Hot water temperature code, laws & regulations listed by authority, country, state or province.
Tables of laws regulating hot water temperatures to avoid scalding burns & to prevent Legionnaires bacteria formation in water heater tanks.
BODY OVERHEATING HAZARDS are discussed here.
Most other countries provide a single hot water temperature limit for water provided at plumbing fixtures and a separate hot water maintenance level for temperatures within the water heater itself.
InspectAPedia tolerates no conflicts of interest. We have no relationship with advertisers, products, or services discussed at this website.
- Daniel Friedman, Publisher/Editor/Author - See WHO ARE WE?
This article gives the allowable limits set on hot water temperatures for hot water used in buildings and compares regulations in various countries. For the U.S. we also include code citations and temperature limits by individual U.S. state.
What is the maximum hot water temperature that shall be delivered at the point of use? What hot water temperatures shall be maintained inside the water heater itself? Comparison of water temperature laws by country and by U.S. state.
Also use your browser's on-page search function [ Ctrl-F ] to search for a country or U.S. state in the data below.
AK - AL - AR - AZ - CA - CO - CT - DC - DE - FL - GA - HI - IA - ID - IL - IN - KS - KY - LA - MA - MD - ME - MI - MN - MO - MS - MT - NC - ND - NE - NH - NM - NV - NJ - NY - OH - OK - OR - PA - RI - SC - SD - TN - TX - UT - VA - VT - WA - WI - WV - WY
Anti-Scald Hot Water Regulations & Temperatures | |
---|---|
Maximum Temperature | Authority |
96-102 degF | Typical comfortable temperature for washing and bathing [15] |
105 degF | UFAS (Uniform Federal Accessibility Standard), 105°F max by automatically controlled tempered water flow, 1988 edition, and ADA (American with Disabilities Act). Arizona Prison Construction 401T-PPS provided below |
110 degF | U.S. Dept. Health & Human Services, Guidelines for Construction & Equipment of Hospital & Medical Facilities, HRP - 0905974, JUL84, avail. from NTIS, p48: “Hot water for showers and bathing facilities shall be at an appropriate temperature for comfortable use but shall not exceed 49°C (120°F) (see Table 4).” Table 4 gives temp in °F as 100 clinical (include shower), 120 dietary, 160 laundry. |
100-120 degF | ACA (American Correctional Association), 100 to 120°F max automatically controlled for prison showers, “Adult Correctional Institutions, 3rd Ed, 1990.” |
120 degF | 1993 International Plumbing Code 97/00 - adopted by 18 U.S. states |
120 degF | 1994 Uniform Plumbing Code (IAPMO/ICBO) 97/00 - 13 U.S. states |
120 degF | 1996 International Plumbing Code SBCCI 97/00 - 10 U.S. states |
120 degF | 1996 National Standard Plumbing Code PHCC 96/98 - 5 U.S. states |
No state code committed in 1998 - 3 U.S. states | |
Reference | A40 1993 Safety Standard for Plumbing (ANSI/MCA/PHCC/IAPMO) 93/ |
According to Domestic Hot Water Scald Burn Lawsuits... D. Bynum et als., there are three different federal standards for limits on safe hot water temperatures
1. 110 degF Max: U.S. Dept. Health & Human Services, Guidelines for Construction & Equipment of Hospital & Medical Facilities, HRP - 0905974, JUL84, avail. from NTIS, p48: “Hot water for showers and bathing facilities shall be at an appropriate temperature for comfortable use but shall not exceed 49°C (120°F) (see Table 4).” Table 4 gives temp in °F as 100 clinical (include shower), 120 dietary, 160 laundry.
2. 105°F Max UFAS (Uniform Federal Accessibility Standard), 105°F max by automatically controlled tempered water flow, 1988 edition, and ADA (American with Disabilities Act).
3. 100–120°F ACA (American Correctional Association), 100 to 120°F max automatically controlled for prison showers, "Adult Correctional Institutions, 3rd Ed. 1990"
See TABLE of ANTI-SCALD REGULATIONS for country by country and within the U.S. state by state codes, regulations or laws regulating hot water temperatures at the water heater tank, cylinder or geyser and at the point of use bath, shower, sink, etc.
