Leaky unsafe relief valve (C) Daniel FriedmanRelief Valve Leaks: causes/cures for boilers, water heaters, water pressure tanks
     

  • RELIEF VALVE LEAKS - CONTENTS: How to fix a leaky pressure relief valve or leaky TP valve on a boiler, water heater, or water tank - what are the possible causes of leaks at these safety devices. Safety Hazard Warnings About Dripping or Leaking Pressure Relief Valves. How to use an expansion tank to relieve high water pressure. T&P Valves Installed on Gas Sidearm Heaters: special problems. Closed Hot Water System & Thermal Expansion Problems
  • POST a QUESTION or READ FAQs about the causes & cures of leaks and discharges from pressure relief valves or TP valves
  • REFERENCES

InspectAPedia tolerates no conflicts of interest. We have no relationship with advertisers, products, or services discussed at this website.

This article describes the causes of leaks, drips, or discharges from pressure relief valves, temperature/pressure relief valves, or TP valves found on heating boilers, water heaters, or the simpler pressure relief valves found on water pressure tanks.

We list the wide variety of possible TP Valve leaks and how to find and fix each of those problems.

Watch out: a dripping or frequently spilling T&P valve is dangerous because those very leaks can eventually cause the valve to clog and then to fail to open when it should.

Green links show where you are. © Copyright 2015 InspectApedia.com, All Rights Reserved.

Leaky or Dripping Water Heater Pressure & Temperature Relief Valves

Obsolete boiler pressure relief valveArticle Series Contents

Evidence of dangerous leaks and corrosion at water heater temperature/pressure safety valves

12 Causes of leaky dripping Pressure/Temperature Relief Valves

Temperature & Pressure Relief valves may open, leak, or drip for a variety of reasons including:

  1. Boiler limit control problems: On a heating boiler, the boiler temperatures are excessive, possibly due to an improperly set limit control, lack of contact between the limit switch sensor and its mounting well, or a defective control.

    See AQUASTAT CONTROL Functions and see Limit Switches, Boilers
  2. Closed hot water systems: Periodic discharge of the temperature and pressure relief valve may be due to thermal expansion in a closed water supply system. Details are at Closed Hot Water Systems
  3. Gas sidearm heater TP valves: The T&P valve is installed on a sidearm gas heater that is causing an overheat condition at the sensor point of the valve (This thermal expansion is discussed

    at T&P Valves Installed on Gas Sidearm Heaters)
  4. Expansion tank defects or problems: if the expansion tank or compression tank on a hydronic heating system boiler or on other thermal expansion systems is itself defective (waterlogged, leaky, damaged internal bladder) system pressures will be excessive due to otherwise normal pressure & temperature variations during system operation, resulting in spillage at the relief valve.

    See EXPANSION TANKS for diagnosis & repair procedures
  5. Leaks into the heating boiler or water heater: leaks into a heating of water from a higher pressure building source can cause recurrent TP valve leaking. For example, if the tankless coil in a heating boiler is leaky, higher pressure water inside the tankless coil may leak out of the coil into the heating boiler.

    Similarly, an internal leak in the heat exchanger coil of an indirect water heater can send water from the water heater's potable water into the coil and thence into the heating boiler.

    We describe these leaks into the heating boiler through the tankless coil or indirect water heater coil
    at EVIDENCE of TANKLESS INTERNAL COIL LEAK INTO BOILER / WATER TANK

    This same leak problem can cause high water pressure in a heating boiler that is used to heat water in an indirect-fired water heater. In that case, a coil containing boiler water (typically at 12-29 psi) that develops a leak may accept higher building pressure water from the building water supply to the indirect water eater tank (or cylinder) that is typically between 20 psi and 70 psi.

    Diagnose this problem by observing that when the boiler is left OFF and its own water feeder is left OFF but building water supply is left ON into the tankless coil on the boiler or ON into the indirect water heater, boiler pressure will creep up several hours. With a reader we discuss this possible TP valve leak cause in the FAQs section of this article.

