InspectAPedia®   -   Search InspectApedia

Moldy subfloor and joists may suggest additional hidden trapped mold contamination - © Daniel Friedman Hidden or Trapped Mold in Building Framing or Sheathing

What to Do About Trapped Mold Growth or Spore Contamination in Buildings

How to find hidden mold in buildings: trapped mold between building surfaces or materials.

The fact that mold is "hidden" in buildings does not mean one cannot find it. We look by context: where do we see leak stains, or where do we see building practices most likely to have produced a hidden leak or moisture problem?

Ice dam leaks in walls, hidden plumbing leaks, roof spillage by the foundation, are all common clues that often track to a wet building wall or ceiling cavity and from there to a hidden mold problem which may need to be addressed.

InspectAPedia tolerates no conflicts of interest. We have no relationship with advertisers, products, or services discussed at this website.

- Daniel Friedman, Publisher/Editor/Author - See WHO ARE WE?

Hidden Trapped Mold in Buildings: what to do about mold between wood framing, sheathing or other building surfaces

Test cuts for mold between flooring layers (C) Daniel Friedman

Our photo (left) illustrates how we made a test cut through subfloor from below, without damaging the finish flooring above, in order to inspect for trapped mold between layers of building floor materials after a flood. Details of this procedure are discussed later in this article.

[Click to enlarge any image]

Our page top photograph shows heavy mold contamination on floor joists and on the visible under-surface of subflooring? What about mold that may be present on the hidden top edge of these floor joists? Is that a problem that justifies demolition of the subfloor?

This document describes both opinion and direct field experience in finding, testing, and handling mold on hidden building surfaces such as between the upper surface of floor joists and the underside of the area of subfloor contacting the joist surface. Similar mold traps that form potential hidden mold reservoirs in buildings include:

In the photo at page top we see the results of a wall cut through drywall to expose wet moldy insulation, mold on the cavity side of drywall, and surprise! a leak in a pipe that the owner did not know was in her basement wall. However there was good evidence in the form of stains on the exposed side of this drywall. Look at the tan stain which is in the photo in the half-round shape directly above the wall cutout.

Don't try to investigate a building by dashing about with an axe cutting holes willy-nilly. That is an unnecessarily and inappropriately destructive approach to studying a property. But when building history, occupant complaints, or direct site observation of site and building conditions raise the level of probability of an important hidden leak or other damage, directed exploration, often with very modest means, can be very productive.

Guide to Testing, Handling, Killing, or Removing Hidden Mold Between Building Material Surfaces

What are the risks or other factors that provide justification for investigating a building for hidden mold contamination, and in particular, what factors might lead us to go to the trouble of invasive or destructive inspection, tests, or other studies to find hidden mold trapped between wood framing surfaces? Here are some key questions to ask about trapped mold in buildings?

Is Mold Trapped Between Wood Framing Surfaces a Risk to Building Occupants?

Roof mold photo (C) Daniel FriedmanIs trapped mold present at all? 

First, we don't know whether mold is present on mating wood surfaces such as between floor joists and subfloors, without destructive inspection to determine that presence as well as its extent.

We can inspect for mold between layers of subfloor or between subfloor and finish flooring by making test cuts from the underside of such surfaces, described at Photo Guide to using a round hole saw.

Our photograph of black mold on roof sheathing in an poorly-vented attic (left) displays a diagnostic history of the building, its moisture, and its attic mold. The vertical white stripes between areas of black mold on roof sheathing mark the location of previous wood framing that was removed (the roof was re-framed).

Because the light stripes mark areas where attic mold had not grown, we can see without doubt that the potential mold trap between the upper surface of the (now removed) rafters and the under-side of the roof sheathing (the white stripes) was precisely where attic mold did not grow.

The explanation of these white stripes on roof sheathing gives insight into the probability that troublesome mold growth is likely to be present or absent between the surface of a rafter or joist and the sheathing or subflooring that is attached to it.

An understanding of the moisture source and the moisture or water movement path in a specific building allows us to estimate the chance of hidden mold in the mating surfaces of wood framing and sheathing.

