) - shredded plastic insulation - recycled polyurethane insulation?
It looks like shredded plastic to me, too, or maybe shredded housewrap or plastic refuse or polyurethane scraps;
You could take a bit of the material outside and see if it ignites and if it smells like burning plastic, but ...
Watch out: Keep in mind that if this isn't a listed insulation it may not be fire-safe.
I'd take a pinch of it outside, put it in a saucer, and see if you can light it on fire. (Do not get burned, etc.) stay safe.
Let me know what you find.
Also is there any kraft facing or wrapping with any markings?
Watch out: using a DIY or re-purposed material for building insulation, if the material is not listed and approved for that purpose, may be a dangerous fire hazard.
Above, suggested by another reader, we illustrate Merryweather Foam Inc.'s .75" x 38" x 46" Black 10 PPI Reticulated Polyurethane Foam Sheet that is used for a variety of purposes such as filters but that in my opinion is entirely unsuitable for building insulation: its openings are far too large to imprison air and thus won't have much insulating value.
Follow-up by Billy J.
Ya we tried burning it and it did burn. Smelt like plastic but didn’t burn like it. Any worry about it being asbestos ?
Reply by (mod) - properties of shredded-plastic-like building insulation
Billy
Post a photo of your shredded plastic insulation burn test;
And consider that the real worry here isn't asbestos - if it's plastic it's not likely to sport much by way of asbestos - but that we don't know what the material is, we don't know that it's a listed, safe insulating material, and we don't know that in the event of a fire you may have a faster- or hotter- fire spread that results in more-extensive loss, damage, injury or worse, death.
I'd look further into the history of the building, when was this stuff added, what is it.
In addition to foam, cellulose chopped-fiberglass and mineral-wool insulation already described and linked-to on this page, there are quite a few other spray insulation products used in modern construction as we note here.
Above: illustration from AISLA Insulation System's catalog cited below shows the most-common insulating materials used in spray applications.
[Click to enlarge any image]
Below: an example of CoolMachines.com insulation spray equipment from the same catalog cited below.
Modern insulation, adhesive, and sealant spray applications cover a wide range of materials and applications including building insulation, noise and sound control, damp-proofing, and adhesives used in construction.
Here we illustrate examples of contemporary insulation spray equipment and provide manufacturer catalog and contact information.
Uses of straw as a building insulation material [research in process, contributions welcome - Ed.]
See details at STRESS SKIN / STRUCTURAL INSULATED PANELS (SIPs) - Structural Insulated Panels
Also see CONCRETE INSULATION & ICFs Insulated Concrete Form construction
Our photograph shows indoor use of pink styrofoam insulating board on a basement ceiling.
As with the next example just below, this installation violates fire safety & fire codes - in an occupied or occupy-able space it should be covered with a fire-resistant drywall or other acceptable barrier.
See also
Here, using a reader Q&A discussion, we give the visual appearance of Owens Corning Thermafiber INSUL-FILL Blown In Attic Insulation - an insulation that can be confusing to identify as it is a mixture of mineral wool mixed with recycled newsprint (cellulose).
I was told this was 100% mineral wool insulation but there's paper in it - what is it?
Hi. I had what was supposed to be 100% mineral wool insulation blown into my ceiling cavities while renovating my home in 2021. Also, the vendor claimed their products do not contain formaldehyde.
Fast forward and I recently had a plumbing leak which required the removal of some of this now insulation and I was surprised to find lots of bits of paper in it and yellowish color mixed in. To me, this indicates the likelihood of formaldehyde due to binder use and the product not being 100% mineral wool.
Also, the product was sold to me as being resistant to fungal growth, but I’m guessing that’s not the case if it has been cut with a bunch of paper.
What are your thoughts about this product based on the photo and my description? Have I likely been hosed by a contractor who was trying to save a buck? Thank you for your help! - On 2023-09-02 by Sam -
Reply by InspectApedia Publisher (mod)
@Sam,
From your photo and description that is certainly not 100% mineral wool insulation - bits of paper are characteristic of cellulose insulation
See CELLULOSE LOOSE FILL INSULATION for details. https://inspectapedia.com/insulation/Cellulose_Insulation.php
Find and post a photo of the packaging - if there is any - of the insulation product used by your installer - else ask them to tell you the product name and brand - then we can together look at the product specification. IT looks as if you have a mix of at least two insulating materials.
