Window efficiency ratings: this article explains window efficiency and efficiency ratings, as well as specific features in window selection and installation that affect the window's energy efficiency.
Green links show where you are. © Copyright 2015 InspectApedia.com, All Rights Reserved.
In this article series we discuss the selection and installation of windows and doors, following best construction and design practices for building lighting and ventilation, with attention to the impact on building heating and cooling costs, indoor air quality, and comfort of occupants.
[Click to enlarge any image, photo, or table]
We review the proper installation details for windows and doors, and we compare the durability of different window and door materials and types. This article includes excerpts or adaptations from Best Practices Guide to Residential Construction, by Steven Bliss, courtesy of Wiley & Sons.
Also see WINDOW / DOOR ENERGY EFFICIENT, DOE, see Skylight Energy Efficiency, and to improve existing windows, see WINDOW / DOOR AIR LEAK SEALING HOW TO. See WINDOWS & DOORS our home page for window and door information, and also see WINDOW TYPES - Photo Guide for a photographic guide to window and door types and architectural styles. Ourlinks listed at the "More Reading" links at the bottom of this article provide in-depth articles on window and door selection, inspection, installation, problem diagnosis, and repair.
Windows have a large impact on a home’s energy consumption, accounting for up to 25% of a typical home’s heating bills in cold climates and up to 50% of cooling bills in hot climates, according to the Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) Energy Star program. Even the best windows, with an R-value of 3 to 4, are thermal holes compared to today’s average R-19 wall. In addition to conductive heat losses, older windows add substantially to a home’s air leakage.
Beyond fuel bills, windows can also have a dramatic effect on occupant comfort. Sitting next to a leaky single glazed window in winter will make an occupant feel cold regardless of the thermostat setting, due to both cold drafts and to radiant heat losses from his or her body to the window surface.
Cold window surfaces also cause condensation, potentially leading to mold, peeling paint, and wood decay of window components. (Also see CONDENSATION or SWEATING PIPES, TANKS and DEW POINT TABLE - CONDENSATION POINT GUIDE as well as HUMIDITY LEVEL TARGET.)
Evaluating a window’s energy performance is a complex task that has been made a lot simpler by two programs developed in a collaborative effort between government and industry. The groups have developed standardized testing procedures and ratings, and provide simple recommendations based on climate zone.
The National Fenestration Rating Council (NFRC), with support from the U.S. Department of Energy, created test procedures and rating systems for the energy performance of windows, glazed doors, and skylights. Any window making energy claims without an NFRC label should be avoided.
For every window, the NFRC label rates the U-factor, Solar-Heat-Gain Coefficient (SHGC), and Visible Transmittance (VT). Air Leakage (AL) and Condensation Resistance (CR) are optional ratings. The ratings are explained briefly in Figure 3-7 and in more detail in the following sections. Ratings should appear on the window label when delivered but can also be found on the NFRC website at www.nfrc.org.
It is important to note that NFRC ratings apply to the entire window, including the sash and the frame. NFRC uses a single standard size to simplify testing and to make it easier for consumers to make apples-to-apples comparisons between windows.
The actual energy performance of windows significantly larger or smaller than the standard test size will vary somewhat from the label since the relative effect of the glass edge and frame is greater on smaller windows.
Where glass-only ratings are needed, for example, for passive solar design, these can usually be obtained from the window manufacturer or the manufacturer of the insulated glass unit (IGU) installed in the window or door.
Launched by the U.S. EPA to promote the use of energy-efficient appliances and equipment, the Energy Star label was added to doors, windows, and skylights in 1998. An Energy Star Label certifies that the window or skylight meets the U.S. Department of Energy’s (DOE) energy guidelines for the climate zones listed on the label (see Table 3-3 below).
For windows without the label, you can still use the Energy Star guidelines in Table 3-3 (above) as a selection guide. Remember that these guidelines are based on NFRC whole-window ratings, not just the glass. For cold-climate buildings designed to use passive-solar heating, look for a whole-window SHGC of .55 or above.
