Antique & modern Nails, including wood treenails, hand-wrought nails, cut nails, wire nails, are compared and described here.
We give a chronology: the history of nails, types & methods of fabrication, and we describe antique and modern cut nails focusing on tree nails, wrought nails, and cut nails used in wood frame construction or interior finishing or carpentry work.
We include useful dates for the manufacture of different nail types along with supporting research for various countries from Australia and the U.K. to the U.S. to New Zealand.
The history, number and types of nails is both interesting and enormous, even if we confine our discussion to just those used in the construction of buildings. We continue to add examples and photographs here and welcome readers to CONTACT US with contributions or suggestions.
This article series describes and illustrates antique & modern hardware: door knobs, latches, hinges, window latches, hardware, nails & screws can help determine a building's age by noting how those parts were fabricated: by hand, by machine, by later generations of machine.
The author worked as a restoration contractor for four decades and is currently an environmental inspector and forensic microscopist. He has inspected, constructed, repaired, buildings since the 1970s
InspectAPedia tolerates no conflicts of interest. We have no relationship with advertisers, products, or services discussed at this website.
- Daniel Friedman, Publisher/Editor/Author - See WHO ARE WE?
As a carpenter’s nails are divided into wrought nails and cut nails; so mankind may be similarly divided. Little Flask was one of the wrought ones; made to clinch tight and last long. - Herman Melville, Moby Dick.
An examination of nails and fasteners and other building hardware is a complimentary effort useful in determining the age of a building and its components.
Photo: a hand wrought spike. This iron spike., detailed further below, was hand-made in the Northeastern U.S. at least before 1800 but could be still earlier.
A close observation of the type of fasteners used in a building is one of the most popular means of estimating its age.
The three types of nails found in North American construction include hand wrought nails, machine cut nails, modern round "wire" nails.
Nelson (NPS) and other nail chronologists point out, however that a wealth other details can describe the date of production and use of each of those three general nail types.
In turn, nail details can establish the time of original construction of a building and the time of modifications to the structure.
In addition to nails, building material, wood saw cut marks, and other hardware details can further assist in determining building age.
To provide a chronology of the production and types of nails we first describe wooden nails or "tree nails" followed by a chronological list of useful dates for iron nails.
...
At AGE of a BUILDING, HOW to DETERMINE we note the following:
Post and beam construction (1700 - est. in North America): (timber framing) uses horizontal and vertical timbers that are connected (joined) using mortise and tenon joints pinned with wood pegs (treenails).
Timber frame construction initially used hand hewn beams, later manually or mechanically sawn beams cut by a pit saw. Later timber frame beams were sawn in mills using circular saws.
Timber framing using post and beam construction with mortise and tenon joint connections was used in Europe for at least 500 years before it was first employed in North America.
In our photo you can see the round sawn-off peg that secured the tenon of the lower vertical post into the mortise that had been cut into the horizontal beam.
The posts and beams were cut to size, mortises and tenons were cut, and the builders marked the corresponding joint components with numbers or letters - in my photo you can see the
I I I I
and
_
_
_
_
stamped into both the vertical post and horizontal beam to aid in assembly.
Below you can see the Treenail joining two rafters at the ridge of this 1790 home near Poughkeepsie New York.
By 1650 a typical timber frame building used multiple bents and girt beams, may have been more than one story tall, and included an exterior made of horsehair-reinforced cement stuccoed over hand-split lath.
More examples of uses of wooden pegs or treenails are at
...
Photo: sprites, small headless hand-wrought nails, discussed in more detail
at NAILS & HARDWARE, AGE FAQs.
Adapting from various sources including Nelson's article cited below we give a rough chronology of types and uses of nails, focusing on North America but including other earlier nail production and use as well.
The Mansfield, Massachusetts Tremont Nail company's historical notes (cited below) indicate that nails have been made (by hand) dating back to 300 B.C.
The denomination of nail sizes based on the price per 100 nails (e.g. ten penny nails or 10d nails) dates from the 1400s.
In medieval England nails were made
into a great variety of special shapes
and sizes and sold by the hundred, e.g.,
8d (pence) per 100 nails.
From this
practice developed the classification of
nail sizes according to their price per
hundred, a system which seems to have
been established by the fifteenth century.
After that time nails slowly became standardized by size rather than
price.
In 1471 for example, "fippenynayl" were only 4d per 100.
In 1477
"xpenynayll" were only 8d per 100; and
in 1494 "sixpenynayle" were 5d per 100. (Nelson NPS)
The 1500s saw the first nail producing machines - First Nail Making Machines - 1590 Slitting Mills
The roots of producing nails by machine date from 1590.
