InspectAPedia tolerates no conflicts of interest. We have no relationship with advertisers, products, or services discussed at this website.
Repair the stripped screw opening at a metal electrical box using the Metal Box Mender:
This article describes using the Metal Box Mender, a U.K. electrical box repair product sold there and on eBay and used for repairing stripped screw holes at mounts for electrical switches, receptacles or electrical box covers.
This article series describes how to repair the mounting screw or screw opening at an electrical box used to mount a receptacle, switch, or other device. A stripped screw or screw opening at an electrical box is more than annoying, it's unsafe as the device will not be mounted safely and securely to the wall, ceiling or other location.
[Click to enlarge any image]
In the U.K. inventor David Sexton provides his invention, "Metal Box Mender" a kit that "mends threadbare screw holes in electrical metal boxes without replacing the box and without damaging surrounding area of the box." This article describes the product and discusses details about its use including using the Mender to repair electrical boxes in the U.K., U.S. and other countries.
Separately at ELECTRICAL BOX SCREW REPAIR - home - we discuss other methods for repairing not only a stripped screw opening on metal electrical boxes but also on plastic electrical boxes as well as repair methods for stripped electrical box or device screws themselves.
Watch out: repair attempts for stripped screw openings in any electrical box installed in a ceiling risks mechanical connections that may not be strong enough to carry the weight of suspended light fixtures or ceiling fans. Do not attempt such repairs; replace the damaged ceiling electrical box and be sure that the replacement is properly secured to the building structure.
[Click to enlarge any image]
The screw (3) passes through the upper portion of the metal box mender (1) then passes through the metal ear of the electrical box and into the screw-holding base of the metal box mender screw receiver. As the screw is tightened the little black plastic retainer pin (2) falls out into the electrical box.
Just to the right of the word "Assembly" in the photo you can see the light-coloured edge of the electrical box's original metal screw receiving tab.
Watch out: in this illustration the parts are not being correctly used: for demonstration purposes I've left off the box cover or alternatively the electrical device such as an electrical receptacle or light switch that the screw would be holding in place. Otherwise you'd not have been able to see how these parts go together. But screwing down the bugle head screw as I'm doing here will damage the metal box mender causing that part to fail and resulting in a possible safety hazard: loose electrical wiring and components.
More about this problem is given later at METAL ELECTRICAL BOX MENDER CAVEATS
On first reading about this product I was concerned about the the use of sharp-tipped "mender" screws that could, after passing through the polypropylene mender and pin assembly then puncture an electrical wire inside the electrical box. But Sexton's design now uses a metal wood screw with a flattened tip to reduce that hazard.
Dave was kind enough to send me some samples of the Metal Box Mender along with instructions and a little 35mm square metal electrical box listed for U.K. use. I took a look at the Metal Box Mender, its instructions, parts and components and have documented what I saw in the photographs and comments given here. Currently this product is sold only in the U.K. and on eBay and it has not been tested nor listed for use in the U.S.
The metal box mender is indeed intended only for metal electrical boxes. It is not sized nor designed to repair plastic or PVC electrical boxes whose screw threads have been stripped. However intelligent selection of an over-sized screw and possibly a tiny bit of drilling can permit repair and continued use of plastic electrical boxes using methods described beginning at ELECTRICAL BOX SCREW REPAIR.
[Click to enlarge any image]
The basic instructions for installing the metal box mender are both simple and confusing. Simple because the actual installation procedure is easy, and confusing because the four different coloured cards pertain to four different product combinations among which you'll want to make the proper choice.
Below I've included but expanded on the manufacturer's original instructions that can be read on the illustrations given just above. I found the company's website and printed instructions confusing, in part because I did not immediately understand that the product design involves five measurements, four instruction cards, two metal box mender sizes and two metal box mender screw sizes. If you wonder why there are four nearly-identical looking product cards in four different colors, that's the trouble.
Watch out: My expanded "Metal Box Mender installation instructions" listed below have not been approved by the manufacturer and are subject to technical review and corrections.