Table of States or Provinces Adopting Anti-Scald Plumbing Codes Hot Water Scald Protection Code Citations for Australia, Britain, Canada, France, New Zealand, U.K., United States, Other Areas |
||
---|---|---|
United States Anti-Scald Codes & Regulations |
||
States or Provinces | Adopted Plumbing Code | Adopted Date or Edition |
18 States including
Delaware |
International Plumbing Code 1993, Max 120°F. New York City: Multiple Dwelling Law § 75; Multiple Residence Law§ 170; NYC Admin. Code § 27-2031 Hot Water Landlords must provide all tenants of multiple dwellings with both hot and cold water. Hot water must register at or above a constant temperature of 120 degrees at the tap. If a tub or shower is equipped with an anti-scald valve that prevents the hot water temperature from exceeding 120 degrees, the minimum hot water temperature for that tub or shower is 110 degrees. New York City Housing Maintenance Code and NY State Multiple Dwelling Law require building owners to provide heat nd hot water to all tenants, providing hot water 365 days a year at a constant minimum [sic] temperature of 120°F |
1997 & 2000 |
13 States Alaska |
Uniform Plumbing Code (IAPMO / ICBO) 1994, Max 120°F. Arizona: DEPARTMENT ORDER 401-PRISON CONSTRUCTION CHAPTER: 401T-PPS ADC Administrative Services, Physical Plant Standards Rev. 02/23/12 [PDF], 105°F adjustable from 100°F to 120°F for sinks, lavatories and showers. Arizona: Maricopa County, Hot Water Supply Code [PDF] California: anti-scald devices are required by the CA 2007 Plumbing Code, Chapter 4, section 418.0 Shower and Tub Combination Control Valves Nevada minimum hot water temperatures: Hot and cold running water are required at all sinks. |
1997 / 2000 |
10 States Alabama |
SBCCI or International Plumbing Code (1996), Max 120°F. | 1997 / 2000 |
5 States |
National Standard Plumbing Code (PHCC) (1996), Max 120°F. | 1996/1998 |
3 States |
State Code Not Yet Committed | |
Nebraska | A40 1993 Safety Standard for Plumbing (ANSI/MCA/PHCC/IAPMO) | 1993 |
States or districts for which hot water temperature limits have not been identified in the U.S. |
[research pending] |
More resources for U.S. Anti-Scald laws
...
Australia's National Plumbing Code AS3500 requires that hot water is stored at a temperature above 60C (140F) and that hot water delivery temperature (at the plumbing fixture) shall not be above 50°C (122°F). The higher storage considers the effort to reduce the risk of Legionella bacteria formation in the system.
More information on Australian anti-scald laws
...
Notes to Canadian Anti-Scald Laws
Notes: proposed change to Canadian plumbing code will specify that water temperature shall not exceed 120°F (49°C) and that water heater temperatures shall not be set so low as to permit growth of Legionella bacteria.
...
Notes to Anti Scald Regulations for France
...
References: www.kiwa.ni provides information on steps to prevent growth of Legionella bacteria in hot water systems.
...
...
...
[pending]
...
[pending]
...
[pending]
...
Hot water temperature at the tap (bath sink, tub, shower) must be 55°C or less. New Zealand building code requires that the maximum hot water temperature at the tap shall be 45°C or less for childcare centres, schools, homes for the elderly and similar facilities.
Typical sources give the ideal hot water temperature setting for hot water cylinders in New Zealand as 60°C in order to keep water hot enough to kill bacteria inside the heater. Higher temperature settings in the cylinder are not necessary and increase water heating costs.
Watch out: 60°C is not the temperature of water that should be delivered at the tap or plumbing fixture - that temperature will cause scalding burns.
See NZS 4617:1989 Tempering (3-port mixing) valves, Date modified: 28/11/1989 regarding Tempering (3-port mixing) valves
Requirements for tempering valves for storage hot water systems particularly in domestic situations where hot water poses a hazard.
These valves are intended to prevent scalding in locations such as homes, schools, motels and residential premises, where ideally all hot water outlets should be sourced from a tempering valve. Provides for valves suitable for water inlet temperatures of up to 100 degrees C.
"Hot water cylinder temperature", Econation, website: econation.com.nz, retrieved 3/21/2014, original source: http://www.econation.co.nz/hot-water-temperature.html#.Uyx6SV6MFpg The site author does not provide direct contact information.
...
