Question? Just ask us!
Free Encyclopedia of Building & Environmental Inspection, Testing, Diagnosis, Repair
InspectAPedia ® Home
AIR HANDLER / BLOWER UNITS
AIRBOUND HEAT SYSTEM REPAIR by WATER FEED VALVE
BACKDRAFTING HEATING EQUIPMENT
BACKUP HEAT for HEAT PUMPS
BLOWER FAN OPERATION & TESTING
BOOKSTORE - InspectAPedia
CIRCULATOR PUMPS & RELAYS
CONVECTOR HEATERS - HYDRONIC COILS
COOL OFF HEAT, THERMOSTAT SWITCH
DEFINITION of HEATING & COOLING TERMS
DIAGNOSTIC GUIDES A/C / HEAT PUMP
DIAGNOSE & FIX HEATING PROBLEMS-BOILER
DIAGNOSE & FIX HEATING PROBLEMS-FURNACE
DUCT SYSTEM & DUCT DEFECTS
ELECTRIC MOTOR OVERLOAD RESET SWITCH
ELECTRICAL POWER SWITCH FOR HEAT
FAN, AIR HANDLER BLOWER UNIT
FAN AUTO ON THERMOSTAT SWITCH
FAN, COMPRESSOR/CONDENSER UNIT
FAN CONVECTOR HEATERS - HYDRONIC COILS
FAN LIMIT SWITCH
FLOODED HEATING EQUIPMENT REPAIR
HEATING LOSS DIAGNOSIS-BOILERS
HEATING LOSS DIAGNOSIS-FURNACES
HEATING SYSTEM INSPECT DIAGNOSE REPAIR
LOW VOLTAGE BUILDING WIRING
LOW VOLTAGE TRANSFORMER TEST
MANUALS & PARTS GUIDES - HVAC
NO HEAT - BOILER
NO HEAT - FURNACE
ODORS FROM HEATING SYSTEMS
OIL FILTERS on HEATING EQUIPMENT
PULSE COMBUSTION HEATERS
RESET SWITCH, HEATER PRIMARY CONTROL
RESET SWITCH, HEATER REPAIR
RESET SWITCH, ELECTRIC MOTOR
RESET SWITCH, STACK RELAY
STEAM HEATING SYSTEMS
THERMOSTATS, HEATING / COOLING
THERMOSTATS, WATER HEATER
THERMOSTATIC EXPANSION VALVES
ZONE VALVES, HEATING
Thermostat heat anticipator function & adjustment guide: this article explains what a heat anticipator is on a wall thermostat, where to find it, what it looks like, why we adjust the heat anticipator, how we do so.
We list the recommended heat anticipator settings. We explain how to test the heat anticipator on a thermostat, and we describe the conditions necessary for a heat anticipator on a room thermostat to work properly in the first place. We also explain the difference between the job of the thermostat heat anticipator and the differential settings on a heating system aquastat or similar control.
We also discuss when you do or do not need a thermostat that includes a heat anticipator device, modern alternative thermostat controls, and where to buy a thermostat with a heat anticipator feature. Our page top photo illustrates key parts of a traditional room thermostat including the temperature sensing device, thermostat switch, and the heat anticipator assembly.
Green links show where you are. © Copyright 2015 InspectApedia.com, All Rights Reserved.
What is a thermostat heat anticipator? The purpose of a thermostat heat anticipator is to "de-sensitize" the thermostat so that when actual room temperature is hovering close to the set temperature on the thermostat, the thermostat switch won't keep switching the air conditioner or heating system on and off too often - which can damage the equipment.
In our photo you can see our pointer hovering over fine wires wound around a triangular piece of plastic (forming a variable resistor) and you can see at center of the photo a flat copper arm which can be moved to slide a contact to different positions along the wound variable resistor.
The triangular pointer at the top of the copper arm has an opening which helps read the exact position to which the heat anticipator has been set. Behind the pointer you can see a silver scale with different amp readings which are detailed in the table below. On this heat anticipator setting scale settings range from 0.10 to about 2 Amps.
The heat anticipator scale: If you click to enlarge this photo you can see the amperage level to which this heat anticipator had been set when we took this picture. It is below the lowest setting recommended by Honeywell.
Which Way Do I Move the Heat Anticipator Adjustment?
Take another look at the finely-wound and flattened wire coil underneath the movable copper arm in our photo just above and at our adapted Honeywell T87 heat anticipator sketch at left. [Click to enlarge this or any InspectApedia illustration].