I don't assume that you've been "hosed" (before we know the product specifics we don't even know its actual cost ) and I don't assume the material installed is not perfectly fine, but I, too, would want to know what was installed and I'd be disappointed if I were misled by the installer.Follow-up by Sam - GC says he installed Thermafiber insul-fill.
@InspectApedia Publisher, thank you so much for your reply and help! My GC just informed me it’s supposed to be Thermafiber insul-fill.
Here’s an image of what it looked like when wet. Thoughts?
Reply by InspectApedia Publisher (mod) - visual appearance of Owens Corning Thermafiber INSUL-FILL Blown In Attic Insulation - compare with mineral wool mixed with recycled newsprint (cellulose)
@Sam,
Just above is Thermafiber's example photo of their mineral wool INSUL-FILL attic blown-in insulation
Your second photo looks like mineral wool insulation but it definitely contains some bits of paper with text on it - almost certainly recycled newsprint. Is it from the same material as was in your first photo? That product looked quite different in that I thought I saw more such paper bits.
Below is an enlargement from your second mineral wool insulation sample, showing newsprint.
You can see what Thermafiber INSUL-FILL looks like and read or download PDFs of its product specifications on our page
MINERAL WOOL - ROCK WOOL INSULATION
If a closer look at your installed insulation in the attic - try a simple magnifying glass - is showing many small bits of paper and newsprint (look for letters on the paper bits) then it sure doesn't look like the Owens Corning Thermafiber's own photo of their product to me.Here is what Owens Corning Thermafiber says about the composition of this insulation:
What is Thermafiber® mineral wool insulation?Thermafiber® mineral wool insulation is made from naturally occurring rocks and recycled slag. Slag is a by-product of the steel industry. Rocks, of various types, are an abundant natural resource.
These raw materials are melted at 2,600°F and fiberized (spun into fibers) to create Thermafiber® mineral wool insulation products with an industry leading minimum of 70 percent recycled content 1.
Thermafiber® mineral wool insulation is naturally non-combustible and fire resistant up to 1093° C (2000° F) making it great for providing protection to structures.
Source:
- Owens Corning Thermafiber FREQUENTLY-ASKED QUESTIONS [PDF] (2017) - retrieved 2023/09/08, original source: thermafiber.ca/wp-content/uploads/2018/05/600022A-Thermafiber-FAQ-Document-ENG.pdf
The note 1 in that information source reads:
1 Recycled content as verified by ICC-ES.
Also see this
- ICC-ES VAR ENVIRONMENTAL REPORT VAR-1025 on Thermafiber Insulation [PDF] (2023) on Owens Corning Mineral Wool Products (Thermafiber) - retrieved 2023/09/08, original source: icc-es.org/wp-content/uploads/report-directory/VAR-1025.pdf
Excerpt:
3.0 DESCRIPTION
Thermafiber(R) insulation products consist of a mixture of volcanic roc, slag, natural rock, various binders, and oil.
Nothing in this product description explicitly mentions a composition of Thermofiber insulation that includes cellulose or newsprint or similar materials like that we see clearly in your sample.
However while the contents of "recycled content" might be a bit fuzzy all of the text describing Thermafiber describes the product as an inorganic material made from rocks and slag. That's mineral wool, not paper. Paper is made from wood pulp or plant materials - which are organic.
"Our mineral wool contains a minimum of 70% recycled content, and it’s non-combustible, inorganic and mold-resistant. Thermafiber is the #1 specified brand of commercial mineral wool." - source: ABOUT THERMOFIBER [PDF] - original source: https://www.thermafiber.com/about-thermafiber/
So in my OPINION, if in fact it includes recycled paper such as newsprint, then the company's description of the Thermofiber as inorganic mineral fiber may be a bit incomplete and confujsing.
