InspectAPedia®   -   Search InspectApedia

Alligatored paint (C) Daniel Friedman Common Building Painting Mistakes to Avoid

26 ways to get a bad paint-job on a building

  • POST a QUESTION or COMMENT about building exterior or interior paint job mistakes and paint failiures - how to avoid paint problems on buildings

Paint job mistakes that result in early paint failure:

This article desribes and illustrates common building exterior & interior painting mistakes, describes how to diagnose paint failures on buildings, and outlines a procedure for diagnostic field inspection & lab testing of failed painted surfaces.

We include photographs of paint failures on buildings and more photos of forensic paint laboratory examination of samples of failed paint useful to assist in diagnosing the probable cause of each type of paint failure.

Our page top photo shows a horrible paint job on a building exterior: the painter simply painted over loose, alligatored paint.

InspectAPedia tolerates no conflicts of interest. We have no relationship with advertisers, products, or services discussed at this website.

- Daniel Friedman, Publisher/Editor/Author - See WHO ARE WE?

Common Building Painting Mistakes to Avoid

Photograph of  peeling paint on a building exterior - can you diagnose this failure by eye?Experts representing paint manufacturers see many field failures of painted surfaces, often arising from a common cause.

[Click to enlarge any image]

But getting a clear answer from these professionals can be tricky: the painting contractor is their customer, not the building owner.

Therefore, while most paint failures are due to poor surface preparation or painting in improper conditions of temperature or moisture, the "expert" may be reluctant to say so.

Importantly, other paint failures are due to construction errors, building ventilation or vapor barrier errors, building leaks, or improper maintenance. It is important to understand why a paint failure occurred before re-painting a building.

Otherwise the expense of a new paint job may be wasted.

"Improper or inadequate surface preparation is by far the most common cause of house paint failures such as blistering, peeling and staining. If the new paint is separating from the old coat of paint, it is most likely due to chalking or some contaminant on the old paint that prevents the new paint from penetrating and binding to the old painted surface.

If the peeling failure is down to the bare wood, it is most likely that the problem is a result of too much moisture within the wall, forcing itself out, taking the entire paint film with it."

"Over 65% of all paint failures can be attributed to poor or improper surface preparation. Two of the major causes of paint failure on exterior wood surfaces are either moisture passing through the substrate from the interior, or exterior sources of moisture getting behind the paint film.

Temperature and humidity have major effects upon drying and ultimately upon the characteristics of the paint film. These effects will always determine the actual appearance and performance of the paint itself.

Photograph of  peeling paint on a building exterior - can you diagnose this failure by eye?Paint should be applied at temperatures of 70o F, (21o C), ideally, plus or minus 20o F (12o C) - unless product specifications state otherwise. A surface should not be painted if its temperature is within 5o F of the dew point or the relative humidity is above 85%." -- PPG Exterior Failures.

The follow sections of this document form a checklist of building and site conditions leading to paint failures (such as peeling paint, blistering paint, chalking paint, cracking or alligatoring paint, or bleeding and stains through paint--terms defined below).

The focus is on failures of painted wood surfaces on building exteriors but the paint failure diagnostic procedure can be generalized to other surfaces inside and out.

The three key steps to successful painting are

1. Prepare the surface,

2. Prepare the surface,

3. Prepare the surface.

- DF (moderator) and a panel of experienced house painters at ASHI ca1988 Paint Failures Seminar.

Also see PAINT SURFACE PREPARATION.

But other than inadequate surface preparation, here are some other very common house painting mistakes:

26 Painting Mistakes That Mean a Bad Paint Job with a Short Life - causes of early paint job failure

  1. Removing only the obviously-loose paint,

    leaving poorly-secured paint, leaving thick edges of old paint where blisters or old peeled paint were inadequately removed.
  2. Using paint to try to fill gaps 

    where caulk should have been applied.
  3. Using a spackling compound o

    r filler intended for holes or cracks to "smooth" large building surface areas (skim coating) such as skim coating in order to apply paint over alligatored or poorly-adhered old paint. More thickness of fillers, paints, primers,or magic gluey coatings on the surface of un-sound paint are unlikely to work.