In this attic the moisture source was the building below. Poor attic venting trapped warm moist air in cold weather, leading to condensation on the exposed attic surfaces. Because the mating surfaces of rafter upper-sides and roof sheathing under-side were not exposed to attic air and attic condensation, the risk of mold formation on those mating surfaces was much less.

Are the Typical Quantity & Mobility of Trapped Mold on Wood Surfaces a Risk to Building Occupants

Unlike large mold reservoirs found in building wall cavities on the cavity side of drywall or in building insulation (these can be a problem in some buildings as air moves in and out of building cavities), mold trapped on mating surfaces such as between floor joist tops and subfloor undersides is very unlikely to be a hazard to building occupants.

We explain this view in more detail below. If however the mold is a species harmful to wood, causing rot and structural damage, further steps might be needed to protect the building.

For an example of mold harmful to buildings

see MERULIPORIA HOUSE EATING FUNGUS.

Field Experience Inspecting & Testing Mold on Inaccessible Mating Building Material Surfaces

Mold encapsulant spray (C) Daniel FriedmanTrapped mold not detected in building air, surface, or dust samples: We have studied this problem in a number of catastrophic mold cleanup projects where in early years people believed it was appropriate to disassemble such framing to expose the hidden surfaces.

Later we inspected and measured buildings where, for example, a subfloor was left intact, cleaned on all exposed surfaces, but with no attempt to remove subfloor to clean the contact area between the subfloor and the tops of floor joists.

The areas were thoroughly cleaned and thoroughly treated with a fungicidal sealant. In our field and lab investigations since 1986, where mold removal/cleaning and sealants were properly performed and applied, subsequent field tests have not detected mold spores nor other particles entering the building from those locations.

Correcting the cause of mold reduces the risk of further growth of trapped mold

If there was mold growth between a sill plate and subfloor, but the building is now dry, which is highly likely in a dry climate a year after dry-in of the building (use a moisture meter with pin sensors and/or a radio-signal type such as the Tramex™), there will be no measurable movement of mold spores or particles out into the building air from those spaces, regardless of whether you caulk or not.

That has been my field experience with carefully instrumented measurements, including using a vacuum pump to try to pull particles out of such areas - there is just not sufficient air movement in and out of such tight spaces.

Harmfulness of trapped mold may be unknown

Furthermore, seeing "mold" on the bottom of sill plates does not tell us anything about whether or not the mold is harmful or cosmetic - some cosmetic molds enter buildings at the time of construction, already present on wood. Nor does such an inspection indicate the possibility of such spores entering the living area.

Mold anxiety may lead to unnecessary mold cleanup or sealant costs

We realize that leaving "mold" in place even in on sealed surfaces is uncomfortable for people who have already some reason for feeling anxious about a building. Think of it like seeing a few small knots in a 2x4 wall stud. If the stud is able to perform its structural duty, few experienced builders would insist that only clear lumber (free of knots or other cosmetic defects) be used to frame a building.

The trapped mold may be blamed for other, more serious harmful mold or allergen reservoirs

If you continue to have an allergic reaction to such a building, we would suggest that you or your mold expert look for a problem mold or other particle reservoir that has not yet been identified, such as moldy insulation that looks "clean"

Future mold risk in buildings where mold cleanup has occurred

Finally, even after a building is inspected and tested for mold and allergens by a well qualified expert (if such testing is risk/cost justified) that is absolutely no guarantee against a future mold problem.

Proper construction in many details (roofing, insulation, ventilation, plumbing, site drainage, choice of materials, installation details), must be supplemented by proper building maintenance (leak prevention, rapid response to leaks and water entry) to avoid a future mold problem.

See MOLD PREVENTION GUIDE for detailed advice on prevention of mold contamination in buildings.

To evaluate the leak and moisture history of your building, 

the overall overall building risk for problematic mold contamination is discussed

at MOLD EXPOSURE RISK LEVELS.

When to Hire a Professional to inspect or test for mold?