BUT the ICC-ES report notes that
Recycled content building materials shall comply with one of the following
1. Contain not less than 25 percent combined post-consumer and pre-consumer recovered material, and shall comply with section 505.2.3
2. Contain not less than 50 percent combined post-consumer and pre-consumer recovered materials.
In my OPINION the vague term "post-consumer recovered material" could include newsprint even though the product is described as made from the mineral products I cited earlier.
For a final answer to this question I suggest contacting the company's Thermfibert technical services department at 1-888-834-2371 or email Thermafi berInsolutions@owenscorning.com.
Ask the company if they include recycled newsprint (cellulose) in their Thermafiber INSUL-FILL products (which is fine if they do) and if they say not, then your insulation product is most likely something else.
In that case, consider mailing them a sample for them to look for themselves. The company would not be happy for someone to be installing something represented as theirs but that is from another source.Insulation R-valuel Fire Rating, Mold Resistance of Mineral Wool Mixed with Newsprint
All of this is beside any question about the efficacy of your insulation but in my opinion it's perfectly reasonable to want to know what insulation was installed and that it has proper insulating value and fire safety ratings as you'd expect.
About your concern for mold resistance, mineral wool itself is in my experience more mold-resistant than fiberglass insulation.
I do not know for fact about the newsprint we see in your insulation, but certainly conventional cellulose loose fill or blown-in insulation that uses recycled newsprint or paper is treated with a fire retardant, often a borate salt, that also imparts some mold resistance.
Tripolymer foam building insulation may be used as building insulation as an alternative to more-widely-used icynene foam. Tripolymer foam, unlike icynene insulation, is a water-soluble foam insulation.
According to the U.S. Department of Energy,
Tripolymer foam—a water-soluble foam—is injected into wall cavities. It has excellent resistance to fire and air intrusion. - U.S. DOE, ret. 2017
Tripolymer foam, because it is water-based during application, has the following properties:
Tripolymer foam, a product that was manufactured by C.P. Chemical Company, a New York Corporation, and marketed under the name Tripolymer4 105, was installed by injection into the building wall or (enclosed) ceiling cavities. In1986 C.P. Chemical was involved in litigation against the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) concerning this insulating material. C.P. Chemical's complaint against the CPSC was dismissed by the court.
Excerpts from the court decision cited below:
The suit arose from the Commission's ban on the use of formaldehyde-emitting foam insulation, 47 Fed.Reg. 57,488 (1982).
The Fifth Circuit ruled, in Gulf South Insulation v. U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, 701 F.2d 1137, 1148-50 (5th Cir. 1983), that the ban was improper because it was promulgated under the procedures of the CPSA, 15 U.S.C. §§ 2057, 2058, 2079(d), rather than under the appropriate procedures of the Federal Hazardous Substances Act, 15 U.S.C. §§ 1261-1276.
C.P. Chemical alleged that the Commission erroneously included within the ban its insulation product, Tripolymer 105, which emits no formaldehyde gas.
The district court held that the FTCA waiver of sovereign immunity does not extend to the agency conduct forming the basis for this tort action against the United States and the Commission.
The court also held that the CPSA provides no predicate for this action. For the reasons stated below, we affirm.
C.P. Chemical Company is a family-owned New York corporation that manufactured "Tripolymer 105," a foam insulation product that was mixed on the job site and pumped between a structure's walls. Tripolymer 105, a phenal-urea based product, competed with a similar product--urea-formaldehyde foam insulation ("UFFI").
However, unlike Tripolymer 105, UFFI was found to emit detectable levels of formaldehyde gas.
...
C.P. Chemical Company, along with other foam insulation manufacturers, sought judicial review of the UFFI ban pursuant to 15 U.S.C. § 2060. On April 7, 1983, the Fifth Circuit held that the Commission's rule was not supported by substantial evidence and therefore vacated the ban. Gulf South Insulation v. U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, 701 F.2d 1137 (5th Cir. 1983).
While expressly declining to address C.P. Chemical's claim that it should have been exempted from the ban because its product was safer than UFFI, 701 F.2d at 1140, the court also held that the Commission had followed the wrong rulemaking procedures when it promulgated the rule under the informal procedures of the Consumer Product Safety Act, 15 U.S.C. §§ 2058, 2079(d).
