InspectAPedia®   -   Search InspectApedia

Photograph of a Drager hand pump used to measure carbon dioxide levels in the environment. Guide to Toxic Gas Measurement Instruments & Gas Detector Tubes for Indoor Gas Level Tests

Types of test instruments for detecting or measuring the level of toxic or dangerous gases in buildings:

This document discusses tools and methods used to test for the level of toxic and other gases in buildings and in outdoors. In related documents we give references and explanation regarding toxicity of several of the most common indoor gases, based on literature search and obtained from the U.S. government and expert sources.

This text may assist readers in understanding these topics. However it should by no means be considered exhaustive. Seek prompt advice from your doctor or health/safety experts if you have any reason to be concerned about exposure to toxic gases.

InspectAPedia tolerates no conflicts of interest. We have no relationship with advertisers, products, or services discussed at this website.

- Daniel Friedman, Publisher/Editor/Author - See WHO ARE WE?

Tools and methods for detecting or measuring the level of gases in buildings or outdoors

TIF 8800 combustible gas analyzer checking a furnace draft hood for spillage (C) Daniel FriedmanWhile other methods are available for gas detection in or around buildings, (such as eletronic gas detection equipment giving gas level readings in ppm and vacuum canisters for lab analysis) two common methods used by building inspectors and trades people for sensitive detection of problem gases in buildings are broad spectrum combustible gas analyzers such as

the TIF 8800 GAS DETECTOR,

and specific gas analyzers for halogens such as

the TIF 5000 GAS DETECTOR, and calibrated gas pumps using colorimetric gas detection tubes such as by Dräger discussed here.

[Click to enlarge any image]

The companies that provide pump and tube gas detection systems produce a very wide range of very sensitive calibrated gas detection tubes, all of which will work just fine with a single, volume-calibrated pump that draws the air or gas sample through the tube provided you use a gas detection tube that was properly selected for the gas and concentration range being measured and that the tube is compatible with the pump being used. .

Color changes and a scale marked on the gas detection tube give a nearly instant reading of the target gas level in the area tested.

Many other combustible gas analyzers or carbon monxide detection instruments are currently available and are given at the end of this article.

Watch out: while a gas detection instrument may itself be highly sensitive and very accurate, variations in building condtions can cause a gas to be present at times and below the limit of detection at other times.

Therefore when a gas detection test gives negative results (no gas detected) you should not rely on that result alone if there is a risk of unsafe conditions. For example

see CARBON MONOXIDE - CO poisoning.

Toxic or Hazardous Gas Detection using Calibrated Pump and Gas Detection Tubes

TIF 5000 refrigerant gas leak detector for halogensThe photograph at the top of this page shows a Sensidyne gas detection hand pump which currently (2008) uses KitagawaTM gas colorimetric gas detection tubes to measure the level of gases in a building. Here we were checking the level of carbon monoxide (CO) at a heating system.

Above is the TIF 8800 GAS DETECTOR in use at a gas furnace draft hood, and at left is

the TIF 5000 GAS DETECTOR used for refrigerant gas detection including detection of refrigerant gas as a tracer gas if used to check for heat exchanger leaks - something no longer recommended nor permitted where discharge of refrigerants to the environment is a possibility.

We like the Sensidyne gas pump method because one or two strokes can produce an accurate quantitative measurement of the level of gas in the area with minimum manipulation of the pump by the inspector.

However indoor air quality investigators and others having need to measure concentrations of various gases in indoor or outdoor air also make very frequent use of the Draeger gas pump and Drager colorimetric gas detection tubes which we describe below, or Gastec Gas Sampling Pumps using gas detection tubes sold by GasTecTM.

Watch out: It is critical that the proper pump and gas detection tube combination be used as gas detection tubes are calibrated to work with particular gas pumps. Using the wrong pump or gas detection tube risks making inaccurate gas measurements - an error which could be fatal in some circumstances.

All of these gas detection systems use a similar approach for measuring the level of gases in a building.

The Drager system uses a rubber bellows pump which requires more pump strokes than the Sensidyne pump (shown at the top of this page) and may provide a wider range of detector tubes and gas sampling approaches.

Draeger (Dräger) provides a wide rage of gas detection tubes used with a simple hand pump - shown below.

Drager accuro gas detector for use with colorimetric gas detection tubes described here (C) Daniel Friedman at InspectApedia.com

Draeger also provides portable or wearable monitoring devices for firefighter safety such as the Dräger X-pid® 8500 that measures hazardous toxic substances such Acrolein, Benzene, Butadiene, Dichloroethylene, Ethyl benzene, Ethylene oxide, Hexane, Isobutylene, Propylene oxide, Styrene, Tetrachloroethylene, Toluene, Trichloroethylene, Vinyl chloride, Xylene,and other VOCs,

or the Dräger X-am® 8000 that for fire clearance measurement, measures up to seven gases such as CO2, O2, CO, HC, H2, H2S, NO, NO2, SO2, PH3, HCN, NH3, Amine, Odorants, Ozone,, including toxic, flammable gases and vapors, and oxygen all at once.