    A case study of this foul-up is

    at PAINT FAILURE CASE PHOTOS, SITE.
  4. Painting over thinly-cracked, or peeling painted surfaces
  5. Painting over old, existing thick, alligatored paint
  6. Painting over dusty or dirty surfaces.

    See PAINT SURFACE PREPARATION

    and for mold (or "mildew") or algae or other dark stained surfaces

    see SIDING, WOOD CLEANERS, STAINS, PAINTS
  7. Painting over mold (which many sources incorrectly call "mildew").

    Painting over moldy surfaces without adequate cleaning and surface preparation such as power washing, disinfection, and light sanding, likely to lead to rapid mold re-growth in the paint and possibly to a paint adhesion failure, even if a paint "mildewcide" or fungicidal additive was used.

    Even if you clean the surface, if you paint without correcting the cause of the stain (shade, trees, moisture) means those stains will recur, growing right through the new coating.

    See SIDING, WOOD CLEANERS, STAINS, PAINTS for cleaning advice and for advice about choosing the right type of stain or paint.

    Also see MILDEW ON BUILDING EXTERIORS?.

    PARMETOL, [PDF] a wood preservativerecommended by the manufacturer was used as a fungicidal additive to paint on the Blue Poplar wood sculpture in Amsterdam, by sculptor artist Mari Shields [Website marishields.com ] whose huge wood tree sculptures and stunning works can be found at a number of locations listed at her website: http://www.marishields.com/[ - art conservation consult DF-artist MS 2010]
  8. Poor paint job (C) Daniel Friedman


    As we discuss
    at PAINT FALURE, DIAGNOSIS, CURE, PREVENTION, our photo (left) shows a new paint job that failed before the job was even finished, on a historic property: the Justin Smith Morrill Homestead in Vermont.

    While most of the paint failures on this building were due to use of improper paint or defective product, here we saw peeling and loss of adhesion over moldy wood.

    A combination of failure to properly clean the wood surface before painting, painting under too hot or too wet conditions, and failure to use an effective primer and properly formulated top coat can conspire together to give a messy paint job failure on some projects.

  9. Painting over oily or other-contaminated surfaces
  10. Painting over high pH surfaces on stucco,

    such as new stucco that has not adequately cured or stucco that needed additional wash and surface neutralization can cause white blooms of efflorescence and early paint failures;

    See PAINT on STUCCO, FAILURES for details.
  11. Painting over glossy hard paint 

    surfaces without adequate preparation such as light sanding or use of a chemical de-glosser, likely to lead to an adhesion failure.
  12. Painting over mill-glazed surfaces such as trim or cedar or pine clapboards.

    See PAINT SURFACE PREPARATION

    Also see UN-FINISHED SIDING & TRIM
  13. Painting over new masonry or new stucco that has not adequately cured.
  14. Painting over old oxidized chalky paint or stain
  15. Painting over rot or insect-damaged  wood
  16. Poor prep trim paint job (C) Daniel Friedman


    As we discuss at PAINT FALURE, DIAGNOSIS, CURE, PREVENTION, our photo (left) shows a new paint job over old rot.

    It looks as if the painter used a rather soft wood filler to try to repair the rotted window sill, and if you look closely (click the image to enlarge it) you'll see that the paint is already coming off - months after this costly renovation.

    Where sill rot is limited, rather than replacing the entire sill or frame, we find it easier to cut out and replace a rotted window sill by piecing in a custom-cut repair segment, perhaps using treated wood (let it dry before painting) glued in place.

    We have also made occasional use of wood restoration epoxy products such as those made by Abatron, Inc. to restore and save valuable trim that would be costly to replace. But slopping on some putty and paint, as was done here is not a durable job.

  17. Painting over silicone caulk

    (which in many cases is not paintable)
  18. Painting in hot sun or dry wind:

    painting in sun or wind can be a particular problem when painting new stucco surfaces.