The shortest burner-on time will be when the heat anticipator puts out the most heat. This warms up the thermostat's room temperature sensor and therefore tells the thermostat the room is up to set temperature earliest.
As we elaborate below, ccording to Honeywell, setting the heat anticipator to a lower number setting will result in shorter burner on-cycles, ie less room-temperature overshoot
The longest burner-on time will be when the heat anticipator puts out the least heat, thus does not turn off heat early, thus lets the burner keep running longer
Watch out: be sure to look at both the direction of the arrow and at the amperage numbers. Depending on your model thermostat and where the heat anticipator is found, left and right or up and down might be reversed from the images here, and some of the thermostat heat anticipators we examined have only a numeric scale, no arrows, so it's important to follow the manufacturer's instructions.
Still it is useful and interesting to understand the principles involved. Below we compare instructions for the Honeywell T87 and the Honeywell CT87 room thermostats, each of which gives similar instructions for which way to move the heat anticipator indicator - up to a higher number for a longer burner on-cycle.
Below we provide specific heat anticipator setting recommendations as well as a description of which way to move the heat anticipator lever to change the thermostat's behavior to address room temperature overshoot. You will see that Honeywell's own instructions contradict one another depending on the thermostat model.
If however you are an installer and want to precisely set up the heat anticipator on a thermostat (if your thermostat has this feature), there are two approaches:
Our sketch, above left, adapted from a Flair APVO2 two-wire thermostat whose the heat anticipator level and scale (red arrow) on the left side of the device. Interestingly the company referred to this as a "fixed anticipation" thermostat, but its installation instructions indicated a screw-secured heat anticipator pointer and an amperage scale on the device. This thermostat was designed for use with zone valves or damper actuators..
Watch out: as Honeywell warns thermostat installers:
This thermostat has an adjustable heat anticipator and will operate properly only if this [heat anticipator resistor] heater is adjusted to match the current of the valve or relay. See HEAT ANTICIPATOR MINI AMMETER TEST for details.
Set the heat anticipator to the heating boiler or furnace manufacturer's recommendation, or if you don't know that number, you can either leave the heat anticipator at its factory setting (recommended) or you can use a mini-ammeter to actually measure the heating thermostat circuit and to fine tune the heat anticipator setting, as we discuss further
For the Honeywell T87F the manufacturer's heat anticipator setting instructions are as follows:
For a detailed explanation of how the thermostat heat anticipator actually works
Honeywell's Instructions for Setting the Heat Anticipator
Heat Anticipator Setting Direction for the Honeywell Traditional T87 Round® Thermostat
Using the Honeywell T87 Thermostat instructions (see [3a] in REFERENCES] as an example, and quoting:
According to Honeywell, set the heat anticipator to a lower number to let the heat run shorter or make the room a bit cooler in relation to the set point on the thermostat by avoiding room temperature "overshoot" as additional heat arrives in the room by radiation from heating baseboards or furnace run-on time after the burner on the boiler or furnace has been stopped by the thermostat.
According to Honeywell, set the heat anticipator to a higher number to cause the burner to run longer - with a longer on-cycle.
When we adjust the heat anticipator on a thermostat that has one, we are fine-tuning the amount of heat anticipation that the device is allowing.
Watch out: Some modern DMMs that include a clamp-on ammeter might measure accurately down into the very few milliamp range that is needed, but most do not. In its instructions for using a mini milli-amp meter (described in detail
Heat Anticipator Setting Direction for the Honeywell CT87A,B,J Round® Thermostat
Using the Honeywell CT87A,B,J Round® Thermostat instructions (see [3b] in REFERENCES] as an example, and quoting:
NOTE: If the furnace stays on beyond the thermostat set temperature,
If the furnace shuts off before the set temperature is reached, move the anticipator pointer up by .1 ampere.
Never adjust the anticipator below .3 ampere. [3b]
You'll notice that the word "Longest" and the arrow shown in the earlier T87 Thermostat heat anticipator sketch are not shown in this Honeywell illustration, but the explanation of which way to move the heat anticipator indicator for a longer burner on-time remain the same as for the T87: for longer burner on time move the heat anticipator indicator to a higher number on the scale.
Question: which way to adjust the heat anticipator settings?