The agency should have proceeded under the Federal Hazardous Substances Act, 15 U.S.C. §§ 1261-1276, which requires a formal hearing wherein rules of evidence are applied and the right to confront and cross-examine witnesses is recognized, 701 F.2d at 1149-50, see 15 U.S.C. § 1262(a) (2).
C.P. Chemical Company, along with other foam insulation manufacturers, sought judicial review of the UFFI ban pursuant to 15 U.S.C. § 2060. On April 7, 1983, the Fifth Circuit held that the Commission's rule was not supported by substantial evidence and therefore vacated the ban. Gulf South Insulation v. U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, 701 F.2d 1137 (5th Cir. 1983).
While expressly declining to address C.P. Chemical's claim that it should have been exempted from the ban because its product was safer than UFFI, 701 F.2d at 1140, the court also held that the Commission had followed the wrong rulemaking procedures when it promulgated the rule under the informal procedures of the Consumer Product Safety Act, 15 U.S.C. §§ 2058, 2079(d).
The agency should have proceeded under the Federal Hazardous Substances Act, 15 U.S.C. §§ 1261-1276, which requires a formal hearing wherein rules of evidence are applied and the right to confront and cross-examine witnesses is recognized, 701 F.2d at 1149-50, see 15 U.S.C. § 1262(a) (2).
...
CONCLUSION
For the reasons stated above, we hold that the district court correctly dismissed the complaint for lack of subject matter jurisdiction and for failure to state a claim. The judgment of the district court is affirmed.
Our photograph above shows UFFI building insulation.
See UREA FORMALDEHYDE FOAM INSULATION, UFFI
Also see URETHANE FOAM INSULATION
Our photograph shows Vermiculite building insulation.
See VERMICULITE INSULATION for details.
Contemporary wood fibre panels are sold in a variety of textures and for a wide range of uses including as a nail base in roofing and siding, as structural insulated panels or SIPS, as insulating sheathing (fiberboard), and as acoustical panels for interior use.
Photo of wood fiber insulating panels is provided courtesy of InspectApedia.com reader Robin.
For contemporary wood fibre panels used both as insulation and as an acoustic or sound insulating panel, see details
at WOOD FIBRE INSULATING PANELS
See also BALSAM WOOL BATT INSULATION - older, traditional batts, paper enclosed shredded wood insulation -
See also SHEATHING, FIBERBOARD - home - fiberboard panels used as nail base and insulating sheathing indoors and on building exteriors
Below: an example of 1940s balsam wool insulation used inside of a refrigerator.
...
Below you will find questions and answers previously posted on this page at its page bottom reader comment box.
I stumbled upon your site while trying to find out what kind of insulation I have in my very old home.
Here is a picture.
[Click to enlarge any image]
Of course my main worry is that it's asbestos. - Anonymous by private email 2018/06/02
Reply: No; mineral wool, or a mix w/ fiberglass and fiberboard fragments
The photo is indistinct, but it looks like a mixture of yellow fiberglass and rockwool or a mineral wool insulation product, this one rather ground-up.
In fact that brown material in your photo could be broken-up fiberboard insulation.
It seems unlikely, certainly there would not be asbestos expected to be in fiberglass or mineral wool nor in fiberboard.
But keep in mind I can't that your health and your money on a blurry photograph.
Is your sample taken from a demolition project?
You can see more identification photos of those materials at our website.
In particular take a look at
Reader reply:
Well thanks again. I couldn't get too much of a close up but those chunks you see are very soft, like paper or cardboard. Here's another picture a little closer, the plastic bag may be dulling the image a bit.
But from what you said, there's doesn't seem to be a need for too much concern. I suppose I can send it out to a lab if I need to. Anyway, thanks for helping on a saturday.
Moderator reply:
"Paper insulation" would be cellulose insulation.
Any "feedback" on this white insulation material?
I would appreciate any info or feedback on this, in the attic of a house we were hoping to purchase. Many thanks.
- On 2023-12-16 by Vanessa Susan Bowler -
Reply by InspectApedia Publisher: what insulation question are we answering: identity, condition, hazards, building damage?
