InspectAPedia®

New building access ramp (C) Daniel Friedman Wood Board Cupping
Why do Boards Cup; Should Wood Boards Be Placed Bark Side Up or Bark Side Down when Building Exterior Decks or Stairs?

InspectAPedia tolerates no conflicts of interest. We have no relationship with advertisers, products, or services discussed at this website.

Bark side up or down on exterior wood decks & stairs:

This article series explains the causes of cupping in wood boards & wood board right side up advice for steps, decks, ramps: this article explains the causes of wood board cupping and gives advice concluding that unless a board is already badly cupped or has a "bad" side, when construction of outdoor decks and wood stairs you should place boards with "bark side up" - that is pith side (tree center side) of the board facing down.

We include a warning about "shelling" damage on decks and steps - a phenomenon that occurs more on the pith side of boards. There has been plenty of argument about bark up vs bark down. Field experience, FPL experts, and further discussion here all agree that "bark side down" advice in some sources is not the best practice when building wood decks, steps, ramps, platforms, especially outdoors.



Green links show where you are. © Copyright 2017 InspectApedia.com, All Rights Reserved.

Cause of Outdoor Deck Board & Stair Tread or Wood Trim Cupping & Shelling - Advice for Which Side Should go "Up" When Placing Wood Deck Boards, Stair Treads

Why Boards Cup in the First Place: moisture differences dominate wood board cupping

End grain view of flat sawn board (C) Daniel Friedman

The two fundamental sources of wood board cupping are moisture differences across the thickness of the board and inherent properties of the wood cells and cell distribution patterns that comprise the board.

[Click to enlarge any image]

Our photo shows a pre-cut treated wood deck stair tread board. Despite the pith-side grooves cut by the manufacturer the board has cupped its outer edges upwards towards the bark side of the tree.

Article series contents

This cupping pattern shown above is consistent with the prediction of wood experts (wood tends to cup towards the "bark side" of the tree and incidentally, shows that this stair tread board is going to tend to hold water, grow algae, form ice, or otherwise be less safe than a board whose center had arched upwards. In use, if the upper surface of this board is usually wetter than its underside it may tend to flatten out.

The extent to which an individual board will cup depends on those two sources of cupping movement combined with the wood grain pattern of the individual board: flatsawn boards will cup more than quarter sawn boards - we illustrate these differences below.

Although conditions are different outdoors and indoors, still we find that deck boards as well as wood floor boards and stair treads tend to cup so that the concave side of the board is towards the floor's more dry side, and the convex side of the cupped or curved boards tend to be facing the floor's more wet side.

If you're not sure about cupping direction or the definitions of concave and convex, this U is concave and this n is convex. A concave board has its outer edges curled upwards while a convex-cupped board has its outer edges curled downwards.

Wood Cupping & Uneven Moisture Content

The moisture variation contribution to wood board cupping occurs because when a wooden board has uneven moisture content across its thickness it will tend to expand more on its more wet side, causing that side to "arch" or become convex while the opposing side becomes concave or "cupped".

Outdoors where despite temporary wetting from rain, deck boards and wood step boards open to air on both sides, some including chemists at the US FPL are of the view that these boards will ultimately have a moisture content within 2% of uniform across the board's thickness. [38] My view is that moisture content will vary across an outdoor deck board's thickness over time as a function of rain, snow-melt, or construction over wet, poorly-ventilated crawl areas.

Wood Cupping & Tangential. Wood Shrinkage

This moisture difference seems to dominate wood board cupping outdoors or inside even though wood experts often describe a different effect: tangential. shrinkage and movement that leads the outer edges of flatsawn boards to cup towards the outside of the tree (towards the bark) and away from the heart, adding that the smaller the original tree and the closer to the tree's heart from which a flatsawn board was cut the more extreme will be its tendency to cup.

That wood board cupping is an old and long discussed topic is evident from US FPL citations such Clarke (1930) in the U.S. alone. Finally, Cloutier et als (1997) noted that during wood drying, water conductivity was generally higher in the radial direction than in the tangential direction. which, along with the presence and structure of ray cells in wood fibers may help explain the actual mechanism wood board cupping that is either absent or confusing in most articles on this topic.[7]

A restatement of tangential. wood shrinkage that may be more clear is to pose that wood shrinks more along the circle of its growth rings than across the thickness of the board. By examining the end-cut of a flatsawn board you will see that one side of the board will show longer arcs of growth rings (the side closer to the bark side of the tree) while the other side of the board (closer to the tree heart) will sport shorter arcs (growth rings).

