How to specify the size of HVAC ducts & how to inspect duct systems for defects, leaks, damage.
This article explains how to inspect and diagnose trouble with heating or cooling air flow, air ducts, air registers and zone components of heating and air conditioning (HVAC) duct systems.
This diagnostic article describes common defects found in HVAC duct work such as incomplete supply or return ducts, poor choice of location or size for supply and return registers, locating ducts in problem areas, leaks into and corrosion of duct work, leaky duct connections, and special notes on product failures by two manufacturers of flexible duct work.
The article includes important safety warnings about dangerous openings in HVAC duct work.
InspectAPedia tolerates no conflicts of interest. We have no relationship with advertisers, products, or services discussed at this website.
- Daniel Friedman, Publisher/Editor/Author - See WHO ARE WE?
We explain how to find and correct air duct problems such as missing air conditioning cool air supply or return air registers, undersized air conditioning duct openings, improper cooling duct routing, cooling (or heating) air duct corrosion, leaky air duct connections, defective heating or cooling ductwork materials such as Goodman gray flex-duct, some Owens Corning Flex-duct, and asbestos-containing air conditioning or heating duct work.
Air conditioning duct system defects include a remarkably wide range of errors, from failure to supply cool air or failure to even circulate air in the building, to health hazards such as use of asbestos material in or on duct work, to very dangerous conditions such as drawing heating equipment combustion gases into the building cooling (or heating) air.
The master document, of which this is a chapter, describes the inspection of residential air conditioning systems (A/C systems) to inform home buyers, owners, and home inspectors of common cooling system defects. Asbestos in or on HVAC ducts is a possible hazard for which we provide links to a separate document - see "Asbestos HVAC Ducts" at below left.
Below we list some common sources of poor air flow from air conditioning or heating duct systems: check these first before ordering a more costly survey or repair job.
2019/11/14 Charlie said:
Hi My name is Charlie I have a question? .
I'm installing a 3ton with Furnace unit 1200 CFM locating the unit in the middle of the basement doing a extended trunk off each side from what i have looked up I can install 16x8 duct @ 700 CFM with two trunks would give me 1400 CFM. is this correct.
[Click to enlarge any image]
This Q&A were posted originally
Charlie
I'm not a mechanical engineer nor duct sizing expert but indeed there are quite a few duct sizing guidelines we can check out.
The table shown here is adapted from the original guideline provided by Hamilton Home Products cited below.
There are also some simple HVAC air duct sizing and CFM rules of thumb that we provide below on this page .
If your furnace blower capacity is 1200 cfm, that's a capacity measured right at the air handler output plenum. Restrictions in the ductwork such as in diameter or elbows and bends will reduce the effective CFM from that number (as will a dirty blower fan).
Extending two ducts off of the supply plenum in two directions is of course a common practice.
In the duct sizing reference chart shown here, adapted from Hamilton Home Products cited below, I have outlined the chart's 1200 CFM line in yellow to show the recommended duct sizes.
To supply 1200 CFM and sticking to your 8-inch duct size, if your duct is RECTANGULAR then according to our duct chart you'd need an 8" duct that's 26" x 8"
OR if you're using round duct you'd need a 15-inch diameter round duct.
Seems to me you can of course split off the 1200 CFM at the air handler (AHU) into two smaller trunks as long as the total meets or exceeds the original number.
Since 2 X 16x8" ducts is roughly (not exactly) = 1 32 x 8" duct which would be bigger than the 1200 cfm required 26" duct, that looks reasonable to me.
However - and maybe this was just a typo on your part - using supply ducts that are larger than the required minimum will NOT increase the CFM - you said two trunks would give you 1400 CFM;
A more-accurate HVAC duct sizing procedure has to take into account the factors I list below; of course some of these are overlapping and not all apply to every duct system design.
If you want to try an easy DIY class on how to size and layout HVAC ducts I like the Carrier power point presentation by Ray Chow cited below.