A window’s ability to conduct heat (not including solar effects) is usually given as a U-factor or U-value. The lower the U-value, the more insulation value a window provides. Low U-values have the biggest impact in heating dominated climates but help reduce cooling loads as well. For climates with substantial heating or cooling loads, choose a total window U-value of .35 or less. The U-value is the inverse of the more familiar R-value.
For example, standard double glazing has a center- of-glass U-value of about .5, which equals an R-value of 2 (1/0.5). Typical glazing U-values are shown in Table 3-4 (below). U-values for the entire window, however, must take into account the edge spacers, sash, and frame, as discussed below.
The NFRC (National Fenestration Council) in discussing solar heat gain at windows, describes the U-Factor (U) as follows:
Also see DEFINITION of HEATING & COOLING TERMS for discussion and definitions of R, U, and K Factors in building heat loss, heat loss resistance, and insulation values.
Filling low-E coated glass with the inert gas argon or krypton will reduce heat loss through the glass by 10 to 15%. Krypton outperforms argon somewhat, but it is usually not enough to justify the higher cost.
Since argon fill is now available on most low-E windows for little or no cost, getting the boost in R-value is always a good idea. In addition to reducing heat loss, it increases the temperature of the inside surface of the window, improving comfort and reducing condensation.
Studies indicate that about 10% of the gas will leak out of a well-built sealed glass unit in about 20 years.
The U-value of the entire window, as reported on NFRC labels, includes the effects of the glass edge, sash, and frame.With high-R glass, standard edge and frame materials often lower than the overall R-value compared to the center-of-glass measure.
Aluminum sash and frames without thermal breaks are the worst, contributing to both thermal losses and condensation in cold climates.
Thermally broken metal frames are better but should still be avoided in cold climates.Wood and hollow vinyl or fiberglass components all have moderately good thermal properties. Insulated vinyl and fiberglass frames offer the best thermal performance (Table 3-5).
[Click to enlarge any image, photo, or table]
Because of their high thermal conductivity, standard aluminum edge spacers lower the insulating value of insulated glass units (IGUs) and often cause condensation along the bottom of the window. The loss of insulation value is more pronounced in very high R-value windows and small windows where the window edge accounts for a larger proportion of the window area.
Starting in the mid-1980s, manufacturers have responded with a variety of innovative solutions that are now used in about half of all new IGUs.
Solutions include using less conductive metals with an improved shape (PPG’s Intercept Spacer) or switching to a plastic or synthetic rubber spacer with little or no metal content (TruSeal’s Swiggle Seal or EdgeTech’s Super Spacer). Warm-edge windows can raise the glass temperature at the perimeter of the window by 6°F to 8°F, significantly reducing the condensation potential.
The biggest risk in using a new edge technology is that the seal will fail prematurely, resulting in a fogged unit. To guard against this, it is best to stick with a technology that has proven itself in the marketplace and is backed by a good warranty and a reliable window manufacturer.
Low-emissivity, or “low-E,” coatings are microscopically thin metallic coatings applied to a glass surface, which reflect back radiant heat.
Different low-E coatings transmit different amounts of visible light, short-wave and longwave infrared, and ultraviolet radiation (Figure 3-8 at left).
The most common type, called “soft coat” low-E, is applied to one of the inner surfaces of sealed insulated glass units (Figure 3-9 at left).
Hard-coat, or “pyrolitic,” low-E, which has a slightly lower R-value, is used in high-solar-gain glass and can also be used on storm windows and other removable glass panels exposed to the air.
Low-E window glass coatings can also be applied to a clear polyester film, called Heat Mirror, which is suspended between two panes of sealed glass, yielding insulation values as high as R-5 with one layer of film or R-8 with two layers.
Also see SUNGAIN, FILMS, LOW-E GLASS.