    See PAINTING in SUN or WIND
    and
    see PAINT on STUCCO, FAILURES for details of the problems this causes on stucco.
  19. Painting the second coat before 

    the first paint coating has adequately dried
  20. Painting without reading 

    the manufacturer's instructions for mixing, thinning, surface prep, temperature conditions, etc.
  21. Soaking building cavities:

    surface preparation for painting by improper use of a power washer: spraying "up" on a clapboard building forcing water into the building wall cavities, (risking hidden mold contamination or a moisture problem leading to paint failure), or spraying too-close to the building surface, causing gouging and undesirable loss of surface material
  22. Surface washing using chemicals 

    or bleach without adequate wash-off of the chemical or cleaner itself
  23. Painting on wet surfaces - failure to measure moisture levels or measuring only the "dry" areas but painting over other wet areas of a building. Also

    See MOISTURE IMPACT ON PAINT
  24. Painting over incompatible old paint - leading to poor adhesion, wrinkling, cracking, paint fall-off.

    See INCOMPATIBLE PAINTS.
  25. Painting with the wrong type of paint for the surface or environment, such as using an interior paint outside.

    See INCOMPATIBLE PAINTS.

Poor prep trim paint job (C) Daniel Friedman

  1. Sanding with a grinder carelessly,

    leaving sanding marks and gouges that ruin the surface and telegraph through the new paint job - may not reduce paint adhesion but may result in a cosmetic issue with the work.
  2. As we discuss at PAINT FALURE, DIAGNOSIS, CURE, PREVENTION, our photo (left) shows the condition of a nearly brand-new paint job on an older home in Poughkeepsie, NY.

    We noticed that old paint was left on the surface with no feathering of the edges of the few spots where paint had been removed or had fallen off before the paint job.

    We noticed also that the painter tried to "seal" the loose paint by globbing on plenty of new paint - see that drip running down the trim board?

    Finally, we noticed that this new paint job was already failing - the split in the paint visible in the lower portion of the photograph.

    This paint job will have a shorter life than if the surface had been stripped, but then the painter (and owner who was selling his home) avoided a much higher cost of stripping lead-containing paint from an older building.

Poor prep trim paint job (C) Daniel Friedman

  1. Painting too thick:

    slopping on paint that runs down walls (see above and below)
  2. As we discuss at PAINT FALURE, DIAGNOSIS, CURE, PREVENTION, our photo (left) shows the result of many coats of paint on a home built in Dutchess County NY in the 1700's. This was some of the thickest paint we have found on a building exterior.

    No tests for the presence of lead paint are necessary in a case like this - you know that lead paint is present. Y

    ou also can see that this paint job is cracking and that paint has been falling off of the building between paint jobs that involved little or no surface preparation.

  3. Painting too thin:

    over-thinning paint to extend its coverage dilutes the binders so that even if the new paint job looks great it may wear or fail prematurely

 

Painting Procedures & Paint Job Mistakes Research

...




ADVERTISEMENT





Reader Comments, Questions & Answers About The Article Above

Below you will find questions and answers previously posted on this page at its page bottom reader comment box.

Reader Q&A - also see RECOMMENDED ARTICLES & FAQs

On 2016-08-08 by (mod) - paint surface is actually oxidized

If the paint surface is actually oxidized (you can rub your finger along it and come away with pigment) then that oxide needs to be removed to get good adhesion of subsequent coats.

Same for dust, dirt, etc.

On 2016-08-08 by heidi

My painter has left the exterior of our house unprimed (a few spots primed) for over 3-4 weeks in high heat and humidity. He says all he needs to do is do a "gentle wash" before starting back up.

Shouldn't he be doing a light sand too? Also he has left the paints which were opened outside in this same heat. Are they still usable?

On 2015-08-03 by Candace

Is there a difference in cedar clapboard gouge patching when you are using exterior latex stain versus paint?

On 2015-08-03 by Anonymous

Thank you Dan. One more question. I have a can of Dap Vinyl Spackling but I'm not sure if it's the best thing to use since it dissolves in water which to me doesn't seem very weatherproof. What weatherproof filler would you use?

On 2015-08-03 by (mod) -

An exterrior-use weatherproof filler can work on surfaces that are to be painted, provided that the surface to which it is applied is sound. Fill, sand, prime, and paint a test area to see how you like it.

On 2015-08-03 by Jarie

Hi I have an old house with wood clapboard and I'm in the process of scraping. There are many layers of paint and the chips are large, deep and down to bare wood. I'd like to know whether I should just scrape, sand, prime and paint or should I use a spackling compound to even out the surface at least in areas of high visibility?

On 2015-07-29 by Candace

Thank you, Daniel.
If many clapboards were damaged, replacing them will be quite expensive! We have bidders who will attest there was no clapboard damage when they bid the job.