Note: in my photo at above right I'm installing a U.S. sized electrical receptacle in a U.S. sized metal electrical box. This is not the same product as the U.K.-sized electrical junction box at above left.
Watch out: if any electrical box repair method cannot provide a very secure mount or screw receiver for the screws that hold an electrical receptacle ("wall outlet" or "wall plug" or "wall socket") in place there is a risk that the whole receptacle may be pulled out of the wall when someone is simply trying to un-plug a power cord that has been plugged in to the receptacle. The result would be unsafe, risking electrical shock, short circuit, or fire.
For this reason, when you are evaluating any approach to repairing an electrical box or stripped screw or stripped screw receiver you must be sure that the repair is of adequate strength to resist pulling on an electrical receptacle secured to that box. Light switches and electrical box covers are not subjected to the same outwards force as is an electrical receptacle.
Metal Electrical Box Mender Product Sizes, Choices, Specs
|Distance H: screw hole to box wall||Screw Length||Screw Color||Instruction Card||"Mender"
Screw Receiver Height
|Up to 10 mm||15mm||Silver||Yellow instruction card||17mm (factory)|
|Up to 10 mm||?? mm (sample not provided)||Gold||Tan instruction card||17mm (factory)|
|10-14 mm||15 mm||Silver||Blue instruction card||17mm (factory)|
|10-14 mm||?? mm (sample not provided)||Gold||Green instruction card||17mm (factory)|
|ADJUST by SANDING?|
I suspect that a product engineer will ultimately design a "one size fits all" solution that reduces product cost and price and simplifies the ordering and installation instructions.
The screw receiver, which is the main component of the metal box mender, is simply slipped over the stripped metal ear of the electrical box to be repaired. is 17mm in total height and consists of a thinner upper portion
When you add the additional thickness of a box cover or the steel mounting ears of an electrical receptacle of switch (about another 2 mm of metal ears or as much as 6mm if you are using a typical U.K. Crabtree brand plastic blank cover plate) to the 17mm screw receiver height, the total thickness that will receive the Mender's screws is 20mm or more: there is no chance that the silver screw (total length 15mm, screw reach about 11mm) will penetrate past the bottom of the plastic metal box mender.
Thus there is little chance that the pointed screw would puncture a live wire inside the electrical box - a source of unpleasant (unsafe) events. such as sparks, shorts, or more.
The upper screw in my photo above is the 16mm silver bugle headed wood screw provided by the Metal Box Mender manufacturer. As se noted above the company also provides a 20mm. The manufacturer explains:
The full original length of the small screw is 16mm. The Mender is 7mm + 3mm gap + 3mm + depth of switch 3mm = 16mm with trim of screw approx 2mm . The longer screw without trim = 20mm still giving the the same result if box is deeper within wall. - private email 4 Sep 2015
The lower OEM screw is a 22 mm (about 0.9") long typical machine-thread, blunt-tipped and longer screw provided with electrical switches and receptacles and was the OEM screw used to secure these devices to the electrical box metal ears or tabs before you or I, with our power screwdriver, stripped the screw, screw hole, or both.
Watch out: if the repair screw is too short for all of the thicknesses involved then it will not screw securely into the "Mender" and / or may strip its hole in the mender resulting in dangerously-loose electrical components. This is exactly what happened when I used the short silver screw and the Crabtree #4001 blank cover plate atop the U.K.-sized electrical box with the Metal Box Mender. Turning the screw gently by hand I found it rotated endlessly and never got tight. It was too short for this application. The gold screw available from the manufacturer may have worked.
Watch out: if the repair screw is too long for all of the components being secured and if the screw has a sharp point (later screws I'm told will be blunt-ended) it can penetrate an electrical wire in the electrical box causing a dangerous short circuit or fire. The manufacturer warned to keep wires from behind the "Mender" in the electrical box, but in the real world of electrical wiring one cannot be absolutely certain that a wire was not pushed back into this forbidden zone when the device (switch, receptacle, spliced wires) is/are pushed back into the electrical box.