@Vanessa Susan Bowler,
I'm not sure what you're asking,
- whether it's identifying insulation or
- the fact that there are areas with no insulation
- the condition of the plaster left ceiling that I think I see in areas of that photo
- the history of leaks in the attic and possible leak stains in a few areas
- the presence of a fiberboard panel
- the dimensions, spacing, and condition of the roof framing
- the extent of or absence of attic ventilation and the presence of moisture.
Every one of those, plus other things that an on-site inspector should see that I can't in your photo would be worth understanding.
Since you're posting on our insulation identification page I'm guessing that that was your primary question.
I see some areas with no insulation at all.
I also see what looks like possibly mineral wool or rock wool but the photo is a bit blurry so I can't be certain.
It's a bit hard to see insulation and just one small area of an attic of an older home. Normally if you were going to go to the trouble to add insulation you would do the whole attic not just one small area.
But then I don't know what the rest of the attic looks like.
If you look through the insulation examples that we give here you will see how to distinguishmineral wool from UFFI foam or other insulating materials.
Please also take a look through that since you've actually been on the site and have had a closer look than I can obtain from the photo.
Or if you have other photos that give a sharp closer view that would be helpfulFollow-up by Vanessa Susan Bowler
@InspectApedia Publisher, Thank you and apologies for only the one photo - it's the only one I've got. I guess I wanted to know what the white powdery insulation stuff visible might be.
Reply by InspectApedia Publisher - what is the white powdery insulation stuff in my attic - Crumbly white foam = UFFI
@Vanessa Susan Bowler,
Okay, that added detail is helpful.
If there's a crumbly insulation in that area that is powdery or easily is crumpled to powder it's probably UFFI.
You can read about that insulation in this article series
Surely you have had a professional home inspection if you're buying a home and in that case the inspector should have come in it to you on the insulation visible in the attic.
Can you tell me what that report contained and with the inspector said?
What's odd in my experience is to find UFFI only in a small area of an attic. Normally one wouldn't go to the trouble of blowing in foam insulation without doing the whole building or at least the whole attic and wallsFollow-up by Vanessa
@InspectApedia Publisher, Thanks very much for coming back to me - appreciated. We had a full survey of course and the surveyor has said it's a white powdery substance which could possibly contain asbestos.
Like you I find it strange that the rest of the loft wouldn't also have this white stuff in too. I can just make out some of the more recognisable pink roll insulation under a board to the left.
I'm wondering whether the white stuff could be mould. Anyway, we will have it tested once the vendor agrees to that.
Reply by InspectApedia Publisher - crumbly insulation may be UFFI
@Vanessa,
I'd be stunned to find mold that thick in an attic;
But if it's a material that crumbles easily take a look at UREA FORMALDEHYDE FOAM INSULATION, UFFI
Back in our lab where I could look at your photo on a large display, this close-up suggests UFFI, perhaps partly removed.
Do let us know what you find as that will be most helpful to other readers finding similar-looking insulation in old buildings.
Where is this building and what is its age?If it's UFFI it's not an asbestos product.
Follow-up by Vanessa
@InspectApedia Publisher. Thanks again - most useful information. I will update when I've received more information from testing (not sure when that will be yet). The house is roughly 1950 and is in West Sussex here in the UK.
Reply by InspectApedia Publisher - UFFI was never "banned" in the U.K.
@Vanessa,
Thanks for that added detail.
Our understanding is that unlike in the U.S., UFFI was never "banned" in the U.K. so it might well appear in homes of various ages.
Still, seeing it in just fragmentary remains in a home is unusual.
When you read our UFFI articles you'll see that while there was an early concern about formaldehyde offgassing, a problem that was detected particularly if the UFFI was improperly mixed during installation, that offgassing occurred in the early life of the material and by now that's long gone and not a worry.Still you might come across a home where someone was anxious and removed some or all of the material (needlessly in our opinion).
Follow-up by Vanessa Susan Bowler - Test confirmed no asbestos in this insulation
@InspectApedia-911, well, the vendor got the sample tested yesterday by a specialist and I was very relieved to hear that it did not contain asbestos! Still no idea what it actually is, but that's what we needed to know so, all good.