MOLD / ENVIRONMENTAL EXPERT, HIRE ? helps consumers decide if it’s appropriate to bring in an mold professional - someone without conflicts of interest and who does not themselves offer mold cleanup or remediation services.

If there seem to be particularly high risks (building history, what you see, complaints or health risks of occupants) it might be appropriate to hire an expert

To Do your own sampling of surfaces or dust for evidence of problematic mold 

see MOLD TEST KITS for DIY MOLD TESTS, a detailed procedure that describes how to collect DIY samples of what you see (you wont' address hidden mold in insulation or in building cavities by this method) using tape sampling.

What about "killing" the hidden mold in place using bleach (see MOLD CLEANUP with BLEACH) heat (mold pasteurization),

ozone (see OZONE MOLD / ODOR TREATMENT WARNINGS) , or tenting and gases?

Heating mold to pasteurize it or using other mold killing methods is pretty much junk science sold by companies preying on consumer mold fear, as is "killing" it by any process since many particles remain allergenic or toxic, live or dead.

See MOLD KILLING GUIDE for an explanation of why mold killing attempts are usually a costly mistake.

OPM: Some Consultants Spend Other People's Money to Reduce Risk For the Consultants, not for the Clients

Extensive demolition for mold cleanup (C) Daniel FriedmanWith this as many topics, even smart people but with no actual field test data to support a view, construct mental models of what they think is happening (yet without a single fact nor shred of evidence) and give aggressive cleanup advice accordingly.

This approach is especially dangerous when the advice suffers what we call the "OPM" problem: that is, Ms. X, the consultant give advice that is safest for her (because the client cannot possibly complain in the future that her advice was not aggressive enough), because the safest (for her) advice does not cost her a dime - the client is the one who pays for the sometimes extreme measures that are suggested.

Consultants who offer OPM-based advice simply playing it safe and they are not earning their fee.

Our photograph (above left) shows extensive demolition performed to remove problem mold on floor framing and subflooring in an older home.

In this case the combination of multiple layers of moldy subflooring and flooring combined with a cost comparison of alternative approaches indicated that it was actually less costly to remove the subfloor and clean the joists than to leave the subfloor in place. In other buildings and circumstances it is reasonable and more economical to leave the subflooring in place.

Mold "Trapped" Between Wooden Building Material Surfaces - not readily accessible for cleaning without costly measures

The following questions were sent to InspectAPedia.com and suggested this article:

Inspecting Multiple Layers of Flooring & Subfloors or Wall Studs & Sheathing for Hidden Mold

Test cuts for mold between flooring layers (C) Daniel Friedman

Our two photographs demonstrate a procedure we use to inspect for evidence of high levels of mold trapped between layers of flooring and subflooring in a building.

Test cuts for mold between flooring layers (C) Daniel Friedman

Detailed suggestions for deciding when such inspections are appropriate and how to conduct hidden mold in flooring are located in a separate article:

HIDDEN MOLD in FLOOR / SUB-FLOOR.

When to Make Strip Cuts to Look for Hidden Mold in Building Ceilings or Walls

When there is an ongoing building complaint that makes us suspect hidden leaks or mold, if we strongly suspect a hidden mold problem but have not found its precise location, on occasion it is justified to make a "strip cut" across multiple wall studs or ceiling joists, exposing multiple wall cavities.

What makes a lot of sense sense is to study the building carefully to decide on the building points at most risk of having been wet from leaks due to construction details or other site observations. That's where one would make a test cut.

Small amounts of mold can be removed simply by cleaning or removing infected materials, something most homeowners can handle -- but see the Warning Notice at the end of this article. Some mold species can make you sick.

How to Identify Hidden & Visible Molds that are Cosmetic or Harmless, or Other Low-Risk Molds

Photograph: typical cosmetic bluestain mold on new framing lumber, floor joists - © Daniel Friedman

Cosmetic-only Ceratocystis/Ophistoma bluestain mold is shown on the floor joists in the new construction framing in the photo just above.