The newest generation of low-E glazing, often referred to as “spectrally selective,” provides an ideal combination of high R-values, low heat gain, and high-visible-light transmittance.
Spectrally selective windows generally outperform all other window types in mixed and hot climates, but they reap the greatest benefit in homes with significant cooling loads.
Because of their high insulation value, spectrally selective windows even perform well in cold climates, particularly in homes with significant air-conditioning loads or large amounts of west facing glass (see Window Orientation).
One exception is a house designed to use passive solar gain in winter, which would perform better with high-solar-gain glass.
-- Adapted and paraphrased, edited, and supplemented, with permission from Best Practices Guide to Residential Construction.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about window energy efficiency
Question: our Low-E Argon-Filled Bonneville™ windows & doors seem to be gaining too much heat - can you help us figure out what's going on?
We started construction on a new home in Riva, MD near Annapolis in 2011. This is a second home so we are generally there only on the weekends. We purchased our Low-e windows and doors from Architectural Window Supply (AWS) in Annapolis. On the recommendation of the owner of AWS we purchased low-e, argon gas filled Bonneville windows and doors - and paid cash up front. Bonneville ceased operations and eventually filed for bankruptcy after we ordered our windows and doors. Fortunately, with the help of the owner of Architectural Window Supply we were able to get most of our windows and doors. The house was completed in June 2012.
Our question concerns the efficiency – or more accurately the ‘inefficiency’ – of the windows. here is a quick summary:
So we are looking to understand why it gets so hot inside our great room. Can you help us understand this issue – or recommend someone we can pose this question to?
Reply from Steven Bliss (www.buildingadvisor.com)
A few comments & suggestions:
It would be useful to know the energy specifications of the windows used. Most windows come with an NFRC label showing the U-factor, solar-heat-gain coefficient (SHGC), and other data.
The typical low-e window with argon has a U-factor of around .32 – equivalent to an R-value of about 3. An average wall today, by comparison, has an R-value of 19 or more, so the best window offers much less insulation than an average wall. The argon increases the insulation value by about 10%, and has only a negligible effect on solar heat gain. Unless these are high-solar-gain windows, it is unlikely that the type of windows are responsible for the overheating, since typical low-e windows let in a lot less solar heat gain than double clear glass (if you can even buy those nowadays).
The problem is more likely due to the amount of glass, size of room, and level of insulation. New homes with tight construction and high levels of insulation are easy to overheat when too much solar gain enters the building.
A window’s solar gain is measured by the Solar Heat Gain Coefficient (SHGC). The higher the number, the greater to solar gain into the house. Low-e glass can be engineered for low, medium, or high solar gain. In southern and central states, the US DOE (in its Energy Star program) recommends that glass have a SHGC of .30 or less. In hot climates, or in houses with lots of east-facing and west-facing glass, heat-reflecting glass with a SHGC of under .25 is often the best choice.
The problem with too much east- and west-facing glass is that in spring, summer, and fall, the sun strikes this glass at a low angle, increasing the solar gain and making it difficult to shade. I don’t know how much southeast glass this house has, but apparently it has too much for thermal comfort. Short of removing windows or replacing them with low solar-gain glass, some options are:
Which solution is right for you depends on your budget and design preferences. A designer or architect experienced in passive solar design can help you select the right product and calculate how much benefit each product will provide.
As for the temperature readings you are getting, if the thermometer is in direct sunlight, you are not getting an accurate measure of the air temperature in the room.
Green link shows where you are in this article series.
Questions & answers or comments about window efficiency ratings - how to translate the numbers on building window stickers and labels into efficiency or energy performance.
Use the "Click to Show or Hide FAQs" link just above to see recently-posted questions, comments, replies, try the search box just below, or if you prefer, post a question or comment in the Comments box below and we will respond promptly.
Search the InspectApedia website
HTML Comment Box is loading comments...
Technical Reviewers & References