England and Wales, from 1 April 2010, revisions to Part G of the Building Regulations (Hot water supply and systems) include the requirement that baths, subject to building regulations, are fitted with a protective device (i.e. a thermostatic mixing valve) to limit the temperature of hot water. Similar regulations have been in force in Scotland since 2006. [2]
As of 1st May 2006 a new Scottish Building Regulation will require that all bath water in a domestic property must be controlled to a maximum of 48°C.
Hot Water Temperature from Sanitary Fittings
Where hot water is provided from storage, building regulations require a storage temperature of 60°C and a circulating temperature of no less than 55°C to prevent the development of Legionella or similar pathogens.
Where water is supplied at high temperature from any source, there is a danger of scalding to building users. Risk of severe injury increases proportionally with the increase in temperature and with the extent of contact.
To prevent scalding, the temperature of hot water discharged from, or to, any bath or bidet should not exceed 48oC.
Where hot and cold water are supplied to a fitting, this may be achieved by use of a thermostatic mixing valve (TMV) or fitting. Such valves or fittings should comply with BS EN 1111 or BS EN 1287.
Guidance on the installation, use and maintenance of thermostatic mixing valves and fittings can be found in BRE information Paper IP 14/03 or from the Thermostatic Mixing Valve Association (TMVA) - www.tmva.org.uk
Additional regulations may yet be pending, under study by the Building Research Establishment (BRE, www.bre.co.uk) for the Department of Transport, Local Government and REgions (DTLR). Proposed hot water storage temperature is 6°C (140°F)
The World Health Organization (WHO) has pointed out a different set of hot water or thermal shock water temperature hazards as well as cold water thermal shock hazards. Quoting:
Body overheating can occur in natural spas and hot tubs, where water temperatures may be above 40 °C. High temperatures can cause drowsiness, which may lead to unconsciousness (especially when associated with alcohol consumption), resulting in drowning (Press, 1991; see Section 2.1).
In addition, high temperatures can lead to heat stroke and death (CPSC, undated).
The CPSC has received reports of several
deaths from extremely hot water (approximately 43 °C) in hot tubs (CPSC, undated).
It
is recommended that water temperatures in hot tubs be kept below 40 °C.
Plunge pools present similar problems, but at the other temperature extreme.
These small, deep pools generally contain water at a temperature of 8–10 °C and in conjunction with saunas or steam baths.
Adverse health outcomes that may
result from the intense and sudden changes in temperature associated with the use
of these pools include immediate impaired coordination, loss of control of breathing
and, after some time when the core body temperature has fallen, slowed heart beat,
hypothermia, muscle cramps and loss of consciousness.
In
general, exposure to temperature extremes should be avoided by pregnant
women, users with medical problems and young children, and prolonged immersion
in hot tubs or other pools with high or low temperatures should be avoided or approached with caution. - WHO (2014)
I want to know if it is legal to have showers with no way to adjust the temperature of the water. I hope you are unbiased. [At our facilities] our showers only have hot water coming out. I have RSD and my legs are extremely sensitive to hot and cold, and I can't even stand the mist if I stand back from the shower spray.
Is there any law that says you have to be able to lower temps of hot water? I would think by now that there could be built in temp adjustments so there would be no handles to break. Thank you for any help you can provide.
Thank you for the question , it helps us realize where we need to work on making our text more clear or more complete. We must emphasize that an onsite inspection by a competent investigator will certainly find conditions and clues that may not yet have been observed nor reported, so any advice by remote email is of necessity incomplete and a bit theoretical.
For example, if the water coming out of showers is hotter than recommended by various safety standards that would be improper. I'm not sure I can say what's legal since rules that pertain to various types of public shower facilities management may be different, but it seems reasonable to me that you could expect basic safety and health standards to apply. That apology made, here are some comments:
There are several types of automatic mixing valves that are designed to be installed on hot water supplies or right at bath fixtures (like a shower) that can be set to a particular temperature - as a safety device to avoid scalding. See the article above for a table of temperatures that suggest what hot water temperature is considered "too hot" or at risk of scalding someone.
In my OPINION, where manual adjustments to shower temperature are not provided, an automatic anti-scalding device should be in place and should be set to a safe temperature. The highest temperature permissible that will reliably avoid scalding is 100 degF.
So start by making some actual temperature measurements, documenting the temp range and the temp variation (if it does) at different times of the day.