Lower heat anticipator settings: according to Honeywell, setting the heat anticipator to a lower number (lower Amps number) setting will result in shorter burner on-cycles, ie less room-temperature overshoot.
Higher heat anticipator settings: according to the manufacturer, a higher heat anticipator setting will result in less self heating of the thermostat, longer burner on-cycles, and possible overshoot of the room temperature. - Chubby541 10/31/2012
Reply: heat anticipator setting numbers versus heat-on cycles
Thanks Chubby for prompting us to make sure that our explanation of the thermostat heat exchanger is precisely accurate and more clear.
As you can see in our closeup photo of the heat anticipator adjustment scale, the word "Longer" and an arrow are stamped into the end of the scale with the lowest number. The arrow points away from the low end towards the high end of the scale.
[Click to enlarge any image]
The heat anticipator is an electrical resistance heater that provides a tiny source of extra heat right inside the wall thermostat of some older room thermostats like the Honeywell T87 bimetallic spring mercury bulb model.
Heat anticipators are found in the T87® and the CT97A,T,J Round® room thermostats by Honeywell as well as in some other thermostat brands discussed here.
Making a little extra heat inside the thermostat means that the thermostat thinks the room is a little warmer than it actually is - which leads the thermostat to stop calling for heat a little early - hence the name "heat anticipator". The thermostat is anticipating that some additional heat will arrive into the room after it turns off the boiler.
More heat inside the thermostat means sooner burner off time (shorter burner on-cycles) and less room heat overshoot.
Reader Follow-Up: moving the heat anticipator to lower numbers gave shorter burner on-time
The Honeywell documentation is correct. Moving the anticipator to the RIGHT, i.e. LOWER current numbers, results in SHORTER cycle time. Why am I so sure?
1. Just tried it with my forced hot air system; moved from 0.8 to 0.4. It turns on/off twice as often now.
2. The current numbers on the anticipator aren't how much current it's generating (really, how would it do that?), it's how much current it's EXPECTING.
At lower settings, it is EXPECTING less current; since the amount of current the BOILER produces is constant, this results in more Joule heating of the anticipator and a faster cycle. 3. That "LONGER" text? Yeah, look more closely. It's got an arrow POINTING TO THE LEFT. It's too fuzzy to see in your picture; look on a real device. - C.K. 11/30/2013
The arrow does not point toward higher resistance, it points toward higher EXPECTED CURRENT (those are measurements in Amperes, as you correctly note!) and hence LOWER RESISTANCE: if the current coming from the boiler is HIGHER, the anticipator needs LESS resistance to produce the same amount of heat. (This is simply keeping I²R, i.e. the total heat output, constant.)
Thanks C.K. I'm not sure about your interpretation of "expecting" and anticipation, but Honeywell agrees with you about which way to move the heat anticipator setting for longer or shorter burner on-cycles.
Please click on any InspectApedia image to see a larger, more detailed image, including showing the arrow on the heat anticipator. And in the REFERENCES section of this article you can find a link to the installation instructions for the Honeywell T87F from which we quote above. I agree with you about the direction of the arrow you cite.
Honeywell Corporation agrees that lowering the heat anticipator from 0.8 to 0.4 will give shorter heat on-times which, in turn, would typically result in more frequent burner on-off cycling - which is on an oil fired system and on some gas fired systems a less efficient way to run a heater.
In their T87 Honeywell states that a higher number on their heat anticipator scale gives a longer burner on-time.
And again in their CT87A,B,J Round Thermostat instructions Honeywell also states that moving the heat anticipator up will give the burner a longer on time.
In preparing the original article and for confirmation of our understanding of heat and electrical resistance and thus of how the heat anticipator actually works, I checked with Dr. Jess Aronstein, an electrical engineer specializing in forensic work. Jess confirmed that by moving the pointer along a copper-wound coil (the heat anticipator body) we are changing the electrical resistance, and that more resistance produces more heat. The numbers and resistance and heat effects in the original manufacturer's instructions can be a bit confusing.
In answer to your question of how the heat anticipator would know how much current it is generating, it is not generating current. The heat anticipator is a variable resistor. It is resisting current flow and generating heat. The heat from the variable resistor warms the thermostat sensing bimetallic spring, thus fooling the thermostat into thinking the room is warmer than it actually is. The heat anticipator is anticipating that additional heat is going to arrive in the room from water (or less-so by air flow).