    Watch out: under normal conditions, because building water supply pressures are above boiler pressures, an internal leak in the tankless coil or indirect water heater's heat exchanger coil will cause boiler pressures to rise. But there can be exceptions in the direction of water leakage, as we explain
    at TANKLESS COIL LEAK DIRECTION IN or OUT
  6. Pressure Relief Valve Defects, or Pressure/Temperature Relief Valve Defects that cause leaks
    • Dirt or debris are preventing proper closure of the relief valve valve
    • A deteriorated gasket inside the relief valve or corrosion on the valve seat can cause leaking at the valve; we find this mess occurring when someone lifts the "test lever" on a older P/T valve that has not been tested or operated for some time. A brittle piece of gasket can be spit out of the valve and it will then keep leaking.
    • The wrong T&P valve has been installed or set to too-low a working pressure. (Proper set pressure is at least 20-30 psi above the working pressure of the equipment to be protected).
  7. Thermal expansion problems: A closed water system with thermal expansion and no means of relief can cause leaks at the pressure/temperature relief valve, such as
    • on a hot water heater with some building piping arrangements
    • on a hot water heating boiler at which its expansion tank has become waterlogged -

      see EXPANSION TANKS for diagnosis & repair procedures
    • see Closed Hot Water Systems
  8. Water expansion pressure (thermal expansion) increases in a closed system with a check valve installed close to the water heater.

    The increase in plumbing system pressure to a level that opens the TP valve is called "thermal expansion pressure". Watts suggests installing a bypass model water pressure regulator that lets the excessive pressure head back to the street main or building water supply system - a solution that only works if the supply pressure is lower than the T&P relief valve spill pressure - which it usually is.
    See THERMAL EXPANSION of HOT WATER for further explanation in horrible detail.
  9. Water hammer: The building plumbing system suffers from water hammer. Water hammer in buildings causes surging in the water piping that in turn can cause leaks at pressure/temperature or other pressure relief valves, particularly at the pressure safety valve found at water pressure tanks.
    See WATER HAMMER NOISE DIAGNOSE & CURE
  10. Water heater temperature too high: The water heater temperatures are excessive. For example on an electric water heater a malfunctioning control can overheat the water e.g. the water heater thermostat is not working properly and is not shutting off the heat source when it should -

    see Electric Water Heater Thermostats
    and
    see Electric Water Heater High Temp Cutoff Test

  11. Water pressure too high: The building water supply pressure is too high or periodically water pressure fluctuates and is too high at times.

    See WATER PRESSURE VARIATION CAUSES and also  

    WATER PRESSURE TOO HIGH: DANGERS and see

    WATER PRESSURE REDUCER / REGULATOR
  12. Water pressure reducing valve / water feed valve problems: On a hot water hydronic heating system, if the water pressure reducer/feeder valve is not working properly it may over-feed water into the heating system causing overpressure.

    See PRESSURE REDUCING VALVES.

Safety Hazard Warnings About Dripping or Leaking Pressure Relief Valves

Evidence of relief valve leakingWatch out: a dripping or frequently spilling T&P valve is dangerous because those very leaks can eventually cause the valve to clog and then to fail to open when it should.

As our photo shows (above left), mineral salts left behind as hot water evaporates from the mouth of a pressure or temperature relief valve can completely clog the spring that is intended to allow the relief valve to open under excess (unsafe) pressure.

The impaction of the relief valve spring with copper and calcium salts in this photo means that the valve is almost certainly not going to open should the heater's internal pressure become unsafe.

The drip shown at the mouth of this relief valve demonstrates that a relief valve can drip and leak for a long time without anyone observing this dangerous condition.

This relief valve needs to be replaced immediately and the cause for the valve's leakage also needs to be determined.

Accidental or deliberately plugged Temperature & Pressure Relief Valves

Watch out: Never remove nor plug a pressure/temperature relief valve. This [water heater pressure/temperature relief] valve must be marked with the maximum set pressure not to exceed the marked maximum working pressure of the water heater. Install the valve into an opening provided and marked for this purpose in the water heater, and orient it or provide tubing so that any discharge from the valve exits only within 6 inches above, or at any distance below, the structural floor, and does not contact any live electrical part. The discharge opening must not be blocked or reduced in size under any circumstance. [1] [2]

Technical note: why must the TP Valve point "down"? Take a look at the photo above. If a relief valve is dripping the deposit of minerals inside the valve will accumulate still more rapidly if the valve points to the side or upwards. The result is a clogged valve as we explain above - a dangerous situation that risks an explosion.