Hand wrought nails were used for construction and later more for decoration.
The scarcity of nails in colonial Virginia was reflected in a statute enacted in 1645 to prohibit settlers from burning down old buildings for their nails.
Some nails were made
in the colonies in the seventeenth and
eighteenth centuries, but despite this
local production very large quantities of
nails were imported during the same
period. (Nelson NPS)
Details are at NAILS, HAND WROUGHT
Although traditional Tahitian culture did not sanction extramarital sexual relations, within 48 hours of Wallis's arrival, Tahitian husbands and fathers were encouraging their wives and daughters to swim out to the Dolphin and offer the sailors sex in exchange for iron nails.
Aware of the brisk trade in iron, later explorers such as Captain James Cook brought supplies of nails and hoop iron with them to barter for freshwater, fish, pork, and vegetables.
Cook's visits [to Tahiti] in April 1769, August 1773, and August 1777 only heightened the islanders' desire for iron and other western goods. (Denver, 2013 Tahiti, p. 682-683).
For more on the history of nails used as barter and in trade see
The colonists shifted to local production of nails and nail import from England was reduced or ceased altogether.
...
1779 - 1780 Hand-Operated nail cutting machines.
Ezekial Reed's 1779 Tack Machine,
(illustrated above, Phillips-1993) the first machine-made tacks,was operated by a foot treadle and was able to produce up to 3,000 tacks a day. Wedge-shaped iron blanks were cut by shears from a loop of strip hoop (such as used to construct wooden barrels).
The iron blank was placed tip-down in the jaws of the tack machine with the top protruding enough to be flattened by a hammer to form a head.
1788 - Adam Rogers machine to cut nails from iron hoops
1772 - 1820: In North America early machine cut nails
Dating from 1590 in England, as the earliest report of nail production, the earliest reported cut nails in America are reported to have been cut, essentially by-hand, by Darrow in 1772 (Federal Writers Project 2013) with other authors crediting the Wilkinson brothers somewhat later, ca. 1783 (Benedict 1883).
Nelson notes the first generation of cut nail manufacturing involved cutting all nails from common sides with heads hammered on as a separate production step.
The first nail making machines in North America appeared during the late 1700's - earlier than one might have guessed.
The slitting mill, introduced to England in 1590, simplified the production of nail rods, but the real first efforts to merchandise the nail-making process itself occurred between 1790 and 1820, initially in the United States and England, when various machines were invented to automate and speed up the process of making nails from bars of wrought iron.
Above are nails used to secure accordion lath - a plaster base found in a rural U.S. post-and-beam home in Wyoming County, New York.
These two nails are from different machines.
Notice that the upper one has a rounded head. A closer look might show that the nail shank is constricted and rounded just below the head: marks from the vise that gripped the nail during the head-forming step.
The head on the lower nail is more-irregular.
More about the accordion wood lath in this building and our estimate of the building age are
1789 - U.S. Congress sets duty on imported nails
1790 - U.S. Congress passes first U.S. Patent Act - the second of two steps that encouraged development of nail making machines in North America.
1792 - Samuel Rogers (nephew of Adam Rogers) - expanded the hand-operated machine-cut nail operation.
These nails have shanks with two tapering and the other two parallel sides, cutting die burrs appearing on diagonally-opposite edges. (Phillips 1993). The cross-section of the nail shank is a "skewed rectangle" and the nail tips are rounded. Heads on these nails were hand-formed as a "T" or as a rose-faceted head.
1794 - Perkins Nail Cutting Machine. Jacob Perkins, inventor of a water-powered nail-cutting machine, began producing machine-made cut nails in 1794 and in 1795 received the first U.S. nail-cutting machine patent. (Phillips 1993)
Perkins' machine, powered by water rather than by hand would have been capable of producing a greater quantity of nails per day.
1798 - Read Nail Cutting Machine. Nathan Read produced cut nails at their Salem Iron Factory beginning in 1798.
Details about both of these inventors, their nail making machinery, and nail properties are in our separate guide to cut nails at
NAIL ID & AGE: CUT NAILS - photos of types of cut nails and details about determining their age where we describe early nail-making machines in North America and include English and U.S. patents for such equipment.
Our first illustration shows a skewed-shank machine-cut clapboard nail.
In our second illustration, (both adapted from Phillips 1993) note the rounded and narrowed shank just under the head as deformed when gripped in the machine vise to form the head (red arrow) and the irregular-shaped head (blue arrow) and also the rounded nail tips on both of these early machine-made nails.
...
By some sources nails made completely by machine, including the nail head, appeared as sprigs and brads as early as 1805, and continue in use to the present.
(Nelson US NPS cited below.)
