InspectAPedia®   -   Search InspectApedia

Gas  burner flame lifting off of or too far from burner orifices - high pressure (C) Daniel Friedman at InspectApedia.com Adjust Gas Equipment for High Altitude
Changes needed to gas orifices, regulators, controls

  • POST a QUESTION or COMMENT about what changes and adjustments are needed - if even possible - to operate LP, Propane, or natural gas fueled equipment at higher altitudes.

This article describes the use of gas fueled heating equipment of any sort when working at higher altitudes.

Some heaters, gas stoves, clothes dryers may be usable with conversion of key parts while some other equipment may not be manufacturer-certified for such use and may even be unsafe.

Our page top photo shows the gas flame lifting a bit far off of the burner on this Mapei LP gas stove operating at just under 7,000 ft. of altitude in San Miguel de Allende, Guanajuato, Mexico. We had to boost gas pressure to get another gas heating device working properly, resulting in pushing this gas stovetop a bit into question.

InspectAPedia tolerates no conflicts of interest. We have no relationship with advertisers, products, or services discussed at this website.

- Daniel Friedman, Publisher/Editor/Author - See WHO ARE WE?

High Altitude Gas Burner & Equipment Adjustments, Conversions, Manuals

LP gas orifice #44 for the Bosch Gas Cootop using LP gas (C) Daniel FriedmanLP gas orifice #44 for the Bosch Gas Cootop using LP gas (C) Daniel FriedmanWatch out: When using a natural gas or propane-burning appliance such as a gas boiler, gas furnace, or gas stove at higher altitudes adjustments to each gas burner's metering orifices, regulator, combustion air, and venting is likely to be needed for safe use of the equipment.

This is also true for gas fueled incinerating toilets, LP or propane fueled generators, etc.

Photos shown here: two different-capacity gas metering orifices, also referred to as gas spuds or jets, swapped in or out of a specific gas appliance to adjust its fuel supply rate.

The gas appliance spud will be marked with

A letter: L (for LPG) or N (for natural gas)

A number: (such as 44 or 122) indicating the orifice opening diameter that in turn defines the BTU capacity of the spud, depending further on the gas supply pressure.

These components are just one of the parts may need to be changed when swapping fuels between LP or propane and natural gas, and similarly when installing an LP gas or natural gas fueled equipment at higher altitudes.

[Click to enlarge any image]

In this article we include a collection of installation and set-up manuals for gas fueled equipment of various sorts. Each of these manuals contains detailed instructions for adjusting the gas-burning device to work properly and safely at height altitudes.

Watch out: our review of instructions for converting various gas-fired equipment to work at altitude find that almost always the requirements are very specific to the equipment brand and model and sometimes altitude as well.

Don't simply slap in a different gas regulator or orifice without following the manufacturer's instructions or your gas fueled device may well be dangerous.

Typical Changes For High Altitude Operation of Gas-Fueled Equipment

The adjustments and changes you may need to set up an LP fueled or some natural gas fueled equipment at high altitudes can include any or all of the following:

More arcane data must be considered by the gas fueled equipment engineers when considering specifications for high-altitude operation, such as the relationship between gas spud orifice size and gas pressure, flow, velocity, and orifice cross-sectional area.

The meaning of the orifice number sizes on gas spuds is explained in more detail

at CONVERT the GAS ORIFICES where you'll see the relationship of orifice size and the BTU rating of these devices for LP gas and natural gas.

Gas Equipment Installation Manuals Including High Altitude Set-Up Instructions

Bosh Gas Regulator for a gas cooktop (C) Daniel FriedmanPhoto: some gas regulators can be converted between fuels (LP vs natural gas) by flipping over an internal part. Other, different adjustments or even an entirely different regulator may be required to operate the same appliance at high altitude.

...




ADVERTISEMENT





Reader Comments, Questions & Answers About The Article Above

Below you will find questions and answers previously posted on this page at its page bottom reader comment box.

Reader Q&A - also see RECOMMENDED ARTICLES & FAQs

On 2022-04-13 by @C F - OK to install a Cinderella gas-fueled incinerating toilet at high altitude?

Paper liners required for use in incinerating toilet (C) InspectApedia.com@Inspectapedia Com Moderator,

Thanks so much for your time, your recommendations and the information you provided in answer to my questions!

Now realize there are many rather obvious reasons why a propane fueled incinerator toilet designed and built to operate at lower altitudes would be very unlikely to work (or be safe) at much higher ones.

Will try reaching back out to the manufacturer to see if they may have a high-altitude conversion kit for the Cinderella Freedom toilet; or if there is any way to order one customized for our high altitude off-grid cabin.

Thanks again!! Will let you know if we receive any reply.

On 2022-04-13 by Inspectapedia Com Moderator (mod) - OK to install a Cinderella gas-fueled incinerating toilet at high altitude?