We are measuring current as resistance or Amps at different points along a wound resistance coil. The scale on the heat anticipator corresponds roughly to the position along the coil at which the moving contact touches the coil.
Moving the point of contact to a place where electricity has run through more wire means more resistance, while less wire means less resistance. [Test & confirmation needed on this statement - Ed.]
Bottom line: by anticipating additional heat arrival (hence the device name "heat anticipator") and by shutting off the burner a bit sooner than otherwise, the heat anticipator is reducing room temperature overshoot - warming the room higher than the thermostat requested.
Reader question: the physics of resistance vs amps vs heat anticipators
(Feb 26, 2014) Bill Martino said:
Thank you for the clarification, Bill. This topic has generated many comments, which underscores how confusing it can be for some readers.
We see on the Heat Anticipator adjuster scale photos in the article above that at the lowest number on the scale the imprint indicates longer burner-on time.
Longer burner on time has to be due to less heat coming off of the heat anticipator (less add-on warming of the thermostat's temperature sensor).
(Nov 17, 2014) RH in CT said:
RH the thermostat should not be making you laugh - nor cycling on and off as you describe. I'd check further. Check for shorted thermostat wires.
16 Jan 2015 ReyAlonzo91 said: - inconsistency in heat anticipater guidelines
The second picture on this page shows a 1.2A setting for shorter burner on-cycles and a 0.1A setting for longer burner on-cycles. But while reading down the page I find "setting the heat anticipator to a lower number setting will result in shorter burner on-cycles... a higher heat anticipator setting will result in less self heating of the thermostat, longer burner on-cycles." So which is it?
Thanks Rey, indeed contradictions between stampings and the manufacturers' instructions and HVAC techs' opinions have long plagued this topic and the detail of the arrow and the heat anticipation.
Bottom line: we have to trust that Honeywell, the manufacturer, knows how their equipment works.
According to Honeywell, setting the heat anticipator to a lower number setting [Lower current stated in Amps] will result in shorter burner on-cycles, ie less room-temperature overshoot.
The confusion is in the details of current flow, resistance, and generated heat.
More heat being generated at the heat anticipator will warm the thermostat temperature sensor (a bimetallic spring in older thermostats) sooner or faster so more heat at the heat anticipator will turn off the burner sooner, thus giving us a slightly shorter burner on-cycle.
Joule's first Law says that "The amount of heat released is proportional to the square of the current". Or from one of several articles on this including Wikipedia (01/16/2015), ... "[Joule] deduced that the heat produced [in a length of wire] was proportional to the square of the current multiplied by the electrical resistance of the wire."
But there's more to be said ....
In general, the lower the resistance of a length of wire the smaller is the voltage drop across the wire, and the lower will be the heat generated for a given or fixed load.
Moving the heat anticipator slider is basically selecting a longer or shorter wire length where longer = more resistance and vice versa. So why, if we slide the anticipator to the low end (lower Amperage or current) and presumably towards a shorter wire length, would we see more heat rather than less heat?
IF we double the length of a wire (move the slider to send the same current through a longer wire at the heat anticipator) we double the resistance.
Heat generated per unit time (i.e., power, as in Watts per second) is given by
V is the voltage across the wire,
R is the wire resistance, and
I is the current.
Note that current and voltage are related by
Finally, from the Physics Forum we get some help explaining Honeywell's instructions:
Should I Change the Heat Anticipator Settings?
It's probably smartest to leave the heat anticipator alone on your thermostat unless you're having a specific problem controlling room temperature. And then, before attacking the heat anticipator setting, check first for more significant problems such as a bad thermostat location (on a cold exterior wall, or in the direct path of warm air from a forced warm air supply register).
Well you may not need a heat anticipator. As we discuss in detail immediately below, for many types of heating system distribution, heat source, and heat controls, you don't need a heat anticipator, while for certain types of heating systems (such as those using heavy cast iron radiators) using a heat anticipator can provide important improvements in heating system operation. But first let's define three thermostat heat anticipator categories:
Reasons to Buy A Wall Thermostat that Includes a Heat Anticipator feature
Heating distribution systems that have high thermal mass (cast iron radiators or cast-iron baseboards) tend to continue emitting heat after the boiler shuts down - thus possibly heating the room well past the thermostat's set temperature.
Popularly, this phenomenon is called temperature overshoot. On the other hand, an improperly adjusted or installed thermostat can also cause too-frequent burner on-off cycles, wasting heating fuel.