Regarding your question of "is it legal" to have no shower temperature control, see the various codes and laws summarized in our table above
- Hot Water Anti-Scald Limits: Laws & Regulations
There are plumbing and safety standards that may apply to shower hot water temperature regulation, such as
Please keep me posted on how things progress, What we both learn may help me help someone else.
As for your hope that our reply would be unbiased, InspectAPedia is an independent publisher of building, environmental, and forensic inspection, diagnosis, and repair information for the public - we have no business nor financial connection with any manufacturer or service provider discussed at our website.
We are dedicated to making our information as accurate, complete, useful, and unbiased as possible: we very much welcome critique, questions, or content suggestions for our web articles.
Watch out: attempts to avoid scalding burn hazards by lowering the maintenance temperature of the water heater itself convey a new hazard: at lower temperatures in water heaters there is a risk of formation of Legionella sp. bacteria. Regarding prevention of Legionella, cf Veterans Administration source in citations at the end of this article.
Water temperatures exceeding 124 degrees Fahrenheit (°F) (51 degrees Celsius (°C)) are necessary to prevent the rapid growth of Legionella , the causative agent of Legionella pneumonia (traditionally known as Legionnaires’ disease) in hot water systems.
Details are at Legionella BACTERIA in WATER HEATERS.
...
Below you will find questions and answers previously posted on this page at its page bottom reader comment box.
On 2022-06-11 by InspectApedia (mod) - please cite research to support opinion on anti-scald regulations issue
@InspectApedia ,
I want to state at the outset that because we were discussing life safety devices that are intended to avoid serious scalding burn injury, it's crucial that we distinguish between what might be your opinion or your field or anecdotal experience versus information for which you, or we together can find credible, expert research documenting your concern for a defect or problem with this type of safety product.
If we have such information we should cite it and to provide it.
We are reading and thinking about it will reply to your comments. But it would be helpful if you would start with a clarification. If the start of your comment you refer to
"these hot water anti-scalding and heat sensors in stove elements is 'inferior' product and NOT standard"
And frankly I'm not sure what device you are discussing.
Anti-scald devices are not found in stoves but rather are a plumbing fitting as I suspect you know. So perhaps we could be a little more clear and what we're discussing. And we'll take it from there.
I agree with you that it's troubling and frustrating that temperature safety controls for residential plumbing systems are
- not completely automatic and not able to handle all conditions such as seasonal water temperature variation
- are not rated for very long life
- require periodic maintenance that is in our OPINION very unlikely to be performed by a normal homeowner or even by some plumbers -see for example torque requirements and dis-assembly required for adjusting the temperature limit stop
In our OPINION litigation around scalding injuries may also have led to more-obscure language in instructions and product descriptions that can be confusing. Does a consumer know how a "pressure balancing valve" regulates hot water temperature?
But it is worth noting that there are now quite a few different temperature regulating and anti-scald or temperature control devices available for plumbing systems, that they do not all work the same way, that some are easier to adjust than others.
Please see details at
ANTI SCALD VALVES & TEMPERATURE CONTROL / MIXING VALVES - home
where various types of anti-scald devices are described, their operation explained (they do NOT operate solely by pressure but instead respond to water temperature), and where we give links to detailed instructions and installation manuals for these devices.
There we include research on the operating life and safety of these devices.
We may later move this discussion to that page.
We welcome your further comments, photos, or references to specific reports, documents etc. that offer an authoritative voice on these concerns.
Re posted by moderator without link - link subject to review.
The reality these devices work by changes in water temperature PRESSURE. and plumbing pressure in pipes 'change' all the time. The valves automatically shut off if pressure of cold and hot water change. and due to all mechanical devices they wear out over time.
It was only mandated in 2013 in Australia and was hotly debatd in 2005. Now these devices only have warranty of 5=10 years only as all mechanical devices break down.
What you have is there is no hot water or even cold water coming out in some cases for some reason. so you have a defective faucet that needs to be replaced and not repairable because the valves are in the metal casing. of the faucet. The faucet of ball valves is basic invention and can last 30 years but these hot temperator control valves have a moving ball and like all 'moving' parts they wear out over time.