This is a harmless, cosmetic-only mold that does not damage the lumber and is not a pathogen for humans. Here's a good example of the observation that not all "black mold" is "toxic black mold". It will be totally hidden when the ceiling drywall is installed.

Detailed advice about how to determine by visual inspection alone whether or not you're probably looking at one of these common framing lumber cosmetic molds is at our

Photo Guide to COSMETIC MOLDS

...




ADVERTISEMENT





Reader Comments, Questions & Answers About The Article Above

Below you will find questions and answers previously posted on this page at its page bottom reader comment box.

Reader Q&A - also see RECOMMENDED ARTICLES & FAQs

On 2019-05-04 - by (mod) - how to get rid of mold in wall cavity space later filled with foam insulation

Rod:

What's the mold actually growing on?

Exposed OSB - not intended for permanent exposure to the weather - can be cleaned using either simple cleaners, followed by drying and sealing with a suitable coating, or more aggressively with media blasting (not normally justified unless for cosmetic reasons)

But the underlying cause of mold growth is what needs to be addressed: leaks, water, moisture traps, lack of sunlight - of which you'd focus on fixing any leaks and weatherproofing the the exterior.

If there was mold growth on the surfaces of OSB sheathing that has now been covered by foam insulation, there is no economical way to remove the mold.

Since demolition and reconstruction of foam-filled exterior OSB-sheathed walls would be very costly, I'd want some more thorough investigation before considering such demolition work necessary.

- is there any evidence by odor or MVOC testing that the wall cavities are releasing mold MVOCs (or spores though that's far less likely) into building air?

- have test cuts been made to confirm the severity of and extent of mold contamination?

- has the cause of mold growth been determined and fixed?

- are we sure that the mold genera/species on the OSB are harmful? There's a small chance that the mold was cosmetic.

See COSMETIC MOLD, RECOGNIZE

On 2019-05-02 by Rod

How to eliminate mold from exterior osb walls that have closed cell spray foam as insulation on the inside

This Q&A were posted originally

at MOLD CLEANUP - WOOD FRAMING & PLYWOOD

On 2019-02-25 by (mod) -

Moldy drywall or sheetrock and insulation that was wet need to be removed and the framing cleans and the new materials installed.

On 2019-02-25 by Mary Lind

Insurance claim. Tree fell, roof crushed. 1 ceiling fell, then tile was removed in 4 other rooms so all ceilings could be replaced. There is mold on sheetrock that was located behind tile.
Does that material need to be treated or replaced before new ceilings are installed? Do I need to have it tested? I dont want to have a health problem later.

On 2018-10-05 by (mod) -

I would not remove the walls and flooring just because of remaining mold between the under-side of the wall sill plate and the upper side of the subfloor.

I just don't feel it's likely to be cost justified - assuming there is no other reason to remove it such as the presence of rot or structural damge. I would clean all the available surfaces, dry everything thoroughly, and stop there.

The remaining mold reservoir in that small enclosed area - assuming in your case it's probably just a few linear feet, if kept dry, is not likely to produce a detectable release of problem mold spores into the occupied space.

I would hesitate to try sealing the joint between sill plate and floor with caulk or other sealant - which is tempting, because I suspect you'd be trapping moisture in that very slow to dry area, inviting eventual rot.

On 2018-10-05 by Carolyn

My water line to my refrigerator started leaking, for how many days I don’t know. My closet is located behind the wall where the refrigerator sits. My closet has had carpet covers floors si I didn’t notice until the carpet was saturated. I have remover the carpet and drywall.

Some what appears to be black mold was between the walls and in two corners of the closet. I have used the bleach and water solution, but still notice black mold between the floor which is compressed wood and the 2x4s. Can I illuminate this by pouring the peroxide solution and allowing it to run between or must I remove the walls and flooring.

On 2016-09-03 by Anonymous

If there is surface mold there can certainly be mold in building cavities: walls, ceilings, under floors not slab on grade; I'd choose some most-suspect areas for judicious test cuts.