HVAC Duct Design Velocities in Feet per Minute - fpm |
|
Component | Recommended FPM |
Supply registers (louvered) | 400 fpm |
Return registers (louvered) | 500 fpm |
Air Filter - Common pleated | 750 fpm |
Air Filter - Bag / Cartridge | 500 fpm |
Air Filter - Electrostatic | 150-350 fpm |
Air Filter - HEPA | 250 fpm |
Across Cooling Coil | 400-500 fpm |
Across Heating Coil | 500 - 1000 fpm |
Round Air Duct Size Table |
|
Air Volume |
Duct Diameter (Inches / mm) |
50 cfm | 5" / 127 mm |
75 | 6 / 152 |
100 | 6 / 152 |
125 | 7 / 178 |
150 | 7 / 178 |
175 | 8 / 203 |
200 | 8 / 203 |
225 | 8 / 203 |
250 | 9 / 229 |
275 | 9 / 229 |
300 | 9 / 229 |
400 | 10 / 254 |
500 | 11 / 279 |
600 | 12 / 305 |
700 | 12 / 305 |
800 | 13 / 330 |
900 | 14 / 356 |
1000 | 14 / 356 |
1100 | 15 / 381 |
1200 | 15 / 381 |
1300 | 16 / 406 |
1400 | 16 / 406 |
1500 | 16 / 406 |
1600 | 17 / 432 |
1700 | 17 / 432 |
1800 | 18 / 203 |
1900 | 18 / 203 |
2000 | 18 / 203 |
...
Rectangular Air Duct |
HVAC |
||
Air Volume CFM |
4" x ??" / mm | 6" x ??" | 8" x ??" |
50 cfm | 4 x 6" / 102 x 152 mm | ||
75 | 4 x 6 / 102 x 152 | ||
100 | 4 x 8 / 102 x 203 | 6 x 6" / 152 x 152mm | |
125 | 4 x 10 / 102 x 254 | 6 x 6 / 152 x 152mm | |
150 | 4 x 10 / 102 x 254 | 6 x 8 / 152 x 203 | |
175 | 4 x 12 / 102 x 305 | 6 x 8 / 152 x 203 | |
200 | 4 x 14 / 102 x 356 | 6 x 8 / 152 x 203 | |
225 | 4 x 16 / 102 x 406 | 6 x 10 / 152 x 254 | |
250 | 4 x 16 / 102 x 406 | 6 x 10 / 152 x 254 | |
275 | 6 x 12 / 152 x 305 | 8 x 8" / 203 x 203mm | |
300 | 6 x 12 / 152 x 305 | 8 x 8 / 203 x 203 | |
400 | 6 x 14 / 152 x 356 | 8 x 10 / 203 x 254 | |
500 | 6 x 18 / 152 x 457 | 8 x 12 / 203 x 305 | |
600 | 6 x 20 / 152 x 508 | 8 x 14 / 203 x 356 | |
700 | 6 x 24 / 152 x 610 | 8 x 16 / 203 x 406 | |
800 | 6 x 26 / 152 x 660 | 8 x 18 / 203 x 457 | |
900 | 6 x 30 / 152 x 762 | 8 x 20 / 203 x 508 | |
1000 | 8 x 22 / 203 x 559 | ||
1100 | 8 x 24 / 203 x 610 | ||
1200 | 8 x 28 / 203 x 711 | ||
1300 | 8 x 28 / 203 x 711 | ||
1400 | 8 x 30 / 203 x 762 |
...
Rectangular Air Duct |
Duct Dimensions " / mm |
|
Air Volume CFM |
10" x ??" / mm x ??mm | 12" x ??" / mm x ??mm |
500 cfm | 10 x 10" / 254 x 254 mm | |
600 | 10 x 12 / 254 x 305 | |
700 | 10 x 12 / 254 x 305 | |
800 | 10 x 14 / 254 x 356 | 12 x 12" / 305 x 305 mm |
900 | 10 x 16 / 254 x 406 | 12 x 12 / 305 x 305 mm |
1000 | 10 x 16 / 254 x 406 | 12 x 14 / 305 x 356 |
1100 | 10 x 18 / 254 x 457 | 12 x 16 / 305 x 406 |
1200 | 10 x 20 / 254 x 508 | 12 x 16 / 305 x 406 |
1300 | 10 x 20 / 254 x 508 | 12 x 18 / 305 x 457 |
1400 | 10 x 22 / 254 x 559 | 12 x 18 / 305 x 457 |
1500 | 10 x 24 / 254 x 610 | 12 x 20 / 305 x 508 |
1600 | 10 x 24 / 254 x 610 | 12 x 20 / 305 x 508 |
1700 | 10 x 28 / 254 x 711 | 12 x 22 / 305 x 559 |
1800 | 10 x 30 / 254 x 762 | 12 x 22 / 305 x 559 |
1900 | 12 x 22 / 305 x 559 | |
2000 | 12 x 24 / 305 x 610 |
Adapted from the following:
Technical note: The D'Arcy-Weisbach equation for pressure and head loss can be used to calculate the actual pressure loss due to friction in a building piping or air duct system.
