InspectAPedia®

Photograph of a natural gas regulator on a furnace Gas Regulator Noise Causes & Cures
Buzzing, humming, hissing, & other gas regulator noises

  • GAS REGULATOR NOISES - CONTENTS: are hissing, humming or other noises at an appliance gas regulator a sign that the system is unsafe or needs repair? Maybe.
  • POST a QUESTION or READ FAQs about inspecting, diagnosing, repairing, or replacing LP gas regulators and Natural Gas regulators found on heating appliances
  • REFERENCES
InspectAPedia tolerates no conflicts of interest. We have no relationship with advertisers, products, or services discussed at this website.

Gas appliance regulator noises & sounds:

Gas regulator noises may include humming, hissing, and other sounds. While many gas grill and some other appliance manufacturers say a bit of humming at the gas regulator for appliances is normal and harmless, not everyone agrees.

This article series explains LP or Natural Gas Pressure Regulators used on building appliances such as gas fired furnaces, boilers, water heaters, and stoves: How to Inspect & Test LP or Natural Gas Valves Regulators, or Gas Controls at Appliances.



Green links show where you are. © Copyright 2017 InspectApedia.com, All Rights Reserved.

Gas Appliance or Gas-fired Heater Regulator or Control Noises

Bosh Gas Regulator for a gas cooktop (C) Daniel FriedmanImmediate LP or natural gas safety hazards: if there is evidence of an LP or natural gas leak at a building, gas odors, for example, you should:

Gas regulator noises: while many gas grill and some other appliance manufacturers say a bit of humming at the gas regulator for appliances is normal and harmless, not everyone agrees.

Certainly if there is a gas odor or gas leak, the gas supply should be shut off immediately and you need to call a professional for diagnosis and repair of the trouble. Some experts explain that over time a humming gas regulator may become unsafe; and there are other noises that have other meanings at gas regulators, pipes, and LP gas tanks.

[Click to enlarge any image]

Reader Question: buzzing noise from the gas regulator at my heater

2016/07/24 Wilycoyote said:

I have a Wayne natural gas burner insert that replaced my oil fired Beckett burner in my furnace. Occasionally there is a buzzing noise that is coming from the combination gas valve.

It is rare, intermittent, and stops after a minute or so, and usually does not reoccur this heat cycle. The flame looks normal and the heater operates normally before/during/after each event.

What is this? Is it dangerous? Does it mean the gas valve is failing?

There is nothing in the troubleshooting manual about this problem.

This question was posted originally at GAS BURNER FLAME & NOISE DEFECTS

Reply:

Wily:

I'm not expert on gas regulator noises but from reading advice from some appliance manufacturers and from several gas distribution companies I can suggest some regulator noises and their possible causes.

Watch out: But before going through noise sources, make darn sure that any hissing you hear is not a gas leak as a gas leak risks fire and explosion. If you suspect a gas leak shut down the gas supply immediately.

Some propane experts and propane industry websites such as propane101.com state:

An important point to note is that under normal operation, a propane regulator will make a "humming" noise. This is normal and should not be construed as a problem or regulator malfunction.

But as you’ll read below, some experts warn that over time a humming gas regulator that is not leaking and that is deemed “safe” may become unsafe as it may be damaged over time by vibration.

Let’s go through some noises and gas regulator noise sources:

  1. Buzzing due to electrical problems at or near the gas regulator: some appliance gas valves use a gas regulator that operates powered by a low-voltage transformer, perhaps at 24VAC. IF there is a loose wire or voltage defect the regulator would be unsafe in my opinion;

    Check for buzzing that is actually coming from a nearby low-voltage transformer. If that's the source, replace the transformer.
  2. Clanking noises at the gas regulator: One gas supplier we consulted mentioned a clanking sound in LP tanks traced to a loose gas level float assembly.
  3. Gurgling Humming at the gas regulator - Over-filled LP tank: can produce a humming or gurgling sound heard in the gas piping or at the regulator. This is a serious problem as it is sending excess pressure and possibly liquid fuel into an appliance regulator designed only for gas and lower pressure.

    Feeding fuel from an over-filled LP gas tank can also cause regulator damage as liquid LP can slug the regulator. According to some gas suppliers, an over-filled LP gas tank can actually cause abnormally low gas flow through the regulator and thus a reduced appliance gas flame.

    Watch out: DO NOT try to fix an over-fill problem yourself - trying to release excess LP gas can blow the place up or burn it down.
  4. Hissing sounds at the gas regulator (not everyone uses the same terms for the same sounds) may be from a gas leak. Sniff for gas - and have your system tested for gas leaks.

    Hissing also occurs through a ventilation hole that releases air from the atmospheric side of the gas regulator - this is normal but it should not be continuous. If you smell gas there is a leak: that would be unsafe - in that case shut off the gas.

    Hissing may also come from gas being released from a safety valve at the gas tank or regulator. That too indicates an unsafe condition.