Location & Length of Growth Rings May also Help Explain Board Cupping - re-stating Tangential. Shrinkage Movement

End grain view of flat sawn board (C) Daniel Friedman

Our end grain view of a flat-sawn board shown above suggests a third possible source of wood board cupping: the pattern of growth rings through a cross section of the board.

In this photo (above) the long arches of growth rings that would also roughly map the round tree shape from which the board was cut. The winter wood (more dense) is marked by the darker growth rings in the board. The wider gaps of light colored wood are summer wood, a less dense growth of cellulose cells.

Cross section cut of lumber shows growth rings & maps the bark side of the tree, predicting the cupping direction

The long arcing red lines of winter wood occur in the center of the board and arch upwards towards the bark side of the tree. The blue lines in our illustration are also marking winter wood growth rings but notice that in a flat-sawn board these lines occur nearest to the edges of the board and that they also represent the typical end-grain of a quarter-sawn board illustrated below.

As we know that more shrinkage occurs across the width of a board through the flat-sawn long-growth-ring arcs (red lines) than will occur through the quarter-sawn end grain portion of the same board (blue lines) we thus have a third source of board cupping: more shrinkage wants to occur in the center of the board than in its edges. But how would this pattern explain the direction of cupping?

Notice that the longest red arcs are towards the upper or bark side of this board? More shrinkage around the growth ring or arc line means more shrinkage where these lines are longest in the board - the upper center board surface in our photo will shrink more than both the board edges and more than the lower board center surface, thus tending to curl the board's outer ends upwards.

Wood Cupping Develops a "Set" in Boards

Ultimately boards that have cupped due to these moisture differences develop a "set" and remain cupped even when the boards have dried. You can observe this dramatically in an interior wood floor that has been flooded, then dried. Boards will remain cupped.

Next: see ANSWER to BARK SIDE UP or DOWN

Hazards Caused by Cupped Wooden Deck Boards or Stair Treads

Poor drainage of upwards-cupped wood boards

Cupped ramp boards (or deck and platform boards) hold water and form algae or ice more quickly than boards that drain properly. They sometimes rot faster too.

Look at the end-grain of any deck, ramp, or wooden walkway board and notice the curved lines that mark the winter wood layers of the tree from which the board was cut.

If the visible curves (the darker colored latewood or winter-wood growth rings) are positioned such that the "cup" formed by these arcing lines is facing upwards - that is the convex side of the board and arcs faces up (opposite of the board in our page top photo) then these boards that are cupped upwards and will drain more poorly, stay wet longer, rot faster, and in freezing climates are going to stay icy longer. Wetter boards also collect more algae and are a slipping hazard, especially on decks and stairs.

Watch out: Use common sense. Especially with pressure-treated wood that may have been soaked unevenly, boards may be quite warped when you are using them in construction. Before nailing a deck or ramp board in place, look at the board surface itself - sometimes the boards don't follow these "cupping rules".

Also see DECK & PORCH CONSTRUCTION.

Shelling Damage to Walking Surfaces on Wood Decks & Stairs

Watch out: As we introduced above in our US FPL quotation, on wooden decks and stair treads a defect referred to shelling can occur with the bark side down method as this position tends to leave more poorly-penetrated (by preservative) heartwood exposed to sun and weather.

Shelling is a term used by some builders to refer to the loss of portions of a board surface as late wood growth (the outer surface of the tree and thus the "bark side" of the board) separates from early wood growth (the inner portion of the tree or the tree-center side of the board).

Shelling is reported to occur more often in lumber made from Douglas Fir and Southern Pine.

When building an outdoor deck wooden stair tread, it is a good idea to avoid using boards with questionable, likely to separate, portions of their upper surface. Shelling may be less of a problem with wood trim that is to be placed vertically and kept painted or sealed.

For another safety tip when building wooden stair treads using 5/4 deck boards or 2x lumber, avoid using boards whose edge that will form the stair tread nose is, by inclusion of knots, chips, or other defects, likely to break away or form an uneven stair tread nose.

Uneven or irregular or chipped stair tread noses are another trip hazard.

See STAIR TREAD NOSE DIMENSIONS and see Slippery Stairs, Walks for details.

Bark Side Up or Down for Firewood?

The New York Times reported (February 2013) that the bark-side up or down debate rages unresolved in a related venue, the stacking of firewood by Norwegians. People appear to be split 50:50 about whether it's better to stack split log firewood bark side up or down. Having heated my home for years on firewood alone, and split and stacked a lot of wood, it's easy to understand the argument. [39]

Bark side up: sheds water better, so we fantasize that the wood will dry out better stacked in that position. But bark side down exposes the two split sides of a roughly triangular split firewood log or a semi-circular split half-log to having its freshly cut and split side up and possibly exposed to more airflow.