Technical note: the Metal Box Mender features and properties discussed next include upside down installation, use on U.S. or Canadian metal electrical boxes, and other features not intended for this product. The U.K. manufacturer of the Metal Box Mender is considering producing a similar product intended for Canadian or U.S.- sized metal electrical boxes.
Below is the Crabtree E40001 blank plate or "blind" electrical box cover installed on the metal U.K. electrical box provided for our inspection. Using the 15mm long silver bugle-headed wood screw provided by the manufacture I found that my screw stripped and spun in the Mender's screw receiver and I could not obtain a tight connection of the plastic blank plate to the electrical box. I suspect that a longer screw would have worked fine.
The silver Metal Box Mender screw provided by the manufacturer is about 15mm in length and is a bugle-headed wood-screw. OEM screws provided for U.S. & Canadian electrical devices such as electrical receptacles or switches are typically a machine-threaded screw of about 22mm in overall length. Other screw lengths vary according to application. For example the OEM screw for securing a blind cover plate or receptacle or switch cover is typically about 13mm in length.
Watch out: although the manufacturer recommends, and many electricians like to use a power screwdriver to speed the installation of electrical devices, you may find it a bit easy to strip the screw holding portion of the Mender. In fact that is how some metal electrical box screw-receiving ears got stripped in the first place. For a one-off electrical repair such as the typical application of the Metal Box Mender described here, I recommend turning your screws by hand and I recommend that you avoid over-tightening.
I had some trouble keeping the Mender in place regardless of whether the plastic pin was inserted or not. However if I could hold it in place until the repair screw had begun to enter the screw receiver the repair continued successfully. This problem may be avoided if the Mender pin is properly placed: the device may rotate on the pin but it should not move enough to lose screw opening alignments.
The screw receiver on the U.S. and U.K. electrical boxes are a bit different in size. If you don't position the Mender properly you may have trouble inserting the pin through the Mender and through the hole in the screw receiver on the electrical box.
Watch out: if you can't be bothered to follow the manufacturer's instructions about using that little plastic pin you may be bothered by the result. Even on a U.K. electrical box, if you omit the little plastic pin you may find that as you begin the turn in the mounting screw the Mender will move out of place (below right).
At below left I left out the plastic pin and found that the Mender moved out of place when I tried to turn a screw through it.
At below right: I had a bit of trouble pushing the pin through the original screw opening of this U.S. metal electrical box.
Watch out: the Mender in the two photos below was also being installed "upside down" and is not consistent with the manufacturer's instructions. The reason for this "upside down" installation was a test of the device for use on North American metal electrical boxes - a topic we discuss below. The rotation shown here can occur in both proper and improper installations of the Mender.
In fact I was able to position the Mender on the U.S. Box and to install the electrical receptacle without using the alignment pin but I had to hold the parts in position with some care that plastic pin was giving me a hard time.
Watch out: depending on the thickness of the metal tabs of the electrical switch or receptacle being secured using the Mender and depending on the width or diameter of the screw opening in the switch or receptacle tabs, the too-small bugle-headed wood screw provided by the manufacturer can pass right through the switch or receptacle tab. You may notice the problem and you might add a tiny metal washer and start over again. But the screw may have already split the Mender's retention head as shown in my photos above.
A half to one millimeter or two may not seem important but when we combine the bugle-headed under-profile of the Mender repair screw with the smaller diameter, it's going to spread and go right through some electrical switch or receptacle screw openings, resulting in a loose and unsafe electrical device.
Below you can see my comparison of the sizes of typical screws used with and sold along with electrical receptacles and switches. At below left is the larger-headed machine threaded screw used in North America and inserted into the mounting ears of an electrical receptacle. At below right is the smaller bugle-headed wood-screw provided by the Metal Box Mender manufacturer inserted into the same mounting ears. With tightening the widest (topmost) point of the 7mm wide head of the Mender's screw will push right through the 6.5mm wide opening in the electrical receptacle leaving the device poorly-secured.