Reply by InspectApedia DF (mod) - Re: test results found asbestos
@Vanessa Susan Bowler,
Good news about the negative asbestos test results. It would be helpful for us and other readers to know what else the test results said as that may help identify a similar insulation in the future, even if not asbestos.
Is it possible to get a copy of the test results from the vendor? If so, you could send us a copy of it via email which can be found at our Contact page (link at bottom of this page).
Thanks again for the discussion and the added information.If you take a look at the articles we recommended about UFFI you will see how easy it is to identify that insulation. Compare that with what you found in your attic.
Follow-up by Vanessa Susan Bowler - but the asbestos test gives no other information about this insulation
@InspectApedia DF, Hello again - the test result sheet gives no useful information unfortunately, other than that the material has been tested and is not asbestos. Sorry not to be able to help more.
Reply by InspectApedia Publisher
@Vanessa Susan Bowler,
I would like to have seen that report. We could keep it private if you want to send it to me by email. Certainly in my forensic work I would have told you what the material was or I would have admitted that I couldn't identify it. I agree that that's a separate issue from detecting or not detecting asbestos in the material.
A careful look in your attic might reveal that there was UFFI insulation and that most of it was removed and for some reason this bit was missed. That's the only explanation I can think of if UFFI is what's there.
No one would spray just a small area with foam insulation.
But if the attic had been insulated with UFFI and people panicked about it earlier in his life they might have removed it. Even though it was later found to have been an unnecessary step.
Or it could have been removed for other reasons such as access to building surfaces for repair or wiring etc.
Need help identifying this white fibrous loose fill insulation - asbestos?
Can you help ID this? Found in the ceiling of a basement finished in MD in the 1950s as our contractor started demo to redo it.
Didnt see it until after two days of demo and I’m worried we’ve busted open a bunch of asbestos.
- On 2023-11-30 by EH
Reply by InspectApedia Publisher
@EH,
That looks like mineral wool or rock wool insulation.
On 2023-08-08 by Davey - Insulation found with kraft facing saying "Canada Gypsum" - they used asbestos
Hi, I tore a hole in some paper when replacing my bathroom fan.
Canadian Gypsum Company used asbestos. Is that grey material asbestos? Hole is blocked up for now.
- On 2023-11-30 by EH
On 2023-08-09 by InspectApedia Publisher (mod) - Canadian Gypsum Kraft paper faced Fiberglass Wall Insulation
@Davey,
I can't see too much in that little tear but it sure looks like fiberglass insulation to me..
Am I right that the imprint on the craft paper facing on that insulation is
Canadian Gypsum Company RED ?
If you can post a closer and sharper image that would be helpful.Followup by Davey - decided to vacate the house and get the room and materials tested and have the attic inspected
@InspectApedia Publisher,
Hi, I decided to vacate the house and get the room and materials tested and have the attic inspected, I feel quite stupid for trying to do this job in an old house. Yes it says Canadian Gypsum Company RED.On 2023-08-09 by InspectApedia Publisher (mod) - small tear in fiberglass insulation kraft facing = not dangerous
@Davey,
With all due respect, that sounds extreme considering that you have what looks like a tiny tear in a craft facing on what's most likely fiberglass insulation.Your photo isn't quite sharp enough for me to be certain but it sure looks as if that's a kraft (paper) faced fibrous insulation such as fiberglass (most-likely) or possibly rock wool (mineral wool) insulation.
We just can't see enough in your photo.
Certainly if you're concerned, just tape over that torn kraft facing with a bit of foil tape.
Perhaps there's a hazard concern here that I have missed or misunderstood from your post. But if your concern is for this tear in the insulation kraft paper facing, evacuating the house is simply not necessary, justified, nor appropriate.I urge you to read
OTHER PEOPLE's MONEY - watch out or you may spend a lot more than is appropriate
and
HAZARD vs RISK - what's the difference
Is this light colored loose fill attic insulation: mineral wool?
Type of insulation? See partial bag in background - On 2023-07-23 by Bill -
Reply by InspectApedia Publisher (mod)
@Bill,
Photo isn't fully sharp but that could be mineral wool - compare with the mineral wool given in links above on this page.