My question is, should we ask that in order to make it right the contractor have the west side thoroughly sanded (to remove "cosmetic" putty and to detect damaged clapboards? And then, request damaged clapboards be replaced by the company who damaged them (they bear the cost) and repaint where clapboards were sanded and replaced?

On 2015-07-29 by (mod) - blistering siding

Candace,

This sounds like a cosmetic snafu and one can but respect the company that agrees to "make it right".

Typically puttying up gouges looks like, well, puttied up gouges. The putty area will not age and weather as will the surrounding wood so color differences and texture differences may be quite noticeable unless the siding is painted or covered with a very opaque dense stain.

You may end up having to replace badly damaged siding.

I suggest allowing the company to try whatever cosmetic repairs they want, with the understanding that

1. if the repair is ugly it's not acceptable

2. you get a year warranty to address differences in weathering

On 2015-07-28 by Candace Fitzpatrick

Painter used power washer improperly and gouged some clapboards. In addition, inadequate prep and/or gouging was done on west side of house where most of the peeling was evident.

The siding stain was applied. After we complained (about the areas we could see from the ground) the company sent someone who puttied the majority of the west of the house over the already sprayed siding stain. He then hand brushed that side of the house.

After the job was "completed" we could see blistering @ the gouged/puttied boards we can see at ground level on the south side of the house. The painter has agreed to replace those few clapboards

. We have no way to assess the west side of the house above ground level and are concerned. The company agreed to "make it right." Any suggestions about what we should ask them to do? This has been a miserable experience.

On 2015-07-03 by (mod) -

Sounds like a rush paint job by someone who doesn't know about fast-setting hole filling compounds - or who didn't have any on the truck.

Depending on what was used to fill holes and its compatability with the paint the filled spots may not look so hot when the paint had dried - slower drying, these areas may form depressions if they srhink, or crack - depending on the filler used.

And if the filler was water based over which an alkyd paint was applied there's a risk of moisture blisters in those areas. If you painted-over with latex or acrylic that may not be a problem.

In terms of an indoor mold hazard what you describe is not significant.

Use the CONTACT link if you like to send us photos of the areas and details about what was used to fill the depressions and what kind of paint was applied and we can comment further.

Thanks for the query.

On 2015-07-03 by anonymous

Painter filled quarter and dime sized holes/dents in interior walls with wood filler and painted over. Some of the areas are still tacky, others are dry to touch but squishy. Can this mold over time? What should be done? Thanks!

Question: how to remove mold from a wood tree sculpture & prevent mold re-growth?

This may be unusual, but I'm a sculptor. Part of my output is expressed using lime wood branches, clippings. I've noticed that mold has appreared from the cut ends of these branches and cuttings. Can I retard this or reradicate it using a spray/chemical? I'd appreciate any advice or someone to whom reference can be made. Yours sincerely, I.C. 6/8/2013

Reply:

Thank you for the interesting question about mold growth on wood branches used in a sculpture - it helps us realize where we need to work on making our text more clear or more complete.

A competent onsite inspection by an expert usually finds additional clues that help accurately diagnose a problem with mold growth on art and artifacts as well as diagnosing the probable cause of that mold;

but I can say that the species of wood, in this case limewood or perhaps wood from the Linden tree. Indeed limewood has a long history of use in artworks, having been used for the carving of painted icons, apparently because of its resistance to cracking and the ease of sanding it smooth.[15]

I don't have a full picture of just what you're making or what mold you're dealing with nor its extent; so my advice is a bit general. 

In most simple terms the proper course of action is to 

1.  remove the problem mold 

- clean the surface; depending on the sensitivity of your wood and sculpture, simple household cleaner would perhaps suffice; for cosmetic reasons you may need to use a more aggressive or oxidizing cleaner, even bleach - but obviously you won't do that if your work would itself be damaged; 

If your work is sensitive or fragile you'll want to chat with an art conservator for some specific recommendations; often we can find success using gentle means to clean and remove stains from wood. (I am an aerobiologist interested in mold in artwork but not an expert conservator, as you'll read at some of the references in links I include below); 

2. protect the wood against new mold growth 

- if your project permits, when the wood is thoroughly dry, if you seal it to resist moisture uptake it will be more mold resistant. 