The Engineering Toolbox provides the D'Arcy-Weisbach formula:
Δp = λ (l / dh) (ρ v2 / 2)
where
Δp = pressure loss (Pa, N/m2),
l = length of duct or pipe (m)
dh = hydraulic diameter (m)
ρ = density (kg/m3).
From Bernoulli's Law we have the following: any change in the air velocity (CFM) will cause a corresponding but inverse change in the static pressure inside the duct system.
"Static pressure" is a theoretical pressure inside of a closed system, while "Velocity pressure" is the force excerted by air moving through or out of a duct system. We find confusion on this topic is similar to normal people expressing as "water pressure" what is more accurately the water flow rate at a tap that would be measured in gpm (gallons per minute).
Ray Chow (2005) points out that the actual total duct system pressure is the sum of static pressure and velocity pressure.
Watch out: But keep in mind that even this apparently accurate calculation of the effect of piping on air pressure and airflow loss will not include the effects of obstructions in the building return air or supply air duct system such as
...
Below you will find questions and answers previously posted on this page at its page bottom reader comment box.
On 2023-04-13 by InspectApedia Editor - find and fix rextrictions in HVAC ductwork
@Gail,
Please do keep me posted - what you find will certainly help other readers.
I'd like to see a photo (one per comment) of the zone dampers in question as well as of any crimps or openings you find in the ductwork.
On 2023-04-13 by Gail
@InspectApedia Editor , Thanks! We'll check that and see what happens.
@Gail,
Correct me if I've misunderstood but it sounds as if your four heating zones are controlled by individual thermostats, each of which operates a zone damper (that you're calling a "gate").
You say you think the forced hot air is forcing the duct damper "open" but that should not happen if the damper is properly secured to the shaft on which it rotates and provided the shaft gears in the zone damper control motor are intact.
If this problem has been there since day one of your heating system duct installation I might suspect that the zone damper isn't properly wired but I suspect you're reporting a "new" problem.
It's possible that inside the duct that keeps receiving hot air the zone damper is not working. An example could be a loss of connection between the actual damper plate inside the ductwork and the shaft that's supposed to turn-it, or the zone damper mechanism or control itself could be damaged.
So a good place to start with the "too hot" room is at its zone control damper. Turn the thermostat for that zone to its highest temperature while another of you watches the zone damper actuator to see what it does.
For the too-cold zone, the damper may be stuck closed so make the same test there.
If the too-cold zone damper is working correctly, look for crimped or open ductwork anywhere in the system.
See details at
ZONE DAMPER CONTROLS
and for Collapsed sections of flex duct block or stop airflow in either supply or return air system -
See DUCT ROUTING & SUPPORT
On 2023-04-13 by Gail
We have an electric forced air furnace, with four zones (originally five). Recently the "office zone" began supplying very little air flow to one room in that zone (keeping it around 65 degrees) while the remaining two rooms plus bath in that zone were above 80 degrees.
Meanwhile, upstairs, we turned off the heat in the bedroom zone, but hot air still blows out the registers. The controller for the bedroom was replaced and the gate indicates it is closed, but hot air still blows out. Hot air is forcing the spring in the gate partially open. Any suggestions?
@Ronald,
I don't think suspending the duct will make much difference as long as its routing is as straight as possible AND it's not kinked, blocked (and is no longer leaking)
Start by assuring a clean air filter is installed
Follow by having the blower fan itself cleaned: I've seen a tremendous improvement in airflow from just those two steps.
On 2022-09-10 by Ronald
@InspectApedia-911, Thank you for the reply. I did crawl through the attic and inspect. the flex duct is laying on the ceiling joists and the canister in the trunk had air leaking from it. I sealed it off before I messaged you, however, I was going to suspend the duct so it is off the joists. If that does not fix the problem what would you recommend next? Thank you.