In its present design, the Metal Box Mender screw receiver is too tall for U.S. devices regardless of whether it is installed right-way up or upside down. The manufacturer is considering designing a revised Metal Box Mender intended for U.S. & Canadian-sized electrical boxes.
At below left is a U.K. steel electrical box. In these electrical boxes the metal tab that receives the retaining screw for an electrical switch or receptacle is itself about 4 mm below the upper or outermost edge of the box.
At below right you see that in its installed position the top of the plastic Mender is about 2-3 mm above the top edge of the metal box.
Note: The screw was used in this photo to hold the Mender device in place for our photo. In a proper installation the Metal Box Mender mounting screw must be passed first through the metal tabs or ears of the device mounting strap: an electrical switch or electrical receptacle as we show in the next image. Tightening a bugle-head screw onto the Mender without first passing it through the metal strap of a switch or receptacle will damage or split the Mender rendering it unsafe.
Below you see the position of an electrical receptacle (or switch) metal mounting strap when properly installed and tightened into position on the U.K. electrical box. It's about 2 mm above the box edge or uppermost surface.
The position of the metal electrical box ear or tab that receives a device or box cover screw on U.S., Canadian and some other electrical boxes is nearly at the top edge of the electrical box and is on some boxes exactly flush with the box edge, depending on the electrical box brand and model, as you can see below. The screw receiving tab on the U.S. / Canadian electrical boxes is anywhere from flush with to about 2mm below the face-edge of the box.
At below right you can see the dimensions of the screw tab and the location of its screw receiving opening.
This means that trying to use the Metal Box Mender on a North American electrical box will leave the electrical switch, receptacle, or box cover sticking up considerably past the face of the box and in most cases projecting out past the wall surface to an unacceptable distance - shown at below left.
So we use two Menders, one at each device screw to avoid a tipped device (below left).
As you see at above right, on a typical U.S. metal electrical box the Mender repair will leave our switch or receptacle about 8 mm. above the face of the box. The receptacle or switch along with its cover are going to project out from the face of the wall by an extra 8mm or more (about 5 1/6") as well as leaving an open gap behind the cover plate exposing the electrical box interior: an unsafe condition.
At below right I'm installing the Metal Box Mender upside down and not as recommended by the manufacturer on a typical U.S. electrical box. Why was I trying this? Because installed "right way up" will bring the electrical switch or receptacle face up out of the electrical box by 11-12 mm - making the whole assembly stick out of the wall surface and creating an unacceptable installation.
The plastic device still projects considerably above the upper edge of the box. If the box is recessed in the wall and you're not using a box extender to bring that box face forward then you might still be OK - or not.
The manufacturer advises that you can sand down the upper portion of the screw-receiving "Mender" if necessary. You'll need to do this in cases where the metal ear into which the device or cover mounting screws turn or pass is "high" in the box - as we illustrate below. You will see that the distance from the upper surface of the metal electrical box screw-receiving "ear" on U.S. electrical boxes is much closer to the upper edge of the electrical box than on typical U.K. electrical boxes.
The receptacle mounting ears are sticking up 1/4" past the face of the electrical box (below). You'd have to sand off the entire face of the plastic Mender to bring the electrical receptacle back to its original mounting position.
This means that trying to use the Metal Box Mender on a U.S. or Canadian electrical box is going to give some trouble with the product's U.K. dimensions: if you don't sand the top of the Mender down to a quite thin dimension your wall plate or cover plate of the box is not going to sit flush and tight against the wall. Rather the plate will separate from the wall by 4-5 mm or still nearly 1/4".
Watch out: when you sand or file down the plastic bottom of a of the "Mender" that you're also installing upside down to make your electrical parts fit properly on U.S. or Canadian metal electrical boxes you're reducing that overall 17mm screw receiver height to something less. In turn that means that the point of a longer screw may penetrate and pass out of the bottom of the "Mender" and thus it could damage an electrical wire causing a short or fire.
