InspectAPedia®   -   Search InspectApedia

Mold growth colonies of several genera/species on the interior surface of fiberglass-lined HVAC ducts in a Georgia home (C) Daniel Friedman InspectApedia.com JCFiberglass HVAC Duct Mold Test Results

How to inspect & test air ducts for mold contamination:

Visual inspection followed by a simple adhesive tape test confirmed mold growth inside the fiberglass-lined HVAC duct shown here.

This article describes how to test the surface of fiberglass-lined or fiberglass-panel air ducts for the presence of problem mold growth. While some debris and low levels of mold, pollen and other particles is normal inside HVAC systems, large areas of harmful mold genera such as Aspergillus or Penicillium may be hazardous to building occupants.

This article series explains the cause, detection, and hazards of mold growth in fiberglass insulation in residential and light-commercial building and gives advice about dealing with moldy building insulation or ductwork. We describe the types (genera/species) of mold most often found in HVAC ducts and the relationship between mold in ductwork and indoor air quality complaints by building occupants. We include authoritative citations for key research on mold contamination in HVAC ductwork.

InspectAPedia tolerates no conflicts of interest. We have no relationship with advertisers, products, or services discussed at this website.

- Daniel Friedman, Publisher/Editor/Author - See WHO ARE WE?

Water Leaks & Mold Contamination in Fiberglass HVAC Duct Interiors

Leak stains may point to water entry into duct work, a cause of duct mold (C) InspectApedia.com JCHere we discuss and illustrate inspection of air ducts for mold contamination following signs of leaks and suspected mold.

Mold may grow at extensive or problematic levels in some building insulation materials used in walls, floors, ceilings as well as in HVAC air duct systems.

[Click to enlarge any image]

Above: leak stains may point to sources of water entry into a building's HVAC duct system that in turn can trigger problematic or harmful mold growth and contamination of the duct system.

These stains combined with visible mold inside a fiberglass-panel air duct and plenum (below) lead a reader to collect surface samples of suspected mold contamination for analysis in our laboratory.

Below we describe the test samples and the lab results finding large areas of several genera of mold contaminants.

Photo below: white, gray, light green round-like deposits on the interior of fiberglass HVAC ducts look like a substantial area of mold contamination. Mold test tape sample locations were chosen specifically to attempt to capture mold-suspect material in these locations on the ductwork fiberglass liner surface.

Mold contamination visible in HVAC duct interior (C) InspectApedia.com JC

In the laboratory we found that the white, gray, and light-green fuzzy round spots on the HVAC duct interior in this photograph were indeed several genera/species of mold.

Really? Well yes, it's mold. Just how much of a health hazard is posed by the mold in the photograph is questionable. But the samples and building case history support a couple of warnings:

  1. High airborne levels of the mold found in these tests would be hazardous to building occupants and might occur if there is in fact a larger mold reservoir in the HVAC system or elsewhere in the building.
  2. Wet or moldy conditions that produced the mold found and tested here might indeed also have invited a problem mold reservoir elsewhere in the building.
  3. Further investigation is warranted. Details are below.

Photo below: white, gray, light green round-like deposits on the interior of fiberglass HVAC ducts.

The shape of these spots and color suggests they might be mold contamination but other possibilities such as drywall debris were also under consideration. The dark, regularly-spaced gray "spots" are natural deposits of house dust (and possibly contaminants" on the factory-surface of the fiberglass duct liner.

Mold growth colonies of several genera/species on the interior surface of fiberglass-lined HVAC ducts in a Georgia home (C) Daniel Friedman InspectApedia.com JC

Question: are these white splotches on the interior of my fiberglass lined ductwork mold or drywall dust or something else?

I recently leased an apartment a few miles northwest of Atlanta, GA, and have been trying to track down the source of the combination of odors permeating the apartment. The apartment manager is not being very helpful. As I inspected the ductwork, I came across a substance which looks like it could be mold. Pictures are attached. I thought at the very least, you might be interested in using the pictures on your website, whether on the "white mold" page or the "not mold" page.