For use by firefighters and fire investigators, and for Civil Defense workers, Draeger also provides a special manifold for the company's gas detector hand pump.

See details at FIRE OFF-GASSING HAZARD DETECTION

Warning: About Selecting the Proper Gas Detection Tube

Gas Tube and Gas Pump Must be Compatible? Some authors report some gas detection tube interchangeability.

Gas tube testing pump schematic (C) Daniel FriedmanColorimeteric gas detection tubes produced by different manufacturers are not necessarily interchangeable among gas detection pumps

Be sure that the gas detection tube you are using is one recommended for use with your gas detection pump - check both the gas detection pump manufacturer's instructions and the gas detection tube manufacturer's specifications.

Watch out: we were informed in May 2008 by Nextteq GastecTM detection tube distributor in the U.S., Gastec tubes that are currently available are not intended for use on the SensidyneTM gas detection pump.

At one point in time, Sensidyne had the contract for Gastec tubes and lost it due to rebranding. 

The tubes they sell now are Kitagawa tubes, not Gastec. 

We don't want to confuse anyone out there that they can use a Gastec tube with the Sensidyne pump. 

The Gastec tubes are not calibrated to work with a Sensidyne pump and therefore, the reading could be incorrect and prove fatal in some cases.

Really? Haag (2001) stirred a hornets' nest of marketing and technical issues, claims, counter-claims when he reported:

Both pump flow profiles and test gas measurements demonstrate that three piston hand pumps in common use (RAE Systems LP-1200, Sensidyne/Gastec GV/100, and Matheson-Kitagawa 8014-400A) are fully interchangeable.

Two bellows pumps (Draeger Accuro and MSA Kwik-Draw) also are interchangeable with each other.

Mixing of bellows and piston systems is often possible, but there are enough exceptions to conclude that such practice should be discouraged because it can lead to inaccurate readings and thus potentially dangerous overexposures.

For an example of a family of gas detection instruments & pumps capable of detecting an enormous range of specific gases and providing a measurement of gas concentration in air including pumps that use a colorimetric gas detection tube

see Dräger GAS DETECTORS.

There you will note that Hirsh (2001) vigorously objected to Haag's report, calling it marketing propaganda, and noted that Draeger as well as various agencies do not support interchangeability of gas detection tubes.

Gas Tube Must Be Properly Sensitive to the Gases Being Investigated

Bulb type gas detector tube pump (C) InspectApedia Watch out: Be sure to select gas detection tubes designed to detect the proper gases being screened in a building, and also to select the gas detector tube which is calibrated to detect gases at the proper level of concern.

The detection of many gases is supported at varying levels of sensitivity.

Selecting a tube which is not sensitive enough may result in failing to detect the presence of the target gas.

Selection of a gas detection tube which is too sensitive may result in inability to accurately detect the actual level of gas which is present since the tube will become saturated before the actual gas level has been recorded.

Watch out: in our OPINION using a simple bulb-type pump with a gas detector tube (illustration above) as has been suggested in some older gas detection articles is a bad idea: if one cannot be confident that each depression of the bulb produces an accrate and known gas volume the quantitative measurement of gas concentrations given by the detector tube would be simply nonsense.

Gas Detection Instrument Sources: Carbon Monoxide, Combustion Gases, Refrigerants, Gas Detectors

Draeger Simultatntest Gas Detetor Tubes set I (C) Inspectapedia.comPhoto: Draeger's gas detection tube set Simultantest-Set I, # 8101735, inorganic gases released during fires, detects hydrochloric acid, hydrocyanic acid, carbon monoxide, ammonia, and nitrogen dioxide.

[Click to enlarge any image]

UEI CO Detector Instrument Model CO71A sold by Grainger.com and other suppliers (at) InspectApedia.com

Shown: UEi's Carbon Monoxide DetectorShown: UEi's Carbon Monoxide DetectorShown: UEi's Carbon Monoxide Detector

Reader Question: what factors affect the accuracy of gas detection instruments & methods?

I am sending this mail on behalf of [an environmental testing company in] Thessaloniki, Greece. We have recently acquired a gas detector.

I would like to ask you if you could send us any information regarding any possible factors that may affect and how, the accuracy of the measurement (indoor and outdoor) with the detector (environmental or technical).

This would help us a lot with the proper understanding and use of the detector. - A.M. Thessaloniki Greece 9/14/2012

Reply:

Watch out: AM - making a mistake in using any gas detection method, including pump selection, detector tube selection, and even more complicated, the choice of sampling time, location, and methodology can produce results that vary signfiicantly.

Making a mistake risks illness or death for building occupants if gas detection testing and test result interpretation, explanation, and reporting are not conducted accurately.

You will find additional depth and detail in articles at our website.

That said I offer these comments:

At the end of this page there is a list of articles in which we discuss the use of gas testing instruments.