PARMETOL [PDF] a wood preservativerecommended by the manufacturer was used as a fungicidal additive to paint on the Blue Poplar wood sculpture in Amsterdam, by artist  Mari Shields [Website marishields.com ]  [per our discussion in 2010]  I'm not sure it was entirely successful. [6]

Watch out; if you don't clean adequately, or if you seal damp wood, or if your sealant is exposed to weather, there is a risk of new mold growth beneath the sealant - a condition that then could be harder to clean; I discuss this problem

at PAINTING MISTAKES - you are on this page.

3. identify & fix the cause of the mold growth - such as wood sculpture in a damp or wet area or if outdoors, in a shaded wet area. Those conditions need to be addresses too if you expect to avoid a recurrent mold problem on your work.

You may be surprised as well but this is not the first such request I've received from a sculptor on exactly this topic; wood is a natural meal for many species of mold. If the wood is wet and thus absorbs water the risk of mold growth is significant.

Mari Shields a sculptor in Amsterdam was faced with similar problems of mold growth on a large wooden tree sculpture  that was exhibited outdoors; some of her work can be see at http://www.marishields.com/ - and she may have other suggestions for you.

These articles may also be of interest to you

Please keep me posted on how things progress, and send along photos if you can. Such added details can help us understand what's happening and often permit some useful further comment. What we both learn may help me help someone else./P>

Question: paint job preparation choices: power washing or not?

(Mar 12, 2015) Rita said:
My 100 yr old house has been painted three times in the last 25 years. It needs another painting due to peeling, dirt and mold. The two companies who bid have different approaches. One will scrape then power wash and my concern is lead contamination. T

he other will scrape then paint over the mold and dirt. Both say the other's approach is wrong. What do I do?

Reply: taking care not to spread lead dust about is important.

Rita I agree that taking care not to spread lead dust about is important.

I'm unclear why either approach is innately "wrong" - both are removing material.

Perhaps the concern and question to ask is if power washing, how will the removed material be contained? Power washing, because it's wet, makes lots of overspray that must be contained but yet produces far less airborne dust.

Generally the more throrough the surface preparation the better will be the paint job. Power washing removes additinal materials and dust that may be left behind by just scraping the surface.

On the other hand, improperly done, power washing can blow water into building wall cavities creating a mold problem or damaging interior surfaces or even electrical wiring.

And if the painters don't wait for the washed surfaces to be fully dry before painting the new paint job will fail promptly. That might be why one of your contractors doesn't power wash. Or it may simply be that they don't own a power washer.

I'd like to power wash but with the proper precautions and checks for surface dryness before re-painting.



...

Continue reading at BAD SURFACE PREP or select a topic from the closely-related articles below, or see the complete ARTICLE INDEX.

Or see these

Recommended Articles

Suggested citation for this web page

PAINTING MISTAKES at InspectApedia.com - online encyclopedia of building & environmental inspection, testing, diagnosis, repair, & problem prevention advice.


Or see this

INDEX to RELATED ARTICLES: ARTICLE INDEX to PAINTS & STAINS & FAILURES

Or use the SEARCH BOX found below to Ask a Question or Search InspectApedia

Ask a Question or Search InspectApedia

Try the search box just below, or if you prefer, post a question or comment in the Comments box below and we will respond promptly.

Search the InspectApedia website

Note: appearance of your Comment below may be delayed: if your comment contains an image, photograph, web link, or text that looks to the software as if it might be a web link, your posting will appear after it has been approved by a moderator. Apologies for the delay.

Only one image can be added per comment but you can post as many comments, and therefore images, as you like.
You will not receive a notification
when a response to your question has been posted.
Please bookmark this page to make it easy for you to check back for our response.


Comment Form is loading comments...

 

IF above you see "Comment Form is loading comments..." then COMMENT BOX - countable.ca / bawkbox.com IS NOT WORKING.

In any case you are welcome to send an email directly to us at InspectApedia.com at editor@inspectApedia.com

We'll reply to you directly. Please help us help you by noting, in your email, the URL of the InspectApedia page where you wanted to comment.

Citations & References

In addition to any citations in the article above, a full list is available on request.



ADVERTISEMENT