If you have the time, I would also appreciate your opinion on whether this warrants calling in a mold expert or if it just looks like dirt or debris to you (perhaps drywall dust?). The zoomed out picture shows the view as I insert the camera about 18 inches into the bedroom register towards the plenum (visible on the left) and the main trunk (extending towards the right).

Two other pictures [not displayed here - Ed] show what I suspect to be mold (one on the floor of the main trunk, the other on the wall where the bedroom branch hits the main trunk (just outside the zoomed-out picture).

The apartment is 20-odd years old, though according to maintenance the HVAC system was replaced about 10 years ago. For all I know the ductwork could be original.

The sampling area where these mold photographs and samples were taken is described thus:

- 2016/11/05 Anonymous by private email

Reply: Procedure for detection & identification of Aspergillus sp. & Penicillium sp. as well as significant amounts of Cladosporium sp. as well as low levels of other molds and particles on these fiberglass duct interior surfaces

The white splotches in your photos look very much like small whitish mold colonies. On magnification one can see the characteristic center color and mounding and growth outwards from that point. We see such round-ish mold colonies when a single spore lands on a surface whereon it finds hospitable growing conditions.

In HVAC ducts I imagine that the mold growth would be due to a combination of organic debris in dust stuck to the fiberglass surface (house dust contains skin cells and other organics) and moisture.

Regrettably I'm not optimistic about disinfection nor cleaning of mold contaminated fiberglass hvac ducts. If the total area were just a few inches I'd probably wipe gently or spray with a household disinfectant/cleaner and blot gently and then concentrate on addressing the controllable causes: filtration of the return air and control of moisture.

For large areas - many square feet or more, and for homes where occupants are at extra risk: elderly, immune compromise, asthmatic, infant, etc., I'd probably replace the ductwork.

While fiberglass is an excellent insulating and noise control material, because of these cleaning difficulties I prefer metal ductwork with insulation on its exterior. IF conditions are bad enough that you decide to replace some duct sections I'd consider that change.

At TEST KIT for DUST, MOLD, PARTICLES: INSTRUCTIONS you can see how to use clear adhesive tape and a freezer-type ziplok bag to collect suspected mold samples.

When this test procedure is being used to screen for mold, the location selected for testing is very important: it should be representative of the largest or most-likely dominant mold or suspect-particle reservoir, chosen by location, size, and other visual properties.

Duct Surface Test Lab Analysis Results: observations of tape samples of suspected mold inside fiberglass HVAC ductwork

White deposits on fiberglass HVAC Duct interior (C) Inspectapedia.com JC

[Click to enlarge any image] Above: sample 1 mold test location on the floor of the HVAC duct. Click to enlarge to see the position of the adhesive tape used to collect this mold test sample.

Fiberglass-lined HVAC Duct Sample #1 sample information

Fiberglass-lined HVAC Duct Mold Test Sample Results

Fiberglass duct  surface mold test results (C) Daniel Friedman InspectApedia.com Fiberglass duct  surface mold test results (C) Daniel Friedman InspectApedia.com

Above first photo: sample 1, Cladosporium sp. fungal spores and hyphal fragments. These conditions confirm active fungal growth. This is not simply an air deposit of mold spores.

Above second photo, sample 1, hyaline (colorless) spores and spore chains, generically "Amerospores" but more likely Pen/Asp spores in this sample. Other unidentified mold spores. Hyphal fragments. Typical indoor dust debris. Pen/Asp spores in chains confirm nearby fungal growth of one or both of these mold genera.

Fiberglass-lined HVAC Duct Sample #2 sample information

White deposits on fiberglass HVAC Duct interior (C) Inspectapedia.com JC

Above: sample 2 mold test location on the upper surface of the interior of the HVAC duct.

[Click to enlarge any image]

Fiberglass-lined HVAC Duct Mold Test Sample Result Conclusions

In the two mold samples on adhesive tape we found evidence of the following molds:

  1. Penicillium/Aspergillus spores in long spore chains consistent with active nearby fungal growth.
  2. Aspergillus sp. conidiophores and mold spores
  3. Cladosporium sp. - very common in building air handlers and ductwork, commonly allergenic. Occasionally pathogenic.
  4. Penicillium sp. conidiophores and mold spores
  5. Trichoderma-like fungal spore clusters.
  6. Wallemia-like fungal spore chains.