If you can post more-complete photos (one per comment) of any insulation kraft facing or packaging labeling that would be a great contribution and would allow us to research and comment further on what you've got.
What type of insulation is this white fluffy fibrous material?
Anyone know what type of insulation this might be? - On 2023-07-14 by Adam green -
Reply by InspectApedia Publisher (mod) - photo of scraps of mineral wool or fiberglass insulation
@Adam green,
Mineral wool or white fiberglass.Followup by Adam
Went rummaging thru an apartment complex attic, built in 1970. Does this look like asbestos?
Reply by InspectApedia Publisher (mod)
@Adam,
We will appreciate that follow-up.
Also see
MINERAL WOOL https://inspectapedia.com/insulation/Insulation-Identification-Guide.php#Mineral_Wool
photos and description and historyFollowup by Adam
@InspectApedia DF, what a relief... will be testing it and will report test results. Thanks so much!
Reply by InspectApedia DF (mod) - 1970s mineral wool or fiberglass insulation
@Adam,
It looks like mineral wool insulation with some fiberglass bits as well.
Can you identify this loose coarse tan fibrous ceiling insulation in a home in Melbourne, Australia? Shredded wood?
Are you able to tell us what this loose ceiling insulation is.
It looks like shredded wood.
The house was built in 1950's in Melbourne, Australia - On 2023-06-18 by Jeff -
Reply by InspectApedia Publisher (mod) - Seaweed-like insulation in 1950's in Melbourne, Australia home
@Jeff,
See SEAWEED INSULATION https://inspectapedia.com/insulation/Insulation-Identification-Guide.php#Seaweed
or a similar plant based insulating fibre.
and also tell me the country and city of location of the building and the building age.
Identify this gray insulation from a 1962 house?
Hello. This is an attic insulation sample we took from a house we acquired built in 1962. Thoughts on the type ?
- On 2023-04-27 by Eric L -
Reply by InspectApedia Publisher - mineral or slag wool insulation
@Eric L,
It looks like mineral wool, or slag wool, commonly used in most countries in the 1960s.
But there are some less-common lookalikes, even using wool, so do take a look through the insulation identification photos above on this page and let me know if you have a different idea.
What is this white-grey blown in insulation with a powdery texture?
Blown-in insulation in the attic space of our home. This white/grey material that has a texture like flower with small granulars (1-2mm diameter) in it was found in my attic space underneath a layer of cellulose.
Just wondering if anyone has any experience with this material. From the previous owner, this insulation was installed between 1960 and 1970.
- On 2023-04-25 by John Anderson -
Reply by InspectApedia Editor - Possibly a mix of cellulose & perlite?
@John Anderson,
The photo isn't too clear but that looks like cellulose insulation - look very closely at samples to see if you can find tiny bits of newsprint - that would confirm my guess, and also look at example photos found at this guide
CELLULOSE INSULATION
https://inspectapedia.com/insulation/Cellulose_Insulation.phpIf there are small white spherical fragments of soft material that may be an addition of perlite or a similar insulation material. Perlite is also described on this page.
Let me know what you thinkFollowup by John Anderson
@InspectApedia Editor , there are no bits of paper or anything like that.
There is a layer of cellulose on top of this different material (not pictured). It is whiteish/grey and quite dusty with little grains that can be crushed between my fingers.
The cellulose material is much more coarse in texture and the particle size is larger. This material is more like flower with little grains.
Reply by InspectApedia Editor
@John Anderson,
Try posting a sharper close-up photo and I can say more.
And try looking through the ID photos and suggestions for various types of insulation above on this page.
Your first photo looks as if it could be MINERAL WOOL if it's not cellulose; but the photo is blurry so ia gray insulation could on closer look and sharper focuse turn out to be cellulose.Also, some early foams could be crushed to powder (UFFI) but those don't look like what I see in your photo.
Followup by John Anderson
@InspectApedia Editor: here (above and below) is a detailed image. Some of the material has clumped together when I removed it.
Reply by InspectApedia Publisher - insulating products mixing perlite and pumice
@John Anderson,
Maybe you've come up with an insulation that I've not seen personally.