Which did I find was better? Neither. What was more important was to cover the top of the woodpile to keep the whole thing dry. Stack the firewood so that it has good air circulation, and cover the top of the woodpile. That made more difference than anything else ... except ... I found putting bark side down on the very first course of logs laid on the dirt seemed to invite bugs into my woodpile about 8% faster than if I stacked wood in the other orientation - for the first course.

Watch out: the slipperiness of a ramp varies enormously depending on what is on its surface, including algae, sand, dust, dirt, water, snow, ice, and even some add-on walking surfaces and paints.

At SLIPPERY STAIRS, WALKS we discuss the SCOF for wet algae-covered surfaces.

IPE Wood Deck Board Cupping

Reader Question:

Cupped ITE deck boards (C) InspectApedia ET

Three months after constructing a new Ipe deck some of the boards became cup shaped (see enclosed photos). Soaking two pieces of the leftovers resulted in one of the boards sink and the other float. Can this 'experiment' prove that some of the boards are not Ipe?
Awaiting your expert advice. E.T. by private email 2016/01/18

Cupped ITE deck boards (C) InspectApedia ET

Reply:

My opinion is that IPE, described by IPE Depot as " Ipe Decking. Ipe is an exotic hardwood that is naturally resistant to rot and decay, is 8 times harder than California Redwood, and is guaranteed for 20 years without preservatives!" - http://www.ipedepot.com/compare.htm

Should not usually float. A cubic foot of water weighs about 62.3 pounds. According to IPEDepot a cubic foot of IPE weighs 69 pounds - it would sink in water.

Cupped ITE deck boards (C) InspectApedia ET

However as this is a "natural" product I would not assume that all IPE boards are absolutely uniform in density or weight. So some boards or board cutoffs may be a bit under-weight. And Gibson (2000) points out that IPE is actually a broad term for a number of similar wood species. And White (2007) points out a range of densities among woods classified as "IPE". So your particular IPE deck boards may be less dense.

Furthermore, any natural wood deck board is exposed to cupping if the moisture differences across the board are significant. Cupping will usually show the concave side of the cup facing the more dry side of the board - which is usually "up" on a deck. Boards can misbehave and cup "backwards" for other reasons as we discuss ad-nauseum in our articles on deck board cupping beginning at the top of this page.

I'd look into the cause of cupping rather than thinking that if you'd had "better or more real" IPE no cupping would have occurred.

Watch out: there may be environmental and protected wood species issues with exotic woods used in decks or other construction. See Gibson (2000) who discusses chain of custody certification for IPE wood sold in the U.S.

Reader follow-up: Use florescence testing to identify IPE wood boards?

Thank you for your detailed answer with the valuable information.

It appears that the 'soaking test' is not absolutely conclusive to determine the exact identity of the boards. Will the 'fluorescence test' (as described in links given below) http://www.wood-database.com/wood-articles/fluorescence-a-secret-weapon-in-wood-identification/, http://www.wood-database.com/lumber-identification/hardwoods/ipe/, http://www.wood-database.com/lumber-identification/hardwoods/cumaru/) be conclusive? - E.T. 2016/02/16

Reply: apparently not

I have not found IPE listed among woods that are easily identified with floresence testing. (Dyer 1988, Sum 1991, Pandey 1998, et als cited below).

Have you gone to the supplier of your wood to ask for documentation of where the wood was purchased and where it was harvested?

Wood Identification by Fluorescence

IPE Deck Board Properties

Bark Side Up or Down Article Series

...


Continue reading at ANSWER to BARK SIDE UP or DOWN or select a topic from closely-related articles below, or see our complete INDEX to RELATED ARTICLES below.

Or see WOOD FLOOR DAMAGE

Or see DECK & PORCH CONSTRUCTION - home

Suggested citation for this web page

BARK SIDE UP or DOWN on DECKS & STEPS? at InspectApedia.com - online encyclopedia of building & environmental inspection, testing, diagnosis, repair, & problem prevention advice.

INDEX to RELATED ARTICLES: ARTICLE INDEX to BUILDING DECKS & PORCHES

Or use the SEARCH BOX found below to Ask a Question or Search InspectApedia


...

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Click to Show or Hide FAQs

Ask a Question or Search InspectApedia

Use the "Click to Show or Hide FAQs" link just above to see recently-posted questions, comments, replies, try the search box just below, or if you prefer, post a question or comment in the Comments box below and we will respond promptly.

Search the InspectApedia website

Comment Box is loading comments...

Technical Reviewers & References

Click to Show or Hide Citations & References

Publisher's Google+ Page by Daniel Friedman