In these cases we can use a heat anticipator-equipped thermostat to advantage.
Other heating systems with thermal mass such as an in-floor radiant heat system, particularly if the floor is a concrete slab or a blockbed solar heat system might also benefit from a room thermostat that has a heat anticipator function.
But we notice that at least some thermostats sold for radiant floor heating, such as the OJ programmable floor thermostats UTN-4991 and the OJ UDG-4999 (shown at left), designed to monitor both floor temperature and air temperature, do not include a heat anticipator.
Question: Helpful Pointers Heat-Anticipators... [other text relocated to pertinent article]
3. Heat-anticipators are typically only found in mechanical (non-digital) thermostats. Whenever installing or servicing a thermostat with a heat-anticipator, the amperage setting on the heat-anticipator should always be verified as matching the amperage draw on the gas valve or relay that it controls. Otherwise the relay or thermostat may not function properly.
- Helpful Pointers Regarding 24V T 10/27/2012
Helpful, thanks so much for the detailed tips on wiring 24-volt room thermostats. I've inserted your remarks into the main article body over at THERMOSTAT WIRE CONNECTIONS -
and in that article beginning in a new section at
Actually, though, a recent search (2013) found that there are indeed contemporary digital and programmable thermostats that do include a heat anticipator, though I agree that many models do not include that feature. In a later FAQ just below we point out the types of heating systems that do and don't benefit from a heat anticipator function in a room thermostat.
Working together and exchanging information makes us better informed than any individual can be working alone. - Ed
Types of Heat for Which You Do Not Need a Thermostat with a Heat Anticipator
Low thermal mass heating systems: other heating distribution systems that have low thermal mass (copper tubing baseboard) or no thermal mass (warm air heat and ductwork) stop emitting heat quickly (thin wall copper baseboard) or immediately (forced warm air heat) when the boiler or furnace is shut off by the thermostat. Those systems don't need and don't benefit from a heat anticipator.
Fan coil type heating systems are, like forced warm air heaters, an "on-off" type heat with no significant thermal mass. You'll find that thermostats sold for use with fan coil heaters, like PECO's TA180-001 digital programmable thermostat do not include a heat anticipator.
Similarly, electric baseboard heat thermostats or electric floor heating mat thermostats typically won't include heat anticipators, though you can purchase thermostats with varying degrees of room temperature variation such as +/1 1 °F or +/3 3 °F.
Shown at above left is the Honeywell T498B1512 120V wall thermostat used for electric baseboard heat. ($50.) This thermostat is designed to maintain heat within a temperature differential of +/- 3 degrees F.
If you need to control electric heat and want a more narrow temperature differential range, check out the Honeywell TL7235A100 non-programmable line voltage digital thermostat or the White Rodgers line voltage snap action room thermostat model 1A65-641 that controls temperatures to +/- 1 degree F. ($40.) or for a programmable electric heat thermostat see the Dayton 1UHG4 line voltage thermostat. Electric heat thermostats are discussed
Non-bounce thermostats: a second type of improvement in heating thermostat controls may also have obviated the need for heat anticipators.
A second reason (besides room temperature overshoot) for the original inclusion of heat anticipators was to allow the installer to widen or narrow the precision of the "on-off" response of the wall thermostat. This prevented a thermostat from bouncing rapidly between on-and off which could happen if the thermostat was both very sensitive to room temperature and the room temperature changed too rapidly. Modern thermostats are quite reliable at holding to a +/1 one degree temperature range.
Homes with stable indoor temperatures: after super-insulating our lab with blown-in foam insulation, we found that its temperature remains very stable - the building is slow to cool down and slow to warm up as outdoor temperatures change. The single largest factor is probably the elimination of uncontrolled air leakage.
Many modern homes are better insulated so cool off more slowly so temperature changes more slowly, and in some homes installers have got smart enough in locating the wall thermostat that it's not placed on a cold outside wall nor in direct path of blowing hot or cold air.
What happened to the bimetallic spring and mercury bulb in thermostats? What about the heat anticipator?
Modern digital room thermostats don't use a bimetallic spring to sense room temperature. And for environmental reasons (mercury is highly toxic) manufacturers no longer use a mercury bulb to control the switching of a wall thermostat.
Rather they use a solid state thermistor. A thermistor is a device whose electrical resistance changes in response to temperature. A microprocessor chip in the digital room thermostat converts that change in resistance to a temperature reading.