On 2022-09-09 by InspectApedia-911 (mod)
@Ronald,
I would start with a thorough inspection of the duct itself to make sure that it's not crimped, crushed, torn, or just connected.
On 2022-09-09 by Ronald
I have a bedroom where half the room is cool and the other half is warm. There is an 8-inch flex duct traveling 35 feet in the attic to the room. The room is 320 square feet. Do I need to go up to a 10-inch flex duct? The Heat pump in the home is a 5-ton. Thanks.
On 2022-04-07 by Inspectapedia Com Moderator - check for shorted TT wires
@Stephen semi-pro,
Thanks for the help.
I agree that checking for shorted TT wires is perhaps one of the first things to check.
We detail that at the THERMOSTAT WON'T TURN OFF article we mentioned earlier.
On 2022-04-07 by Stephen semi-pro
@Inspectapedia Com Moderator, RE Lewis: What is the actual temp at the thermostat when it is set at 74 and reads 74 and the HP is constantly running - is it different from 74? Is not enough heat getting to thermostat due to poor return and/or supply? Is 24V red shorted/connected/jumpered to HP so it never shuts off? Weird.
On 2022-02-11 by Inspectapedia Com Moderator
@Lewis,
Check that you're not running the system with a manual FAN ON switch set at the thermostat or at the fan limit switch.
On 2022-02-10 by Lewis
@Inspectapedia Com Moderator, I will be receiving the meter to check the air flow today. However the thermostat is set to 74and it reads that it is 74 in the house. I took some temperature of the registers and they are blowing 92 out and the return is 84. The thermostat never goes up or down and the system never turns off.
I can manually turn off the heat pump on the thermostat. After about 6 hours the temperature will stop dropping. However this is pretty normal for a spray foam insulated house. I have put an external thermometer by the thermostat to see if it’s about the same. The thermostat has been changed already. Any ideas?
On 2022-02-08 by Inspectapedia Com Moderator
@Lewis,
How frustrating;
That sure sounds like a system design or installation problem.
Check the airflow at supply regs and check the obvious like a duct crimp or dirty filter so we don't just embarrass ourselves here.
On 2022-02-08 by Lewis
@Inspectapedia Com Moderator, This is a brand new home. The condenser unit has been changed after 4 months of operation. It is still continuously running. The thermostat was also changed along with the txv. The temperature difference between the vents return is only about 10 degrees. The thermostat shows it to be the same temperature as it is set on. Airflow some rooms are cold and some are warm. I did get the it’s but not sure how to read it. Go figure.
@Lewis,
To address the question of why your heat pump unit runs continuously you need more onsite diagnosis than is offered by assuming the issue is duct length as there can be plenty of other causes.
If the air flow is quite weak at your supply registers and if you've got a new clean proper air filter installed, then start by checking for a crimp or obstruction or blockage in the duct system.
But if air flow has always been quite weak in your home, then yes there could be a duct design or layout defect.
But IMO, I'd want to rule out the easy and other causes of trouble before getting into a duct design and certainly well before trying to calculate duct lengths.
continuing:
If we GUESS that your unit runs continuously because the thermostat is never satisfied, you'd start by checking the easiest and most obvious causes (such as a dirty air filter) - a good place to start that diagnosis is
THERMOSTAT WON'T TURN OFF
also
See OPERATING TEMPERATURES HVAC
also see
CONTROLS & SWITCHES, A/C - HEAT PUMP
If the HVAC compressor motor will stop but the compressor / condenser fan is not working properly,
see
FAN, COMPRESSOR / CONDENSER UNIT
On 2022-02-08 by Lewis
I have a manual D of my hvac installation. It shows the total effective length of the ducts to be 144 ft. When I add the length of all the ducts together it shows I have 264 ft of ducts. The issue is the condenser for the heat pump runs continuously.
I have many questions like how does a 5 inch flexible duct 21.1 feet long put out 121 can? How does a 32.6 ft 7 inch flexible duct put out 184 cfm. Any help would be appreciated.
On 2020-01-07 - by (mod) -
Yes, I agree, Richard.
On 2020-01-07 by Richard Hartill
Thanks for your comments. It seems to me in order to balance the system they would need to add a main return trunk with dampers at the plenum to separate the upstairs and basement air the same way they did for the supply.
Then balance the return to the supply.
Does that seem correct?
On 2020-01-07 1 - by (mod) -
It sounds to me as if the basement heating air duct system is not properly designed.