@C F,

You will absolutely want SPECIFIC gas burner adjustment requirements for the gas burner used in the Cinderella Freedom gas-fueled incinerator toilet for high altitude - that needs to come from the company's engineers. No generic explanation or "kit" is likely to be right, nor safe.

But to understand the requirement in general, you can take a look at this

LP/High Altitude LP/High Altitude Natural Gas Conversion Kit Installation Instructions For Model Series G Furnaces, P(G,N) Gas/Electric Appliances, and R Gas/Electric Appliances [PDF]

Watch out: This is ONLY AN EXAMPLE and NOT RIGHT for your Incinerating toilet

Excerpt: This conversion kit is only for United States installations to convert a natural gas furnace to a propane (LP) gas application, a high altitude natural gas application, or a high
altitude propane (LP) gas application. For Canadian installations, the Canadian conversion kit must be used. -
- Source: Nortek Global HVAC, retrieved 2022/04/12 original source: https://enora.nortekhvac.com/literature/707758b.pdf

At InspectApedia at

https://inspectapedia.com/plumbing/High-Altitude-NG-LP-Conversion-Kit-Instructions.pdf

Similarly, here's information from JennAir a gas cooktop and range manufacturer, on high-altitude gas burner orifice conversion kits:

Excerpt: This LP Range High Altitude Conversion Kit includes the orifices necessary to adjust your liquid propane range to operate properly in elevations that exceed 6560' (1999.5 m). At higher altitudes where air pressure is lower, cooking temperatures need to be increased to bring water to boil or thoroughly cook your food. If you’ve experienced these issues, you can update your LP range with this kit. This is a universal accessory that can be used across several brands; check to see if your model number is compatible.

Installing this accessory will require specialized tools, complicated disassembly of the range and prior repair experience. We recommend that you hire a qualified technician to install this conversion kit. If installing yourself, remember to unplug the range or shut off the house circuit breaker for the appliance before installing this part.

Also make sure to turn off the gas valve before the repair. - JennAir,LP RANGE HIGH ALTITUDE CONVERSION KIT W11035431 - at https://www.jennair.com/parts-and-accessories/range-parts-and-accessories/p.lp-range-high-altitude-conversion-kit.w11035431.html

The reason I emphasize that you need the exactly right high-altitude conversion kit for your Cinderella gas-fueled incinerator toilet is that the LP gas metering orifices are sized specifically to meet the gas burning rate needed to match the rest of the design of the gas burner.

If the manufacturer's engineers won't or can't help you with that information, as much as I praise the Cinderella incinerating toilet line in general, I would not buy the unit as you may find that it simply won't work - won't incinerate the waste adequately - and it might be unsafe (incomplete combustion of propane or natural gas risks production of fatal carbon monoxide gas).

Watch out: keep in mind that you may need to replace or adjust (if possible) the gas regulator, and adjust combustion air and venting, not just the metering orifices.

Finally - for now - read this older but excellent article by Eiseman

The effect of altitude on the limits of safe operation of gas appliances

Also see information on operating LP or natural gas appliances in tall buildings or at high altitude, found at

See CINDERELLA INCINERATING TOILET for details about this device.

Below: the ash pan and pan carrier are assembled and ready to be re-installed into the toilet base.

Insert the Cinderella ash pan into the toilet base (C) InspectApedia.com

On 2022-04-10 by C F

@Inspectapedia Com Moderator,
Thanks! Your time and offer of assistance are greatly appreciated!

On 2022-04-10 by Inspectapedia Com Moderator (mod)

@C F,

I will see what we can find.

The Cinderalla distributor, the Canadian company was very generous with me when I had complaints about a part. However I'm not sure that they have engineering staff available. That needs to come from the manufacturer.

On 2022-04-10 by C F

@Inspectapedia Com Moderator,
Thanks much for response. My inquiry to mfg in Norway via their US customer support email address was forwarded to North American distributor in Canada. All he said was they could make no guarantee of operability. Has not responded to my follow up email requesting additional details. Your observation makes sense as the gas powered generator we occasionally use required smaller carburetor jet to function satisfactorily at altitude.

Your response also made me wonder if there are adjustable propane regulators or those made for high altitudes that might help. Will look into that. Any suggestions about related references or resources would be appreciated!

On 2022-04-10 by Inspectapedia Com Moderator (mod) - use of the Cinderella Freedom (gas) incinerator toilet at higher altitude

@C F,

Worth getting some details asyou may need adjustments to gas combustion at that altitude.

Are the mfgs engineers willing to give advice?

On 2022-04-09 by C F

I'm searching for info on use of the Cinderella Freedom (gas) incinerator toilet at higher altitudes, specifically 10,500 feet. North American distributor says the product has been tested to 1050 meters (3150 feet). Anything beyond that he cannot give any guarantees. Unable to find any related research about this. Anyone have experience in use of incinerator toilets at altitude?

Any reason(s) a propane fueled incinerator toilet would not work at such an altitude? Feedback would be much appreciated.