Really? Phillips (1993) reports that actually cut nails made entirely by machine are credited to Jacob Perkins- cited above.
Thomas Blanchard was born on June 24th,
1788, in Sutton, Massachusetts, near
Worcester. His first invention was a tack making
machine which he invented at age
eighteen and perfected over the next six
years.
This made production of tacks,
which Thomas and his brother had been
previously engaged in making, easier and
more efficient at a rate of five-hundred
per minute. - U.S. NPS cited below.
Illustration above: properties of early machine-headed cut nails, - US NPS, Lee Nelson (cited below).
Photo above: early machine cut nail photo, courtesy of reader J - 2020/05/23
[Click to enlarge any image]
I was recently repairing an old dresser I had gotten from a thrift store and found some very old looking square nails, which led me here.
They appear to be early machine cut nails based on your photos. Is my assessment correct?
The observation that your nail is irregularly tapered from below the head, getting wider, then narrowing again, suggests that it's an early machine-cut nail, perhaps roughly between 1815 - 1839 according to Nelson in our references.
NAIL ID & AGE: HAND FORGED NAILS
In the article above and also again at NAILS HAND-WROUGHT & REPRODUCTIONS we note from Nelson's research that ...
If your cut nail is irregular in shank width and has the "A" type side burrs it's likely to have been made before the late 1830s.
Above and below: photos of Dan Nelson's early machine-made nail discussed just below.
2020/04/20 Dan Nelson said:
Hi,
I found this nail while metal detecting an old hayfield in northern Vermont.
The head is round.
The first quarter inch or so of the shank from the head is round-oval.
From there to the point, the nail is very square and tapered.
I do not understand why there are fins on the shank directly below the head. I have found coins I the area as far back as 1787.
I would like to be able to know the rough age of this nail. Thank you.
Dan,
Thank you for the helpful photos of your antique nail. My estimate of the age of your nail is 1830 or a bit older, with an "earliest" date of 1815.
As you are a Nelson, perhaps you will enjoy this companion article:
At NAILS & HARDWARE, AGE RESEARCH
On that page I cite Lee Nelson:
Looking carefully at the irregular-round nail head in your photo and the pinch marks just below the nail head, the earliest we could date this nail might be 1815-1830,
or in my OPINION, probably a bit later, as late as 1850. I think some early nail making machinery often had a longer life than ascribed by Nelson. In some communities, old nail making machine may have, for a time, continued in production alongside later, more-sophisticated machines producing more-rounded and more-uniform nails.
Made in the U.S. in the East, this is an early machine-made nail characterized, per Nelson, by its irregular-round head and the combination of a rounded shank and pinch marks from the nail heading clamp, transitioning to a rectangular shank for the remainder of the nail.
Your nail is large enough that it would not have been later modified (by hammering the head) to convert to a "finishing nail" that could be countersunk. Instead this 3 1/2" long nail would have been used as a structural connector.
In the U.S. the earliest manufactured nails (1790-1830) were operated by hand, later by water mills and still later by steam engines.
Because the rounded upper nail shank looks regular I suspect this is one of the later members of "Early Machine Headed Cut Nails" nails, 1830 - 1850 described by your namesake.
Nelson points out that these early machine-made nails were more readily available than machine-made finishing nails, and that they were often irregular in both length and diameter or width - something you cannot see when we have just one nail but that we might see if we were examining multiple nails from an old New England building.
A close look at the rectangular sides of the nail shank may show the remains of a long burr along the shank characteristic of early cut nails. The burr remains on the side of the nail that was cut from a flat iron plate that was opposite the descending shear blade.
Tapering was produced by "wiggling" the iron plate side to side as the shear descended to cut individual nails.
The irregular rounded head was made in a subsequent step by first clamping the nail shank so that the head could be compressed - hence the rounded shank with pinch marks on the upper part of the nail just under the nail head.
Photos below: large iron spike found near Elmira, Ontario by Vern M shows laminar splitting along the length of the nail shank, giving an earliest date that some sources put at 1830.
The Perkins first cut nail machine patent (1795) was succeeded by an 1810 patent filed by the same inventor in England in 1810.
That improved nail cutting machine produced nails with fibres along the length of the shank. (Phillips, 1993 citing English Patent No. 3365, application dated July 26, 1810; specifications filed January 26, 1811.)
So we have an earliest-date for nails like the one below, produced in the U.S., of 1810.
See more of our discussion on reader Vern's iron spike splits
at NAIL SPLITS & CRACKS vs AGE
Below: Tony's RR spike found on the Oregon Coast is an example of how rust patterns can suggest the direction of iron fibers in a nail. [Click to enlarge any image]
In our images above and below you'll notice that the head of these large railroad spikes sport an offset head. The larger lip of the offset head on these large spikes, also called crampons, was used to secure the bottom edge of the rail to the steel plate upon which the rail rests.