Watch out: Particularly, take note of GAS DETECTOR WARNINGS

Certainly there are different classes of gas detection instrument problems and mistakes depending on variables such as

I found many years ago that there are problems with both false positives (detecting a "problem" level of a gas) and false negatives (missing an existing problem). 

An example of false positives is using the TIF8800 - which will respond to your breath, or a flatulent bystander (no joke, I've encountered this).

After making a few conference presentations on CO detection devices we saw a surge in inspectors using them - it was horrible. What developed was the fellows stopped looking at the building, stopped thinking, and just plopped an instrument somewhere to take a reading - reporting the results and disclaiming any further responsibility.

I would start with a clear definition of the problem: what are we looking for, why, and thus where and how might a gas contaminant originate and where it might be found. I'd match the instrument, test, methodology to the problem.

I'd also check with the maufacturer and the instrument's specifications against the problem being studied.

And I have had very good experience calling both the equipment manufacturers and, in the case of specific gas tests using colorimetric gas detection tubes or other specialized instruments, I've been grateful to the technical support staff at the manufacturers: people who've been willing to help assure that the proper test is selected for the problem at hand.

Watch out: making a mistake can be dangerous or fatal for building occupants.

I think that it's for this reason that our local fire department, called to a home where there is a complaint of carbon monoxide detector alarm sounds, is reluctant to delcare a building "safe" just because their instrument detects nothing at the time of their visit. The experienced investigators know that many variables can cause the presence of a gas to wax and wane in detectability in and around a building.

Ultimately, in most cases of general field investigation for the detection of toxic or harmful gases, I would trust the results of gas detection instruments only if the instrument detects a problem; I would not fully trust a negative result.

Perhaps if you can tell me more of what you are up-to and what instrument you're talking about we could get more specific

Reader follow-up:

Thank you very much for your email. This really helps us in the proper understanding of any factors that may occur during a measurement and can change its results.

Moreover we will be properly prepared to face the problems mentioned.

Our company Envia Environmental Solutions is specialized for some years, as you can see from our website (www.envia.gr) in the deodorization of industrial areas from malodorous gases.

For this purpose and recently acquired the Eagle 2 multi gas detector from RKI to help us better identify malodorous pollutants and subsequently deal with them with the use of our products.

It can detect CO, O2, NH3, CH4, H2S and VOCs and we wanted to find out which environmental or technical factors can affect the accuracy of its measuring capability, because our company is new in this field. I will keep you informed about the instruments' performance. - A.M. Thessaloniki tech.maragoulidis@envia.gr

Reply:

Thanks for the added information; you'll see at my website that I've had a long interests in and some experience in odor source tracking and remediation.

In my experience, detecting a specific gas MIGHT, SOMETIMES point to a correctable source, particularly in industrial applications where there is more likely to be a recognizable and specific gas or chemical source.

But very often we get an odor complaint whose nature is uncertain, whose chemistry is a complex of molecules not a single specific chemical or gas (excepting methane and sewer gas problems), and whose location is mysterious to the building occupants.

Or even after a known source and event there may remain odors lingering that have been absorbed by building materials but the occupants don't know which materials are harboring the odor.

An example is the over-dose of ozone during a misguided odor remediation attempt; some building materials become oxidized - but which are the prime offenders?

Performing an in-air gas test is not going to give much help in remediation guidance in such cases.

Instead, a thoughtful review of building history along with our smell patch test approach can point to the odor source and the odor remedy.

Our home base for this topic is at ODORS GASES SMELLS, DIAGNOSIS & CURE


...

Continue reading  at GAS EXPOSURE LIMITS & STANDARDS or select a topic from the closely-related articles below, or see the complete ARTICLE INDEX.

Or see To convert between % and ppm

Or see these

Recommended Articles

Suggested citation for this web page

GAS DETECTION INSTRUMENTS at InspectApedia.com - online encyclopedia of building & environmental inspection, testing, diagnosis, repair, & problem prevention advice.


Or see this

INDEX to RELATED ARTICLES: ARTICLE INDEX to GAS HAZARDS in BUILDINGS

Or use the SEARCH BOX found below to Ask a Question or Search InspectApedia

Ask a Question or Search InspectApedia

Questions & answers or comments about how to detect & measure hazardous gases in buildings.

Try the search box just below, or if you prefer, post a question or comment in the Comments box below and we will respond promptly.

Search the InspectApedia website

Note: appearance of your Comment below may be delayed: if your comment contains an image, photograph, web link, or text that looks to the software as if it might be a web link, your posting will appear after it has been approved by a moderator. Apologies for the delay.

Only one image can be added per comment but you can post as many comments, and therefore images, as you like.
You will not receive a notification when a response to your question has been posted.
Please bookmark this page to make it easy for you to check back for our response.
Our Comment Box is provided by Countable Web Productions countable.ca

Comment Form is loading comments...

Citations & References

In addition to any citations in the article above, a full list is available on request.


ADVERTISEMENT