There are definitely modern wall thermostats that still use a heat anticipator, though its physical form has changed from the tiny coil over which a pointer slides to a thin wire mounted on a disc, still encompassing a movable arm that contacts the wire at different points along its length. The operating principle is the same: shorter wire, less resistance, less heating. Here are some room thermostats that include a heat anticipator:
Question: Where can I buy a room thermostat that has a heat anticipator? Big box stores don't carry thermostats that include a heat anticipator
Stopped at a local big box store and looked at the models on display, called Honeywell while there and was told that typical retail outlets like these DON'T carry thermostats that have anticipator functions or a heat control differential and they are set to stay within +/- 1 degree at all times. The Honeywell tech could not give me part numbers but said that those units are normally only sold to HVAC installers through their distributors. - Mike at Longmeadow MA
Reply: Where to Buy a Room Thermostat with a Heat Anticipator Feature
Thanks for this field report on the availability of room thermostats that include a heat anticipator.
You're sure right. I stopped by a local Home Depot store, checked out a local Radio Shack, and also shopped at the one remaining lumber yard/building supplier in our area who hasn't been driven out by big box store competition. None of them stocked a room thermostat that included a traditional heat anticipator, though some newer room thermostats provide a very similar function in the form of micro-toggle-switches inside the unit.
But it is in fact still easy to find a wall thermostat that includes a heat exchanger by a little careful shopping, as I detail below. I think part of what you heard from the Honeywell tech was less than clear or less than forthcoming. Or maybe s/he was not fully informed about the company's products. Or maybe the tech didn't even know what a heat anticipator is or why they are sometimes used in thermostats.
Following some explanation, just below at I include a list of room thermostats that include a heat anticipator - including Where to Buy a Room Thermostat with a Heat Anticipator g from Honeywell, Lux, Robertshaw and White-Rodgers. Perhaps you'll want to forward a copy of this article to the Honeywell "tech" with whom you spoke by telephone.
Recap of Thermostat Heat Anticipator Functions
A heat anticipator is basically a tiny heater placed inside of a room thermostat to slightly shorten the heat-on-cycle called for by the thermostat. The heat anticipator in the traditional Honeywell T87 thermostat and older models is a simple electrical resistance heater of very small size, placed close to the bimetallic spring that operated the thermostat.
The question of whether or not you need or should want a thermostat that includes a heat anticipator feature is discussed in the article above, at Do I need a thermostat with a heat anticipator?.
More Information about Heating System Controls
This article series on room thermostats and heat anticipators continues discussion of the basics of heating or cooling system thermostats, their use, setting, and adjustment. Here we provide A Guide to Finding, Using, and Adjusting Thermostats for Heating & Air Conditioning Furnaces & Boilers, Heat Pumps or Electric Furnaces or Boilers.
This article series answers most questions about central heating system troubleshooting, inspection, diagnosis, and repairs. We describe how to inspect, troubleshoot and repair heating and air conditioning systems to inform home owners, buyers, and home inspectors of common heating system defects.
The articles at this website describe the basic components of a home heating system, how to find the rated heating capacity of an heating system by examining various data tags and components, how to recognize common heating system operating or safety defects, and how to save money on home heating costs. We include product safety recall and other heating system hazards.
Continue reading at HEAT ANTICIPATOR Operation or select a topic from the More Reading links shown below.
Suggested citation for this web page
Green link shows where you are in this article series.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Question: heat cycling on and off when it should not
(Dec 6, 2014) dave said:
just got a new white Rodgers m150 thermostat and the furnace states a .75 anticipator heat setting so we set it at that and it comes on and off 3 times more now with this thermostat
Dave let's see if we can figure out why the thermostat is cycling heat more often: here are some things to check
- possible cold draft - e.g. through the wall
If you have the old TT and can reinstall it, if that behaves the same way as the new one (frequent cycling) then the issue is not in the thermostat itself
Question: heat anticipator repairs - not working
17 January 2015 ReyAlonzo91 said:
I've tried adjusting my heat anticipator setting to the lowest, highest, and even somewhere in the middle. No matter what I try, my wall heater comes on for only 2-3 minutes at a time and does this short cycle every 20 minutes or so. Would it be safe to simply put a toggle switch on my wall for the Red wire and White wire to be manually controlled?
Rather than installing a toggle switch I'd try first to debug the problem as there may be something else that needs attention for safety or reliability of the heating system.