As the railroad spike is driven through the plate and onwards into the railroad tie or (sleeper), the combination of spike, tie-plate, and sleeper hold the rail in place in the stone-covered bed (ballast) of the railway.
Details are
...
Below, an example of modern round or wire nails, galvanized fasteners. These 4d 1 1/2" galvanized nails are designed for use with steel joist hangers.
Early wire nails were made first in smaller sizes.
If we exclude nails coated with a galvanized or other material, most modern wire-type nails will show parallel indentations across the top of the nail below the head, indicating the grip on the nail shank as the nail's head was formed.
The Birmingham industry expanded in the following decades, and reached its greatest extent in the 1860s, after which it declined due to competition from wire nails, but continued until the outbreak of World War I. (Sjögren 2013) - source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nail_(fastener) retrieved 2018/06/15
Ezekiel Reed from Bridgewater Massachusetts developed the first machine that could cut a nail including its head in one operation.
In the U.S. the Parker Mills nail company was built in 1819 on the original site of the Parker Mills cotton mill that had been burned by the British during the War of 1812.
Above and below: Hardware Merchandising magazine article discussing a new English nail making machine, 7 February 1890.
...
By 1890 nail making machinery had advanced to produce cut nails at high volume and low cost and at improved reliability. (Hardware Merchandising 7 Feb 1890)
The Parker Mills nail company became the Tremont Nail company that continues to produce traditional machine-made "cut nails" today. [1]
The development of machine made nails that could be produced in high volume was critical to this change in construction methods. But even in the 1930's and 40's nails were a meaningful cost of construction.
Above, a advertisement for wire-nails appearing in The Iron Age magazine, ca 1893.
...
Illustration above: Popular Mechanics, March 1950, p. 96 describing the new "nail gun".
Illustration below: Paslode nail gun nails sold in strips are still "wire nails" but are no round in cross-section.
...
Nails cannot alone give the exact date of construction of a building because the nails themselves may have been made considerably earlier or even re-used from a still-older construction. But nail age can suggest date boundaries for the construction at a site.
In guessing the age of a nail or other hardware it is very helpful if you can tell us
Watch out: Documentary sources
should take priority whenever possible, and
other artifacts should be used as supportive
evidence. (Adams 2002) as cited
at NAILS, AGE & HISTORY
Watch out: keep in mind that the date of manufacture as well as the date of actual use of nails varies significantly by country and even smaller areas, so the physical location and context of the nail's use are important in understanding its probable age.
If we know when a type of nail first became available in the area where it was found or used and if we know when later machine made nails were available in the same area that can set an earliest date for a particular nail.
Details of Hand-wrought nails used in North America in the 17th, 18th, and 19th century in American building construction as well as modern hand wrought nail reproductions are now found
at NAILS HAND-WROUGHT & REPRODUCTIONS
This section has moved to NAILS & HARDWARE, AGE RESEARCH
where we provide photos, text excerpts & research citations for the history of production and use of nails for various countries including Australia, India, the U.K., Scotland, Wales, The United States, and New Zealand.
...
...
Continue reading at NAIL AGE DETERMINATION KEY, or select a topic from the closely-related articles below, or see the complete ARTICLE INDEX.
Or see NAILS & HARDWARE, AGE FAQs - questions & answers posted originally at this page and additional photos of old and newer nails
Or see these
NAILS, AGE & HISTORY at InspectApedia.com - online encyclopedia of building & environmental inspection, testing, diagnosis, repair, & problem prevention advice.
Or see this
Or use the SEARCH BOX found below to Ask a Question or Search InspectApedia
...
Try the search box just below, or if you prefer, post a question or comment in the Comments box below and we will respond promptly.
Search the InspectApedia website
Note: appearance of your Comment below may be delayed: if your comment contains an image, photograph, web link, or text that looks to the software as if it might be a web link, your posting will appear after it has been approved by a moderator. Apologies for the delay.
Only one image can be added per comment but you can post as many comments, and therefore images, as you like.
You will not receive a notification when a response to your question has been posted.
Please bookmark this page to make it easy for you to check back for our response.
IF above you see "Comment Form is loading comments..." then COMMENT BOX - countable.ca / bawkbox.com IS NOT WORKING.
In any case you are welcome to send an email directly to us at InspectApedia.com at editor@inspectApedia.com
We'll reply to you directly. Please help us help you by noting, in your email, the URL of the InspectApedia page where you wanted to comment.
In addition to any citations in the article above, a full list is available on request.