Lab photos of these duct mold test findings and observations are provided in this article.

Warnings: When Aspergillus or Penicillium spores are present in chains in indoor mold samples we can be confident that there is active fungal growth of these mold genera. When the conidiophores (mold producing growth structures) are present it is possible to separate the identification these two genera.

In these samples we found both types of conidiophores. At high levels in building air either of these two mold genera are potentially serious health hazards.

Without a more extensive inspection of the building and its HVAC systems and ductwork to determine the total extent of mold growth by area and type, we cannot conclude the level of actual health hazard to building occupants. I recommend that further inspection of the building and its HVAC system be performed.

Fiberglass duct  surface mold test results (C) Daniel Friedman InspectApedia.com Fiberglass duct  surface mold test results (C) Daniel Friedman InspectApedia.com

[Click to enlarge any image]

Above first photo, sample 1, long hyaline spore chains, Wallemia serbi-like but possibly desiccated Pen/Asp spores. Other typical indoor air debris.

Above second photo sample 1, dense profusion of Cladosporium sp. fungal spores and some hyphal fragments.

Fiberglass duct  surface mold test results (C) Daniel Friedman InspectApedia.com Fiberglass duct  surface mold test results (C) Daniel Friedman InspectApedia.com

Above first photo, sample 1, typical fiberglass fibers with dark debris, normal in indoor fiberglass duct surfaces.

Above second photo sample 1, Cladosporium sp. fungal spores and some hyphal fragments.

Other photographs illustrating the appearance of white or light colored mold in buildings are

at WHITE MOLD PHOTOS

Fiberglass duct  surface mold test results (C) Daniel Friedman InspectApedia.com Fiberglass duct  surface mold test results (C) Daniel Friedman InspectApedia.com

Above first photo, sample 1, Aspergillus-like conidiophore and hyphae at upper left, Penicillium-like conidiophore at lower right.

Above second photo sample 1, Penicillium sp. conidiophore.

Fiberglass duct  surface mold test results (C) Daniel Friedman InspectApedia.com Fiberglass duct  surface mold test results (C) Daniel Friedman InspectApedia.com

Above first photo, sample 2, Aspergillus sp. conidiophore (photo center) hyphae (photo upper left).

Above second photo sample 2, Cladosporium sp. in dense fungal growth on the surface.

What to do about mold contamination in ductwork

Watch out: The reader's photos showing the duct interior looks very moldy over more than just a trivial area; it's likely that this is itself a significant mold reservoir and of course there may be hidden mold on the cavity side of drywall that got wet from the leaks you show.

Large reservoirs of Aspergillus sp., possibly Penicillium sp. and possibly Cladosporium sp. (depending on the species in this case) are likely to be health hazards to building occupants, can even healthy non-allergic people to become sensitized to mold, and for people who are asthmatic, allergic, immune impaired, elderly, infant, or otherwise at risk for respiratory illness, such mold contamination can be a serious hazard.

The type of ductwork in these photos, fiberglass-panel constructed ducts (as well as any fiberglass lined ducts) cannot be effectively cleaned by conventional duct cleaning methods - most likely the ductwork needs to be replaced. But before risking contaminating new ductwork with airborne moldy dust, the building merits further investigation.

Please see DUCT CLEANING ADVICE for guidance on cleaning mold-contaminated HVAC ductwork.

Question: any lawsuits or class action over HVAC insulating duct boards?

(Aug 26, 2014) Maggie said:
Are there any type of lawsuits for duct boards?

Insurance won't pay anything for the remediation of my home and I am at a loss on where to even start - no one seems to be able to tell me the source of my leak or what has caused the contamination or how long I've had the mold growth and I am now being told my whole house needs to be remediated because it's blown throughout the duct work for who knows how long and the levels are off the charts

Reply:

Maggie,

I'm doubtful that lawsuits are the best place to start attacking the problem you describe. I'd start by hiring either an experienced building inspector or HVAC system technician to diagnose the problem you face, including its cause, providing evidence and documentation, not just "opinion" lest you get nowhere. If necessary you may need an independent insurance adjuster to help out.