Watch out: You are also modifying an electrical component and using it not in accordance with the manufacturer's instructions. Even if a device has been tested and listed for use in electrical systems, modifying it or using it other than as intended violates both the manufacturer's instructions and fails to comply with the electrical codes in most jurisdictions.
Earlier I explained that one of my illustration photos risked damage to the Mender by causing it to split. In my photo below I've backed the Mender screw out a bit but my green arrows point to faint markings that show where the bugle-head of the screw contacted the raised sizes of the top portion of the Mender, and my red arrow points to the spit developing in this part, rendering it damaged and possibly unsafe.
Note: the photo below does not illustrate a procedure recommended by the manufacturer because
At below left is an un-damaged, intact Metal Box Mender screw receiver.
Below you can see three interesting details in a damaged Metal Box Mender screw receiver:
The two small holes in the upper photo show us where the tip of the sharp-pointed wood screw missed the proper screw opening and tried to penetrate the Mender block at the wrong location. Using a manual screwdriver I could feel this trouble and I could move the screw for another try. If I'd been using a power screwdriver the screw would have entered the block at the wrong location (one of those two little holes) and I'm not sure how the device would perform.
The center screw opening shows a beveled edge - signs that the bugle portion of the bugle-headed wood screw entered and spread the screw receiver.
The split at the right center of the Mender shows that this device has "failed" or more fairly, I broke it. If you screw the bugle-headed wood screw fully into the Mender without the screw passing first through a box cover or switch or receptacle mounting tab the bugle-shaped screw head will pass into the Mender's plastic top segment causing it to split. The result is an insecure holding device that may be unsafe, risking electrical short or fire. I made this mistake. Don't do it.
Proper electrical wiring in most countries requires a physical grounding conductor wire between a grounding terminal screw on the electrical receptacle or switch and the electrical circuit's grounding conductor wire, usually joined by a crimp-splice or sometimes by a twist-on connector.
However amateur electrical wiring too often omits this connecting wire and instead relies on the coincidental ground path between the metal strap or body of the electrical receptacle or switch, through its mounting tabs, through its mounting screw to the metal ear on the metal electrical box that in turn may be grounded to the circuit ground or may be grounded through the metal jacket of older BX armored cable.
Watch out: this is not a safe, reliable ground connector. However it may be the only one present on an older electrical circuit and it may have been "working" - somewhat. If you then repair a stripped metal electrical box mounting screw opening with a plastic Metal Box Mender and the Mender's wood screw, even that improper and rather iffy ground could be lost.
U.K. readers who need to repair a stripped screw mounting hole on an electrical box should contact the Metal Box Mender inventor, David Sexton at the addresses given below.
Note: my understanding is that the MBM or Metal Box Mender, sold directly from the producer and also sold in Ebay (£2.88 postage paid (VAT included) for Single packs of 2 Menders), has not been tested nor listed for use in the United States nor Canada. For North American, Australian, New Zealand, Canadian or other applications, look for a product listing and approval that applies in your country.
Technical note on the illustrations in this article: the metal electrical boxes used in this article were selected to permit illustration of the electrical box screw repair parts and installation procedures. The boxes themselves may not be of adequate size in cubic inches and certainly do not include the hardware that would be needed to mount these boxes in a building wall.
Continue reading at ELECTRICAL OUTLET BOX SCREW REPAIR or select a topic from closely-related articles below, or see our complete INDEX to RELATED ARTICLES below.
METAL ELECTRICAL BOX SCREW REPAIR, METAL BOX MENDER at InspectApedia.com - online encyclopedia of building & environmental inspection, testing, diagnosis, repair, & problem prevention advice.
Or use the SEARCH BOX found below to Ask a Question or Search InspectApedia
Try the search box below or CONTACT US by email if you cannot find the answer you need at InspectApedia.
Questions & answers or comments about ways to replace an electrical outlet or switch mounting screw when threads are stripped on the screw or in the mounting box.
Use the "Click to Show or Hide FAQs" link just above to see recently-posted questions, comments, replies, try the search box just below, or if you prefer, post a question or comment in the Comments box below and we will respond promptly.
Search the InspectApedia website