See BLEVE EXPLOSIONS for an explanation of why a leaky or plugged TPR valve can cause a large catastrophic explosion.

See WATER HEATER SAFETY for our complete list of water heater safety devices and water heater safety inspection advice.

Closed Hot Water Systems & Thermal Expansion Problems

Watts and other manufacturers of TP valves warn of serious safety hazards caused by dripping at the TP discharge line and point out that often the dripping is caused by thermal expansion of hot water.

When water is heated in a closed plumbing system, it expands, causing an increase in pressure. This increase in system pressure over that regulated by the pressure reducing valve is called thermal expansion pressure. The T&P valve is a safety device and is not intended for continuous operation to relieve thermal expansion. Continuous dripping can cause the build up of mineral deposits on the valve and may render it useless. - Watts (2011)

See HOT WATER PRESSURE EXPANSION RATE - for an explanation of just how much pressure increase to expect when heating water. In explaining why the relief valve on a water heater may be dripping, American Water Heater Co. [1] explains:

Periodic discharge of the temperature and pressure relief valve may be due to thermal expansion in a closed water supply system. The water utility supply meter may contain a check valve, backflow preventer or water pressure reducing valve. This will create a closed water system.

During the heating cycle of the water heater, the water expands causing pressure inside the water heater to increase. This may cause the temperature and pressure relief valve to discharge small quantities of hot water. To prevent this from happening, there are two recommendations:

  • Install a diaphragm-type expansion tank that is suitable for potable water on the cold water supply line. The expansion tank must have a minimum capacity of 1.5 U.S. gallons for every 50 gallons of stored water.
  • Install a 125 PSI pressure relief valve in the cold water supply line. Make sure the discharge of this valve is directed to an open drain and protected from freezing. [1]

Note: While a 125 psi pressure relief valve on cold water supply piping is fine to protect piping from rupturing, if building incoming water pressures are too high, rather than relying just on a relief valve (wasting water) we prefer to install a pressure reducing/control valve at the building entering water supply piping. Limit incoming water pressure to 60 psi at a typical one or two story residential home.

How to detect that a TPR valve is dripping due to thermal expansion

Draining pressure from the water system to determine the cause of a leaky TPR valve (C) Daniel FriedmanThere are several reasons that a temperature/pressure relief valve or TPR valve might be dripping or leaking.
See RELIEF VALVE LEAK for a complete discussion of leaky TP valves.

Watts (2011) suggests two methods for testing for thermal expansion of hot water as the cause of a TP valve drip. The text below is adapted from that source.

  1. Open a water faucet and see if the dripping stops: If the TPR valve is leaking due to thermal expansion of hot water, simply opening a water faucet or fixture anywhere in the plumbing system will immediately stop the drip.

    That's because opening the hot water faucet reduces the system pressure back to normal operating levels - we are no longer heating water in a "closed" piping and tank system.

    Why would opening either a hot or cold water faucet work? Because when no water is running, the entire plumbing system is "closed" - unless there is an expansion tank already installed on the hot water heating system to accommodate thermal expansion, heating water in the water cylinder (water heater for Yanks) causes an increase in system pressure.
  2. Monitor actual water piping system pressure using an temporarily or permanently-installed pressure gauge:

    Install a pressure gauge on a convenient hose bib such as at the washing machine hook-up or if weather permits, outdoors. Install & use the pressure gauge to monitor system water pressure over at least a full 24-hour period. You don't have to sleep by it. If you select a pressure gauge with a re-settable "telltale" needle, the gauge's re-settable indicator will indicate the highest pressure that has been reached by the water system since the water pressure test gauge was installed.

    See MEASURE WATER SYSTEM PRESSURE & PRESSURE MAXIMUM for tips on how to make or buy an inexpensive recording-type water pressure test gauge for this purpose.