You need a balance between Supply Air and Return air.
Elsewhere in this article series you'll read about return mistakes that are dangerous, such as taking the return air from a location to close to the heater and risking drawing in combustion gases or interfering with heater operation. So be sure you don't do that.
But you do need a balance of supply and return.
On 2020-01-07 by Richard Hartill
That's correct. When the heat is on in the basement there are a total of 7 supply's feeding hot air into the basement. There are only two 10" returns and they feed into the existing main return so air is being pulled from all the returns (2 10" down and 5 larger upstairs).
it seems that there is nowhere else for the air to go but out that door. I'm not so sure it's being pushed up and out or sucked up by the five larger returns upstairs. We also have a radon mitigation system and if the heating system is causing a negative pressure in the basement it might affect its operation.
On 2020-01-06 by (mod) - issues with warm air heat heat after adding heating zone for the basement
Let me get this right, Richard.
When you open the basement door are you feeling air rush OUT of the basement or INTO it?
On 2020-01-06 by Richard Hartill
I have a two stage gas hot air furnace (80,000 BTU) with a multi speed motor. The house is one level 2,200 sq. ft. with a full basement. I had no issues with the heat until I had a HVAC zone added to the basement.
They ran a 12" reduced to 10"towards both ends supply with six 6" drops and one 5" drop. They installed three electric controlled dampers on the supply trunk and a Honeywell control board. Nice work neat and clean.
The problem ( I think? ) is they cut two 10" returns in to the existing return trunk and put grills on them. Now when the heat in the basement goes on air is being pulled from those two returns plus the five much larger returns upstairs.
When you open the basement door your hit with a rush of cooler air (because we keep the heat lower down there).
It will keep the door open and if I push it closed air whistles under and around it. What do you think of this and if you think it's wrong what should I tell them to do to fix it. If you don't want to answer on this web site you can email me at rhartill62@gmail.com. Thanks, Rich
On 2019-03-29 - by (mod) -
Eli
Before adding booster fans or return or supply air ducts and registers let's be sure we have properly diagnosed the poor air flow problem.
Where is the air handler?
An attic air handler on a three floor house will have a devil of a time blowing warm air (for heat) down to the lower two floors,
while a basement or crawl space air handler will have a hard time blowing cool air up three floors in a home.
If there is inadequate return air volume then neither air handler is going to work very well..
If the air handler blower is dirty or if ducts are crimped etc. then air flow will be horrible.
See details at AIR FLOW IMPROVEMENT, HVAC https://inspectapedia.com/aircond/Duct_Air_Flow.php
On 2018-07-08 by Eli
Hi! Have a problem in the house — the cold/warm air is coming out only on the 3rd floor, and just barely from 1st and 2nd. The most reasonable and expected thing to do is, quite probably, balancing.
But, I’m considering other problems, that may have been overlooked by the experts that came. First of all, I’m concerned that there is only one air return register, on the third floor, just between two bedrooms and near the stairs.
Could this be a bigger factor than the lack of proper in-duct balancing? Next, could installing air boosters for each floor be a better and more stable option in such case?
Boosters would essentially set the pressure difference between duct and room, and so mirror the pressure between floors in the ductwork, making a sort of auto-balancing, is this correct? Any other options I missed? Thanks.
On 2013-01-09 by (mod) - how to inspect inaccessible HVAC ducts
Basil,
You will want to find an air conditioning service company or duct cleaning company who have a duct inspection camera that can be inserted into the ductwork.
On 2013-01-09 by basil
i want to make inspection for ducts(leakage test) but all duct is hidden above the decorative sealing i cant see the duct..how can i make smoke test or any other way???
On 2012-10-08 - by (mod) - stinky air coming out of air supply registers
Mike, i agree with your one of investigation. check at the air handler and return air inlet, also some of the supply ducts deliver air with your blower unit off. Scan inaccessible ductwork via camera.
On 2012-10-08 by Mike
I rent a unit in an old industrial building that as converted to condos in 2005. All the interior systems and finishes were new with the conversion, the building was gutted. Each unit has its own HVAC unit.
Our unit's central air conditioner vents air into our unit that has obviously come from somewhere else - it's full of second-hand cigarette smoke and cooking odors. Sometimes it smells like someone is smoking a cigarette in the same room.