From just your note we don't know what contamination is the concern, nor how we know what's been blown through the building, at what levels, and causing what need for further cleaning.

(Aug 26, 2014) Anonymous said:

Thanks Dan. I have actually had all the mold testing along with air samples done and that's how I know it's all throughout my house. I have the type of mold and the counts etc. The insurance adjuster is coming to see if there's any possibility of them paying for any of it - but they say there's slim to no chance of them paying for any of it and if they do it is a minimal amount of the cleanup.

I am in the process of getting estimates from 3 mold remediation companies and an estimate from a HVAC company for replacement of the duct board and/or whole system. I spoke to a real estate agent about "resale" values and the effect of mold in the home and he is actually the one who suggested researching if there were any lawsuits relating to duct boards since insurance doesn't pay for anything etc. I did a google search but came up with nothing. The cost is very prohibitive to wanting to get your house clean so it's all pretty discouraging.

Reply:

If your HO policy excludes mold damage you're not covered.

WATCH OUT: DO NOT allow a superficial inexpert "cleanup" if in fact there is a large area of mold contamination - inexpert work may further spread contamination and require still more professional and costly cleanup. Before proceeding with cleanup you need a reliable mold remediation plan defining the scope of work, containment, etc.

(Aug 27, 2014) Maggie said:

Yes the insurance company came out today to do their inspection and nothing is covered. I have 4 companies coming tomorrow to provide me with quotes. Two of them work with insurance companies all the time and are supposed to be two of the top mold removal companies (Rainbow Intl and ServPro) the other is Advanta and the 4th is AAS Restoration. If you've heard of any of these companies and have any reviews or thoughts on them I would appreciate any feedback. I've read Angies list reviews and other online reviews and really haven't seen too many bad reviews on any of them.

I also had a duct cleaning service come in that was NADCA certified and they were telling me about some type of service that they spray and paint and the manufacturer of the product guarantees no new regrowth or old leaks of mold for 10 years. I'm guessing this would be the cheapest but not sure if it is the most effective.

If you have an opinion on that too I would appreciate your input. ServPro also told me they use a different testing company because the mold inspection company I used tends to be very "over the top" with their recommendations. For instance because my readings on the 3rd floor were high they suggested having the whole house HEPA vaccumed. ServPro suggested the whole house may not require "total cleaning"

He stated some companies will then try to tell you you have to have absolutely everything cleaned or thrown away - like sheets, clothes and if you have a stuffed animal it would be thrown away. Tables could be cleaned but some furniture couldn't - so sometimes the "over the top" recommendations are not necessary and companies may try to get me to do more than necessary.

Not sure if you have thoughts on that either but if I do the minimum cleaning - in other words replace duct work clean extremely high level areas with HEPA vacuuming etc. how much damage will I leave if I don't HEPA clean whole house. I of course realize these are all broad opinions on items that you are not seeing or reports you are reading. Thank.

Reply: "throw everything away" is usually inappropriate advice

I agree with your ServPro rep that "throw everything away" is usually inappropriate advice. Some items such as hard surface items are usually easily cleaned; some soft goods can be laundered or dry cleaned. Other items such as water damaged carpets, padding, drywall, upholstered couches are tossed out.

Question: white dust in fiberglass HVAC ducts: Efflorescence?

On 2019-07-13 by Morgan

Hi - reading a lot on this website as we are renters in a 3-level (w/ HVAC unit in 4th level crawl space) town home in NC. I independently hired an air duct cleaning service, since I noticed that we were still wiping dust off of surfaces following some drywall repair and I have bad allergies.

The cleaning never started though, since the guy went up to the unit, looked inside the plenum box and suspects there is mold/other growth that needs to be remediate before cleaning can be done.

Couple of things/prior events to keep in mind:
Approx 6 months ago: HVAC utility drain clogged and was running over for a few weeks. We only picked it up due to a leak down on the 1st floor that was coming through drywall.

Approx 3 months ago: ServPro brought in to remove damaged drywall and bring in dryer fans. Drywall was replaced and sanded and painted (hence the dust mentioned above).