This like the new 'mandates' on electric ranges in stoves that shuts off and making appliance unusualbe for the consumer for 'safety reasons' like if
(Disallowed link withheld)
these coils shut off if the temperature is too hot but the sensor malfunctions over time or very quick and woud shut off at even low temperature as these sensors work on liquids expanding or metal expanding to shut off electricity and over time the metal loses its elasticity or expansion or more sensitive so it shuts off even on slow temperature.
The consumer would need to replace the faucet or stove element with these temperatur sensitive every 5 years as they wear out and becom unususebable even f rom the start because of 'safety' concerns by the gov't either pushed by the insurance industry but at cost of inconvenience for 99% of the people. or a lot of people or product is no longe usseable. because there are lot of senile seniors with dementia cooking food or people on drugs. or kids cooking alone at home.well it's their problem . and their risk
now because of gov't regulations and 'safety' lobbyist two home applances are now unuseable or higher breakdown and costly to replace and more garbage in the landfills. many professionals in the building industry opposed because it's not practical and its' a unuseable product
In making new code changes, one has to weigh benefits and risk of any regulation or code. What are the statistics that someone got 'burned' too hot from sink? A person can just turn off the faucet if the water is too hot. right?
So these hot water too hot feature doesn't make sense and the problem is this mechanical device breaks down and shuts off intermittenly whereby the residents can have no water coming from the bathtub for hours and only way to fix is
1. replace the faucet.
2. release the pressure by opening all the faucets in the housing plumbing and water valve release water. so the problem is the pressure changes in the pipe and pressure sensor is malfunctioning or may not even work when news and cons of these heat sensors or water temperature sensors.
These sensors are delicate and work by sensing and wear out. you have more broken faucets that cannot be repaired and cost thousands of KM or gas emissions as repairman has to drive back and forth etc. environmentally its really bad and costly like $300-500 per faucet that needs to be replaced and lots of carbon footprint. These faucets are not repairable and you have to metl more metal to manufacture new one valve these valves cost like $100 or more.
they say 'american standard' is 'standard' these hot water anti-scalding and heat sensors in stove elements is 'inferior' product and NOT standard, you have an unuseable .easy to break 'product' that that is not based on the free market'. this is the case of gov't regulations and building codes trying to fix something that is not broken, there is no problem with stove elements and ball valve faucets...
and ball valves is one of the best inventions in plumbing and was not widely installed in the 1950's as they were more expensive than the old faucet valvest that used rubber rings to shut off cold and hot water.
dont fix somethign that is not broken..same with electric cars too.. i mean..consumers will having large problems with gov't dictacting ice enginees or gov't mandate on fuel efficiency, you have engines that break more or inferiror product as a result of unreasonable hallunicongenic dreamer gov't 'mandates' or regulations. thanks for reading
On 2022-03-10 by Inspectapedia Com Moderator (mod) - Uniform Plumbing Code applies in California
@David Kennedy,
Yes.
On 2022-03-10 by David Kennedy
Does the "Uniform Plumbing Code (IAPMO / ICBO) 1994, Max 120°F." apply to apartments / Landlords in California?
On 2020-03-14 by danjoefriedman (mod)
Hot water temperature needs to be regulated but the device can be located anywhere that's effective; it does not have to be specifically at the sink.
On 2020-03-13 by Derrick Lassen
In the state of Michigan,do commercial sinks have to have a mixing valve in place for state and building codes?
On 2020-01-25 by danjoefriedman (mod) - what is the requirement to add the anti-scalding device during a renovation
Fair question WS but I'd say
1. the "requirement" to add anti-scalding during renovation is in the hands of your local building code compliance officer and building department. Some communities might require adding local anti-scald devices at any such renovation.
2. Adding anti-scalding devices or one to protect the whole building, makes plenty of sense for anybody, and when doing plumbing work that's an opportune time to do so. The risk is of course greater if
- there are elderly, infant, or other fragile people in the building
- the building's water system is delivering water at plumbing fixtures at temperatures above 120F
On 2020-01-25 by wshek@mail.com
Is there a requirement to add the anti-scalding device when the renovation only involves adding of 2 faucets?
@Kristina Martinez,
thank you for posting and for helping out with this;
For other readers
there is a nice water heater flush-out procedure right here at InspectApedia
at
WATER HEATER FLUSH PROCEDURE
On 2021-04-23 by Kristina Martinez
@Rachel,
Yes, could be your hot water heater has not been drained annually and could be clogged with sediment. There are youtube videos showing how to do this. If you don't have the improvement you need then you have to take it to the landlord. Good luck, renters have rights, look them up in your state.