This stinky used air comes in even when the fans are off, but much more so when the unit is AC unit is running.
The building has a common vent that sucks air out of the bathrooms. It's always on and is rather strong.
Does it sound like a return air vent leak?
The only thing I can figure is that both the intake in our unit is leaky and the common vent (which would be sucking air out of the other condos, including the cigarette smoke) is also leaking, letting our AC pull in the exhaust from the common vent. I think this would account for the bad air coming in when the AC fans are off.
I need to have a contractor come take a look, but I have to educate the landlord so he understands that this is both plausible and serious before he'll authorize it.
Thanks
On 2012-10-07 by Anonymous
will air condition make your eyes water if so whu
On 2012-10-07 - by (mod) - soot coming out of the duct registers
Check first for unsafe conditions like oil burner or gas burner sooting, a leaky heat exchanger, or a burning up wire, blower fan belt, etc.
Then I'd start tracking down the dirt or soot source at the return air register, and look at general house dust levels. So far we don't even know if it's really soot.
On 2012-10-05 by Harley
I get a phone call from My Dad and he is telling me they have soot coming out of all there registers and asked if it could be a motor problem well I already know the answer to that since I am a union industrial electrician he told me he changes the filters every 3 weeks so I am wondering why do the have soot coming out of the registers and will not come clean
they thought it was a fridge problem so they replaced the fridge but the problem has gotten worse and isnt just at the fridge anymore I surely am no A.c. guy but I am thinking they have a problem with filters and lots of nasty dirt in the A.c. handler so before I drive almost 2 hours to there home in Arizona
I would like to have a fairly good idea what I need to be looking for oh and talking to my Mom today she has been instructed to tell my Dad to stop spraying the filters with Pledge since he was told it helps collect more dirt being they literally live in the middle of no where in the desert 18 miles to the closest town!
On 2012-07-26 - by (mod) - what if the air register has no operable levers or controls over air-flow?
Tanner, if the "vent" has no operable louvers to open and shut it then indeed it could be a return air register. Bur return ducts should be under negative pressure - air moving in not out of the register.
First map out the duct system to see what is installed.
Next look for a misrouted or improperly connected duct - it would be very unusual for air movement through a return duct system to cause one of it's branches to blow out instead.
Any mistake where a small add on return duct was connected, say right atop and ahead of the cooling coil would however cause the problem you describe.
More common would be a cool air supply duct that is routed through a hot space and perhaps has lost its insulation.
On 2012-07-26 by Anonymous
The vent looks different than the return and cold air vents I think the suction of the return is causing it to draft hot air what could cause this?
On 2012-07-26 by Tanner b in SC
I have central air and a clean filter all the vents are blowing cold air. The problem is there is a vent above the thermostats and air return that is blowing out hot air when ever the air handler or fan is on. This is keeping the temp too high for the ac to turn off
...
Continue reading at AIR FILTERS for HVAC SYSTEMS or select a topic from the closely-related articles below, or see the complete ARTICLE INDEX.
Or see DUCT SYSTEM & DUCT DEFECT FAQs - questions & answers about air duct problems posted originally at the end of this page
Or see these
DUCT SYSTEM DESIGN SIZE & DEFECTS at InspectApedia.com - online encyclopedia of building & environmental inspection, testing, diagnosis, repair, & problem prevention advice.
Or see this
Or use the SEARCH BOX found below to Ask a Question or Search InspectApedia
Try the search box just below, or if you prefer, post a question or comment in the Comments box below and we will respond promptly.
Search the InspectApedia website
Note: appearance of your Comment below may be delayed: if your comment contains an image, photograph, web link, or text that looks to the software as if it might be a web link, your posting will appear after it has been approved by a moderator. Apologies for the delay.
Only one image can be added per comment but you can post as many comments, and therefore images, as you like.
You will not receive a notification when a response to your question has been posted.
Please bookmark this page to make it easy for you to check back for our response.
IF above you see "Comment Form is loading comments..." then COMMENT BOX - countable.ca / bawkbox.com IS NOT WORKING.
In any case you are welcome to send an email directly to us at InspectApedia.com at editor@inspectApedia.com
We'll reply to you directly. Please help us help you by noting, in your email, the URL of the InspectApedia page where you wanted to comment.
In addition to any citations in the article above, a full list is available on request.