Approx 1 month ago: noticed another leak on 1st floor. This one resulted in replacement of HVAC system (coils were dirty, lines freezing over thus causing leak).

This week: duct cleaning service came out but could not proceed further. HVAC company that installed new unit came out and looked at plenum box, saying it is probably efflorescence growing in the fiberglass box due to sediment from the water that runs through the unit. Unit is on 4th floor, in an unconditioned crawl space so during summer months it is hot and humid up there.

I welcome your thoughts on situation and whether you’d recommend a test for mold. Property manager is slow to act, and given I have allergies (esp to mold), I don’t want to just sit around and wait. Photos also attached.

On 2019-07-13 Reply by (mod) -

It's not efflorescence. That conclusion tells us that the person asserting that is not well informed.

Efflorescence is a mineral salt left behind when water leaches through *masonry* materials such as brick, concrete, stone as water, passing through the masonry, dissolves minerals, then evaporates from the surface, leaving minerals behind.

See EFFLORESCENCE SALTS & WHITE DEPOSITS if you want to know more about that - but it has *nothing* to do with HVAC ducts.

If there was drywall work including sanding, and if the HVAC system air handlers were running during that time, it'd be no surprise to find white gypsum dust deposits in the ductwork, supply and return plenums, and on the blades of the blower fan.

Unfortunately, fiberglass lined ducts cannot be physically cleaned - trying to do so damages the fiberglass surface and ruins it, causing subsequent fiberglass shedding, a small reduction in air flow and increased rate of particle trapping.

Gypsum dust alone trapped in the ductwork isn't particularly dangerous. That same dust (or other dirt) could explain clogging of condensate drains that led to leaks - something worth investigating.

IF the duct interiors have been wet then the combination of water + organic dust and debris normally found on duct surfaces (principally skin cells and fabric fibers) invites mold growth. If mold is growing in / on fiberglass ducts the cause needs to be corrected, the air handler cleaned, and the ducts replaced. (They cannot be cleaned, and in my experience and opinion, magic-bullet spray coatings are unreliable).

If you see other material than what's obvious drywall dust and suspect it's mold, collect a tape sample for lab analysis.

See TAPE & BULK SAMPLING & TESTS for MOLD to see how easily that's done.

I would not have "air tests" done - as that approach is highly inaccurate and also not diagnostic. If you want to know more about that problem

see AIRBORNE PARTICLE COUNTS in DUCTWORK.

Finally, when there have been leaks wetting building materials, particularly ones that may be mold friendly such as insulation, drywall, wood, the investigator who defines the presence of a problem needing attention also needs to define the scope of work, the extent of cleanup needed, and after the work is done, that person, who must be independent of the company doing the work, confirms that the cleanup was complete and the problem cause found and fixed.

Mold-Contaminated Fiberglass Duct Research

Help for detecting & testing mold contamination in HVAC ductwork.


...

Continue reading at WHY DOES MOLD GROW in INSULATION? or select a topic from the closely-related articles below, or see the complete ARTICLE INDEX.

Or see these

Recommended Articles

Suggested citation for this web page

FIBERGLASS AIR DUCT MOLD TEST at InspectApedia.com - online encyclopedia of building & environmental inspection, testing, diagnosis, repair, & problem prevention advice.


Or see this

INDEX to RELATED ARTICLES: ARTICLE INDEX to MOLD CONTAMINATION & REMEDIATION

Or use the SEARCH BOX found below to Ask a Question or Search InspectApedia

Ask a Question or Search InspectApedia

Try the search box just below, or if you prefer, post a question or comment in the Comments box below and we will respond promptly.

Search the InspectApedia website

Note: appearance of your Comment below may be delayed: if your comment contains an image, photograph, web link, or text that looks to the software as if it might be a web link, your posting will appear after it has been approved by a moderator. Apologies for the delay.

Only one image can be added per comment but you can post as many comments, and therefore images, as you like.
You will not receive a notification
when a response to your question has been posted.
Please bookmark this page to make it easy for you to check back for our response.
Our Comment Box is provided by Countable Web Productions countable.ca

Comment Form is loading comments...

Citations & References

In addition to any citations in the article above, a full list is available on request.



ADVERTISEMENT