Solutions for Dripping TPR Valves due to thermal expansion of hot water are given
at HOT WATER EXPANSION TANKS where we describe both hot water expansion tanks and hot water expansion relief valves designed to handle thermal water pressure increases and thus to stop dripping TP valves.

Watch out: get advice from a licensed plumber and your local water supplier. Never remove or plug a leaky pressure/temperature relief valve on a water heater - doing so risks dangerous or even fatal
BLEVE EXPLOSIONS.

Also see the FAQs below where we discuss closed plumbing systems caused by check valves on the cold water line.

If the building water pressure gauge reading is ever found at 80 psi or higher, you will want to install a water pressure regulator at the point where water supply enters the building.

If your building already has a water pressure gauge installed, it may be defective or it may be set too high. The articles listed just below discuss how to adjust a water pressure regulator:

Expansion tanks to relieve high water pressure

An alternative to installing or changing a water pressure regulator when building water pressure is occasionally 80 psi or higher is the installation of an expansion tank to temporarily absorb that pressure increase. Proper use of an expansion tank can help avoid unnecessary opening of the pressure/temperature relief valve on a hot water heating tank or a hot water heating boiler.

T&P Valves Installed on Gas Sidearm Heaters: special problems

Watts Regulator Co. offers this explanation of T&P leak problems that may be encountered on gas fired sidearm heaters. [10]

Question: What would cause an automatic T&P valve to open and close repeatedly when there is very little hot water in the storage tank?

Reply: troubles at the gas sidearm heater

With a sidearm gas heater a common problem is frequent T&P valve opening even though there is very little hot water in the hot water storage tank. That's because an overheated condition exists right at the sensor point of the T&P valve - most of the overheated water is "congested" at the top of the tank. This problem can be caused by undersized circulation piping between the sidearm heater and the water tank. Undersized piping between the sidearm heater and the tank (supply or return) amounts to a restriction of the circulation area (or volume).

When this "too small" circulation area or volume is combined with a heater whose BTU input rate is higher than that undersized volume can carry, proper circulating does not occur through the tank nor through the sidearm heater coils themselves - the "congestion" referred to above occurs. In turn this congestion (think of it as a hot water traffic jam) causes overheating right where the T&P valve sensor is located, thus causing the valve to spill hot water repeatedly. In other words, hot water is accumulating at the T&P valve location rather than being distributed more evenly throughout the hot water tank.

Because there is just a small volume of "too hot" water where the valve is located, the valve opens, spills the small amount of hot water, then is cooled and closes after just a short interval.

To correct this condition install at least 3/4" piping, preferably not iron pipe, in the circulating loop. [The system we used for years used 1 1/4" diameter copper piping - Ed.] Non-ferrous piping is preferred to reduce the chances of clogging from rust debris - a clue that warns us that even 3/4" piped gas sidearm heaters can clog from rust or scale formation and will then exhibit this problem if the piping is iron.

With an automatic gas storage heater installation, either the heater thermostat is acting abnormally (not shutting off when it should) or stacking temperature conditions are causing this TP leak. - paraphrased & adapted from information from the Watts Regulator Company. [10]

 

Continue reading at THERMAL EXPANSION of HOT WATER or select a topic from the More Reading links shown below.

Or see RELIEF VALVES - TP VALVES - topic home where we include additional relief valve information including for hydronic heating and steam heating boilers used for central heating.

Suggested citation for this web page

RELIEF VALVE LEAKS at InspectApedia.com - online encyclopedia of building & environmental inspection, testing, diagnosis, repair, & problem prevention advice.

More Reading

Green link shows where you are in this article series.

INDEX to RELATED ARTICLES: ARTICLE INDEX to ARTICLE INDEX to T&P RELIEF VALVES

OR use the Search Box found below at Ask a Question or Search InspectApedia

...




Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Click to Show or Hide FAQs

Ask a Question or Search InspectApedia

Use the "Click to Show or Hide FAQs" link just above to see recently-posted questions, comments, replies, try the search box just below, or if you prefer, post a question or comment in the Comments box below and we will respond promptly.

Search the InspectApedia website

HTML Comment Box is loading comments...

Technical Reviewers & References

Publisher's Google+ Page by Daniel Friedman

Click to Show or Hide Citations & References