This Q&A were posted originally at INCINERATOR TOILET SYSTEMS

 

On 2020-01-22 - by (mod) - adjustment to operate gas equipment at 700 ft ? - make sense of gas consumpation rate ?

Thanks Charles for an interesting question.

Thoughts:

- the Goodman gas pack data tag will be giving INPUT BTUH which is of course a higher number than the btus of energy or heat delivered to the occupied space as combustion and heat delivery are not 100% efficient

- The gas meter can tell us, with careful reading and recording, the cubic feet of gas used over an interval
But
Unless we are keeping accurate records of the number of minutes the Goodman gas pack burner is actually on, and at which of its two input/output levels it is operating, I don't understand how we can calculate its actual natural gas usage rate.

If we have the actual on-time in hours (or fractions thereof) of the heater and if we know that it's operating at just one of its two BTU rates, then we can as I infer you're doing, calculate its anticipated usage rate and compare that with the meter's measured usage rate.

Can you give me more details about how you made your calculation?

As you cite a gas meter reading I infer that your gas supply is natural gas, not propane.

The typical BTUs in LPG and in natural gas are given

at GAS BTUH, CUBIC FEET & ENERGY

There you'll find I quote: One cubic foot (0.028 cubic meters) of natural gas contains about 1,050 BTUs - so I'm using a number slightly below yours per c.f.

I don't think the elevation at Raleigh, just 400 ft. requires a significant adjustment to the gas consumption rate as it's not far above sea level.

The relationship between altitude and gas use is addressed in an interesting paper by

In any event I would be very hesitant to change the gas orifices in the heater from what was installed by the factory. I think that there are multiple design features that are balanced by the heater's design engineers.

So unless the Goodman unit's instructions (or a call to Goodman's tech support) allow us to change the orifice sizes and thus gas metering rates, I would not do so as it could make the unit unsafe.

In addition to reading the details of how you are making your calculation it'd be helpful to know the Goodman gas pack model and to see a photo of the unit's data tag (you can use the "add image" button to add one photo per comment).

Thanks

Daniel

For other readers

A "Gas pack" is a heating and cooling unit that provides heat by burning gas, LPG or NG, and provides cooling by using electricity.

The photo below is of a Goodman GPG16M gas pack unit

Cooling Capacity: 22,800 – 58,500 BTU/h

Heating Capacity: 60,000 – 140,000 BTU/h

Product specifications for Goodman Gas Pack units GPG 1624 to GPG 1660 are given by

GOODMAN GAS PACK SPECIFICATIONS [PDF] at InspectApedia.com

Charles' unit is perhaps the Goodmanb GPG1630 with orifice sizes 45 / 1.25MM and an AFUE of 81% In that unit the two firing ranges give these INPUT/OUTPUT BTU numbers

Low-fire rate 60,000 / 47,000 BTUh

High-fire rate 80,000 / 62,000 BTUh

Image Lost, please re-post.

On 2020-01-22 by Charles

Hello, I have a new (one month) Goodman gas pack. It has a two stage gas burner, rated at 80,000/60,000 btu on natural gas.

The gas pressure has been double checked and set at exactly what is on the nameplate (ie: 3.5" w.c. and 2.0 w,c.).

Elevation here in Raleigh is about 400'. The problem is that by checking the gas consumption on the gas meter, using a btu content of 1020 btu/c.f., the unit is using only about 63,000/50,000 btu on highfire/low fire.

I'm just wondering if perhaps the orifaces are not the correct size, or perhaps the gas pressures should be increased above Goodman's suggestions.

 


...

Continue reading at GAS PRESSURE vs BUILDING HEIGHT, or select a topic from the closely-related articles below, or see the complete ARTICLE INDEX.

Or see these

Recommended Articles

 

Suggested citation for this web page

GAS APPLIANCE OPERATION at HIGH ALTITUDE at InspectApedia.com - online encyclopedia of building & environmental inspection, testing, diagnosis, repair, & problem prevention advice.


Or see this

INDEX to RELATED ARTICLES: ARTICLE INDEX to GAS APPLIANCES, PIPING, CONTROLS

Or use the SEARCH BOX found below to Ask a Question or Search InspectApedia

Ask a Question or Search InspectApedia

Try the search box just below, or if you prefer, post a question or comment in the Comments box below and we will respond promptly.

Search the InspectApedia website

Note: appearance of your Comment below may be delayed: if your comment contains an image, photograph, web link, or text that looks to the software as if it might be a web link, your posting will appear after it has been approved by a moderator. Apologies for the delay.

Only one image can be added per comment but you can post as many comments, and therefore images, as you like.
You will not receive a notification
when a response to your question has been posted.
Please bookmark this page to make it easy for you to check back for our response.
Our Comment Box is provided by Countable Web Productions countable.ca

Comment Form is loading comments...

Citations & References

In addition to any citations in the article above, a full list is available on request.



ADVERTISEMENT