First disconnect the thermostat completely and connect the thermosat terminals directly at the heater control board - which should be exactly the same as the thermostat calling for heat at the wall mounted thermostat location. If then the heater runs normally the trouble is in the thermosat, its settings, or its wiring. If the heater still short cycles then there is a problem with the heater that needs to be found and fixed.
In that case see these two articles above in More Reading
Question: early heat turn-off traced to bad thermocouple sensor
(Jan 21, 2015) ReyAlonzo91 said:
Thanks so much, Rey. I've learned from your reply too. I know that the thermocouple is sticking out there in the air but unlike a bimetallic spring that is easily clogged with dust, I hadn't considered that a thermocouple too might become debris blocked. Nice going.
See THERMOCOUPLES for help in replacing a failing thermocouple. Often we just clean off the tip of the thermocouple only to find that soon it fails again because the root problem was not soot but improper placement in the flame or a failed sensor itself.
Or if you actually were referring to the thermistor used as the temperature sensor on some room thermostats -
Question: should the heat anticipator on a room thermostat be called a compensator?
2 Feb 2015 Chuck Stutz said:
After reviewing the helpful information on Thermostat Anticipators, I wondered… wouldn’t a more appropriate name for the anticipator be “compensator”? By measuring the current at the thermostat, aren’t we really compensating for any current draw thru the controller and other components like zone valves and circulators on boilers or fans on forced air furnaces and their wiring?
I installed new thermostats and of course there was no documentation for the older controller to set the anticipator(s). After finding documentation on the newer Honeywell L8148E controller, the anticipator setting is shown to be .2.
Am I wrong with such a short cycle, the thermostat stops calling for heat too soon, closing the zone valve and shutting off the circulator, which never allows the residual water from the boiler to circulate after high limit on auquastat shuts off the burner reducing efficiency?
Reply: why is the heat anticipator called that? Causes & Effects of heater short-cycling.
Thanks for the interesting comments, Chuck. Indeed the topic of function and adjustment of heat anticipators in thermostats has draw lots of remarks from both homeowners and service techs who find the concept, operation, and instructions for heat anticipator adjustment a bit confounding.
You're right that the device is in a sense a compensator as you described it.
My guess is that the company chose the term "anticipator" most likely thinking that would be clear to normal people as it suggests that the thermostat is "anticipating" that the room heat is about to be reached and is turning off (stopping the call for heat) a bit in advance so as to reduce overheating of the space or "heat overshoot".
Because individual building heating system performance in heating cycle or heating temperature "overshoot" in the occupied space can vary due to a number of factors it is reasonable to change the heat anticipator if you find that heat is turning off too soon - under-shooting the thermostat setting. If adjustment doesn't prove satisfactory I'd look for a different problem in the heating system controls. A loose wire connection, intermittently-shorted thermostat wires, or poor thermal contact between the aquastat's sensor probe and the sensor well side can also cause odd on-off or cycling behaviour at a heating system.
I also agree very much with the principle that too-short burner on-cycles are inefficient (we don't heat up the combustion chamber enough to get complete combustion so we waste fuel and maybe with heating oil we also soot-up the system leading to operating trouble). But this sort of "too-short" on cycle depens on the fuel and burner design to define just what is "too short". In my experience, an oil fired heating system needs to be on for 5 minutes or longer to reach fully stable operating conditions.
Finally, let's separate some control functions. It's the burner-on time that defines the efficiency worry that I mentioned, not the ultimate temperature at which the burner turns off (though there is an argument that higher water temperatures in baseboards or radiators give more efficient heat transfer to the heated space).
Control wiring and designs vary but in general, if the thermostat stops calling for heat and the boiler temperature is above the LO/DIFF settings in an aquastat (designed to keep the boiler hot for the tankless coiul) then it's ok with me for the burner to shut off immediately. Letting it run to heat up the boiler if that boiler water is not going to circulate into the occupied space (because the room thermostat is satisfied) is unnecessary. Of course if we are not circulating water through the boiler and the burner continues to run, because the volume of water to be heated is then small, the burner won't run much longer anyway, even if it runs up to the HI.
Use the "Click to Show or Hide FAQs" link just above to see recently-posted questions, comments, replies, try the search box just below, or if you prefer, post a question or comment in the Comments box below and we will respond promptly.
Search the InspectApedia website
HTML Comment Box is loading comments...
Technical Reviewers & References