On 2016-09-03 by Janice

We are in the process of purchasing a foreclosed home that has been sitting in Florida for seven years with no Airconditioning. The inspector found yellowish surface mold on walls, cabinets, and floor boards. The floors are wood. They don't appear moldly. The entire place has a high moisture content. Should we be concerned about mold beneath the wood floors? There is bucking in one area, but it is not discolored. It is below an air vent. Thank you.

On 2016-02-06 by (mod) -

Kevin

I would be surprised if the mold trapped between the upper side of a 4" wide beam and the ceiling above would explain a mold smell, but your test argues that I'm wrong.

My suggestion: when the ceiling and beams are very dry (wood moisture below 18%, and 12% or lower is better) then seal the juncture of beam to sealing along either side with a small, well-bonded sealant either clear or color matched or paintable depending on the surrounding finished surfaces.

Keep in mind that in the future if you have leaks INTO the sealed space we're inviting rot.

On 2016-02-04 by Kevin

I am sure I have hidden mold sitting on the top side of exposed 4x10 wood beams in the ceiling. House is Mexican style with wood beams supporting a flat concrete ceiling. Ceiling leaks have been fixed but moldy smell persists. During leaks, water would sit on the top hidden surface of the beams in the crack between the beam and the clay ceiling tiles.

Other water would drip onto the floor. House has been dry for 2 months since leak repair and humidity is low through use of dehumidifier.

With the help of a ladder I can stick my nose into the offending crack and smell the Mold. As a test, I even sealed off the ceiling with poly and carefully taped the edges to ensure no air leakage from the ceiling into the room. Guess what, smell disappeared immediately. After one week I had to take the poly down due to asthetic reasons. Smell returned immediately.

So how can I fix this problem? Maybe poly the ceiling and apply drywall? Maybe give it more time to dry? Cant remove the beams or concrete roof will fall down. Maybe apply caulking in the crack between wood beam and ceiling tile to eliminate airflow. That would seal in the mold. Is that a good idea?

On 2015-09-02 by (mod) -

Kudos for a condensed question

IMO NO biocide is a good substitute for proper cleaning of clean-able surfaces and for removal of items that can't be cleaned such as moldy drywall and wet insulation.

See FUNGICIDAL SEALANTS by searching InspectApedia.com and you'll read details.

On 2015-09-02 by Ann

Just had flood from leaves clogged in drain on roof....had mold inspection ..have dangerous mold....I am very chemically sensitive...remediiator will use a prod I suggest

Soo which biocides or fungusides r the safest to use as far as out gassing for longer than three months...

and what to use on wood framing under roof.....
Any help woul b appreciated.....I research everything I can ...but alot to do in one day


...

Continue reading at HIDDEN MOLD in OTHER PLACES or select a topic from the closely-related articles below, or see the complete ARTICLE INDEX.

Or see these

Recommended Articles

 

Suggested citation for this web page

HIDDEN MOLD in FRAMING / SHEATHING at InspectApedia.com - online encyclopedia of building & environmental inspection, testing, diagnosis, repair, & problem prevention advice.


Or see this

INDEX to RELATED ARTICLES: ARTICLE INDEX to MOLD CONTAMINATION & REMEDIATION

Or use the SEARCH BOX found below to Ask a Question or Search InspectApedia

Ask a Question or Search InspectApedia

Questions & answers or comments about mold traps: mold that may be hidden between layers of building materials.

Try the search box just below, or if you prefer, post a question or comment in the Comments box below and we will respond promptly.

Search the InspectApedia website

Note: appearance of your Comment below may be delayed: if your comment contains an image, photograph, web link, or text that looks to the software as if it might be a web link, your posting will appear after it has been approved by a moderator. Apologies for the delay.

Only one image can be added per comment but you can post as many comments, and therefore images, as you like.
You will not receive a notification
when a response to your question has been posted.
Please bookmark this page to make it easy for you to check back for our response.
Our Comment Box is provided by Countable Web Productions countable.ca

Comment Form is loading comments...

Citations & References

In addition to any citations in the article above, a full list is available on request.



ADVERTISEMENT