There were some insulating products made mixing perlite and pumice.
I understand we think this insulation was installed in the 1960s.
Where is this building and when was it built?
Your photos appear to combine a gray fibrous material with small white pellets of varying size, and by your description (can crush to powder), those white fragments are not styrofoam nor do we think this is gypsum board or drywall debris contamination - as you'd be likely to find that uniformly distributed throughout building insulation.
I'm researching the topic a bit more and will add some citations.
Save one or two cubic inches of this insulation (no more) in a clean small-sized freezer-type ziplok bag that you can mail to me for forensic lab examination. Our email is in the page top or bottom CONTACT link - thence I can give you an address. I'm doing a bit of travel so am not always in the lab - we can discuss mailing.I'd like to look at this insulation under the microscope. (No costs are involved for you but postage, and of course I can't promise a thing about an unknown material.)
Is this loose fill Expanded Perlite Pumice building insulation in a Canadian Home?
@John Anderson,
Worth a look
Loose fill Perlite pumice building insulation history & example patents
Followup by John Anderson - This building and insulation are in Nova Scotia in a 1930's home
@InspectApedia Publisher, this is located in Nova Scotia Canada. The house was built in the 30’s.
Thanks for the help on this!Reply by InspectApedia Editor - Nova Scotia has a long history of creative uses of material as building insulation
@John Anderson,
Thanks for that added information.
Nova Scotia has a long history of creative uses of material as building insulation. Early settlers used locally-available natural materials, even grasses (particularly sea grass), and tree bark, and later, wood shavings, or simpler, some folks simply crumpled up newspapers and stuffed them into attic floors and into wall cavities - not that your insulation looks like those materials.
Chopped newsprint "cellulose" insulation began to see wide use in North America in the 1950s, but I don't rule out that someone combined another paper source - not newsprint - and mixed it with perlite or similar insulating materials.
I'm researching further.Special Insulations Produced in Nova Scotia - Seagrass
Identify the kind of insulation under my attic floor: looks like white cotton under a black dirty surface
Hi, wondering if you can help me identify what kind of insulation this might be under the floor of the attic in my 1908 house. It looks like white cotton (underneath the dirt). Thank you!
- On 2023-04-01 by Amy VH -
Reply by InspectApedia Editor - Gray (dirty) Mineral wool insulation
@Amy VH,
That looks like mineral wool insulation. See our article at
ROCK WOOL, MINERAL WOOL BUILDING INSULATION IDENTIFICATION
What's this gray insulation on north-facing walls of a 1950s house?
Could you advise on what insulation this is? Located on internal north facing walls of an 1950s house.
- On 2023-02-19
by Cli -
Reply by InspectApedia Editor - Paper-backed closed-cell polyethylene foam insulation product or polystyrene
@Cli,
It's difficult to say from one photo but that looks as if it 'might' be a paper-backed closed-cell polyethylene foam insulation product.Continuing, zoom in on the photo. I think we might be looking at a thin layer of polystyrene white insulation
...
Continue reading at FOAM SPRAY INSULATION TYPES or select a topic from the closely-related articles below, or see the complete ARTICLE INDEX.
Or see INSULATION IDENTIFICATION GUIDE FAQs - questions & answers posted originally on this page
Or see these
INSULATION IDENTIFICATION GUIDE at InspectApedia.com - online encyclopedia of building & environmental inspection, testing, diagnosis, repair, & problem prevention advice.
Or see this
Or use the SEARCH BOX found below to Ask a Question or Search InspectApedia
Try the search box just below, or if you prefer, post a question or comment in the Comments box below and we will respond promptly.
Search the InspectApedia website
Note: appearance of your Comment below may be delayed: if your comment contains an image, photograph, web link, or text that looks to the software as if it might be a web link, your posting will appear after it has been approved by a moderator. Apologies for the delay.
Only one image can be added per comment but you can post as many comments, and therefore images, as you like.
You will not receive a notification when a response to your question has been posted.
Please bookmark this page to make it easy for you to check back for our response.
Our Comment Box is provided by Countable Web Productions countable.ca
In addition to any citations in the article above, a full list is available on request.