    Watch out: If you smell gas - there is a gas leak - the system is unsafe; the gas supply should be shut off and then you should call for repair. The risk is fire or explosion.
  5. Humming, buzzing, hissing noise at the gas regulator: Diaphragm noise: Most-often humming or buzzing at a gas appliance regulator is traced to the gas regulator diaphragm. Some manufacturers (charbroil.com & napoleongrills.com for example) consider this normal as a function of variations in temperature, barometric pressure, and relative humidity and say ignore it.

    Weber, another gas grill manufacturer says the noise is safe as long as it’s not accompanied by a gas leak (or gas odor indicating a leak). But as you’ll see at the end of my notes, Zafer (2008) warns of possible regulator damage that could be unsafe.

    This is more likely to occur with LP gas systems than with piped-in natural gas systems.

    Try this: slightly close the gas supply valve; that won't change the system pressure but it'll restrict the gas flow slightly. If that makes the buzzing/humming noise stop you're probably seeing a regulator diaphragm. vibration issue.

    Most gas heater/appliance regulators use an internal rubber diaphragm. that might be damaged, perforated, or its spring may be sticking; in those cases the regulator needs repair or replacement.

    Watch out: if you smell gas, for example if gas is leaking through a perforated gas regulator diaphragm, the system is unsafe and should be shut down.
  6. Knocking and pinging sounds at the gas regulator: other gas appliance regulator noises include a knocking or pinging sound that can be caused by improper mixing of gas and air at the LP gas tank. If you see yellow or white-blue instead of mostly blue flames with a yellow tip then this may be the trouble. You’ll need to have your LP gas service tech inspect and repair the equipment.
  7. Various noise sources at the gas regulator - Air trapped in gas piping or water or rarely ice in the regulator: - that might be from a contaminated fuel source, possibly transient.

    If trapped air is the problem, purging the gas line between appliance regulator and tank ought to correct it.
  8. Various noise sources at the gas regulator - Dirt or debris in the regulator - ultimately that'll probably lead to its replacement

Watch out: Zafer (2008) points out that while humming and vibration at appliance gas regulators is a common problem, it is ultimately unsafe because the vibration in the regulator leads to component fatigue damage and regulator failure “if left unchecked”.

A nauseating amount of information about gas regulators begins at InspectApedia at GAS REGULATORS for APPLIANCES

Question: Diagnosing & Fixing a Buzzing Noise at a Gas Fired Water Heater

Buzzing noise at gas fired water heater (C) InspectApedia.com RSOur hot water heater is making the sound you hear in the attached video. The sound is intermittent. Do you have any idea what this could be? The water is hot. - Anonymous by private email 2017/01/13

BUZZING GAS FIRED WATER HEATER VIDEO [3MB .mp4 recording]

Reply:

To me that sounds like a buzzing sound right at the heater control or burner. This isn't a high-efficiency water heater, right?

I see what looks like a large black gas supply tube (to the burner) and a smaller diameter aluminum tube presumably feeding a pilot. Is that right?

Could there be a buzzing igniter?

Do you have other gas appliances and are they working normally? That'd reduce the chances of a problem at the gas supply or main gas regulator.

The system may be unsafe.

Also see GAS FLAME & NOISE DEFECTS

and for a more exhaustive list of sources of noises at water heaters see WATER HEATER NOISE.

Reader follow-up: replaced gas heater burner assembly

It was the only device acting up, and we had the burner assembly replaced, so all is good now. Throughout the off and on buzzing period, the unit continued to heat, and my friend, colleague & owner of our business was too distracted to take the action our regular plumber had recommended.

Eventually the buzzing stopped, and so did the heat. The repair cost approx $600, and apparently we had to replace the same burner assembly 2-3 years ago at this laundromat location.

Moderator follow-up comment:

To me that sounds like a failing control, probably an electrical component, or an igniter, though on occasion gas regulators can be noisy too. If a specific failure repeats itself I figure there's some underlying problem that's not yet been identified.

Article Series Contents

...


Continue reading at GAS REGULATORS for APPLIANCES or select a topic from closely-related articles below, or see our complete INDEX to RELATED ARTICLES below.

Or see GAS REGULATOR ADJUSTMENT PROCEDURE

Or see HVAC NOISE-1 BANG BUZZ VIBRATE - banging, bearings, buzzing noises in mechanical systems

Suggested citation for this web page

GAS REGULATOR NOISES at InspectApedia.com - online encyclopedia of building & environmental inspection, testing, diagnosis, repair, & problem prevention advice.

INDEX to RELATED ARTICLES: ARTICLE INDEX to GAS APPLIANCES, PIPING, CONTROLS

Or use the SEARCH BOX found below to Ask a Question or Search InspectApedia


...

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Click to Show or Hide FAQs

Ask a Question or Search InspectApedia

Questions & answers or comments about inspecting, diagnosing, repairing, or replacing LP gas regulators and Natural Gas regulators found on heating appliances

Use the "Click to Show or Hide FAQs" link just above to see recently-posted questions, comments, replies, try the search box just below, or if you prefer, post a question or comment in the Comments box below and we will respond promptly.

Search the InspectApedia website

Comment Box is loading comments...

Technical Reviewers & References

Click to Show or Hide Citations & References

Publisher's Google+ Page by Daniel Friedman