On 2019-08-06 by (mod) - Minimum hot water temperatures to be provided: Nevada
Rachel:
Minimum hot water temperatures for plumbing fixtures in Nevada:
In the article above, at the Table of Countries, States or Provinces Adopting Specific Anti-Scald Laws & Regulations
if you click on your state code NV you'll see Nevada's requirements for hot water. Please take a look.
You'll see that the codes are focused on avoiding scalding burns by setting a MAXIMUM hot water temperature but not a minimum one.
Some cities have in addition rental or tenants' rights laws that specify minimums for hot water, heat, air conditioning, etc.
For example in Southern Nevada code compliance officers include this note:
Hot and cold running water are required at all sinks. Monitor water temperatures. The hot water supply must deliver a minimum of 120°F to ware-washing, prep and utility sinks. 5-102.13. For hand sinks the minimum water temperature is 100°F. 5-202.11. - source: "Critical Violations", Southern Nevada Health District, Tel: (702) 759-1000, Email: environmentalhealth@snhd.org,
southernnevadahealthdistrict.org/ferl/inspection-violations-critical.php retrieved 2019/08/06
On 2019-08-06 by Rachel
Is there a minimum hot water temperature that renters must provide in Nevada? My water takes about 10-12 minutes to get warm and it never really gets hot.
On 2019-07-09 by (mod) - In no case should you be seeing scalding water at the showers
Skye
In no case should you be seeing scalding water at the showers, regardless of what equipment is or isn't installed. More than 120 degF is asking for an injury.
Just what temps are being produced at your pool will vary depending on lots of variables:
- how they make hot water
- distances water has to move
- number of users
- temperature of incoming water (usually it's colder in winter)
- and of course, if they had anti-scald devices installed, the settings on those
Just look for a maximum.
On 2019-07-08 by Skye
This is an excellent reference page. I use a community swimming pool that is wonderful. The showers however has no temperature control at all. And at times the water feels like it is scalding . I am going to take a Thermometer there to see how hot the water is actually.
Question-what is the maximum reasonable temperature in F for a public shower that has no water control temperature.? It is one strange that you push a button and the temperature of water comes out with no temp control. The water is already mixed with hot and cold. 120 Would Be Way too hot. 110 is still quite hot because it’s already mixed with cold. I want to take some readings over a week and report it to the director of the facility and even perhaps the state. I really appreciate it.
It will be about a week before I can test it. I doubt it’s 120 but it sure feels like it’s “scalding”.
On 2019-06-21 by (mod) -
Gail your question is answered in the article above on this page - at the start of the article where we give two-letter state codes for the United States just click on the letters for your state - that'll be VA .
On 2019-06-21 by Gail
Is there a law in Va.that regulates hot water in bath and what is it?
...
Continue reading at TABLE OF SCALDING TEMPERATURES & TIMES or select a topic from the closely-related articles below, or see the complete ARTICLE INDEX.
Or see HOT WATER ANTI-SCALD REGULATION FAQs questions & answers posted originally at this page
Or see these
HOT WATER ANTI-SCALD REGULATIONS at InspectApedia.com - online encyclopedia of building & environmental inspection, testing, diagnosis, repair, & problem prevention advice.
Or see this
Or use the SEARCH BOX found below to Ask a Question or Search InspectApedia
Try the search box just below, or if you prefer, post a question or comment in the Comments box below and we will respond promptly.
Search the InspectApedia website
Note: appearance of your Comment below may be delayed: if your comment contains an image, photograph, web link, or text that looks to the software as if it might be a web link, your posting will appear after it has been approved by a moderator. Apologies for the delay.
Only one image can be added per comment but you can post as many comments, and therefore images, as you like.
You will not receive a notification when a response to your question has been posted.
Please bookmark this page to make it easy for you to check back for our response.
IF above you see "Comment Form is loading comments..." then COMMENT BOX - countable.ca / bawkbox.com IS NOT WORKING.
In any case you are welcome to send an email directly to us at InspectApedia.com at editor@inspectApedia.com
We'll reply to you directly. Please help us help you by noting, in your email, the URL of the InspectApedia page where you wanted to comment.
In addition to any citations in the article above, a full list is available on request.