False electrical ground inspection & detection: this article answers basic questions about false grounds and their related safety concerns. Page top photo is courtesy of Jim P. Simmons - Mr. Electric.
Green links show where you are. © Copyright 2017 InspectApedia.com, All Rights Reserved.
Our photo at left shows a home wired with knob-and-tube circuitry. A knob and tube circuit does not include a grounding conductor or "ground wire" so any receptacles or other devices powered by such a circuit will normally lack the added safety of electrical grounding.
But electrical wiring errors combined with hasty inspection and testing may lead an inspector or homeowner to think that a device such as an electrical receptacle on such a circuit is "grounded" when it is not. Here we provide photos and discussion of such a case.
Older homes often have electrical receptacles and fixtures that are ungrounded, and many local codes do not require that they be rewired so they're grounded. Still, grounding is worth adding to your system because it adds protection against electrical shock.
Grounding provides a third path for electricity to travel along, so if there is a leak of any sort, it will flow into the earth rather than into the body of a person who touches a defective fixture, appliance, or tool.
An electrical system is grounded with a local grounding rod driven at least 8 feet into the ground outside the house or by connecting to a cold water pipe. Each individual branch circuit must be grounded as well, either with a separate wire that leads to the neutral bar of the service panel or with metal sheathing that runs without a break from each outlet to the panel. (In theory, electrical outlets can be grounded individually, but this is impractical.)
In some older homes we find incorrectly installed "grounded" electrical outlets that have the opening for the grounded plug ground connector, but the electrical system has no ground path present. If you are replacing an electrical receptacle on an ungrounded circuit you should use two-slot non-grounded electrical receptacles.
But worse than installing a "grounded-type" electrical receptacle on an electrical circuit where no ground is present, is the dangerous step that a few amateurs take of connecting the receptacle's ground screw to the neutral or white wire in the circuit.
Jim Simmons is a professional and licensed electrician who studies electrical field failures and unsafe electrical wiring.
His photos at left and below show an improperly wired electrical circuit that provides a "false ground" by making a connection from the neutral wire to the ground screw. This connection may make it appear that the circuit is "grounded" since a test that connects the hot side of the receptacle to the ground port will show current flowing, but this is incorrect.
Not only does a "false ground" electrical receptacle lack an actual safe alternative path to earth through a separate ground path or grounding conductor, but worse, the "ground" connection, by being wired to the neutral side of the circuit, can cause dangerous electrical shock as well as damage to equipment plugged into such an electrical outlet.
A safer repair would be to install new electrical wiring that provided a ground path along with grounded electrical receptacles.
Mr. Simmons wrote "A simple $7 tester will test this outlet as OK.
The Ideal tester I use clearly shows FG on the display, or False Ground. I have seen it many times over the years but this is the first time I got good pictures of it. You can see the copper jumper from the ground terminal to the neutral."
See ELECTRICAL GROUND SYSTEM INSPECTION for details about how to inspect the electrical grounding system at a building.
Our photo (left) shows a polarized electrical outlet that does not provide a ground connection for a grounded plug. You can see that the two slots are of different sizes. This is an un-grounded outlet.
If your outlets have two slots that are the same size, then they are neither polarized nor grounded.
These are non-polarized or un-polarized, un-grounded electrical receptacles. You should not install grounded electrical outlets on circuits where no ground path is actually present (such as knob and tube wiring).
To provide a grounded outlet where no ground is present is dangerous.
Some locations in your house- especially where the outlet and/or appliances may become wet- require ground-fault circuit-interrupter (GFCI) receptacles. Older, ungrounded circuits usually are protected by polarization, which is less effective than grounding but better than nothing. Grounded and polarized receptacles work only if they are wired correctly.
If you look closely at bottom connecting strap below the face the electrical outlet show above, just above our red (C) notice, you'll see a white-painted wire wrapped around the metal strap used to mount this connector in the electrical box.
Unlike the earlier "False Ground" case, this electrical receptacle was wired with a "false neutral" using bell wire or telephone wire.
The receptacle was mounted in a metal junction box and wired with two-wire armored cable (BX) that contained a hot and neutral wire. But a fault in the neutral wiring in this building caused the receptacle to stop working.
A previous owner or handyman "fixed" this problem by making a flimsy connection between the neutral screw on the receptacle and the receptacle's mounting ("ground") strap.
Since the circuit wire was armored cable, a path to ground was provided by the metal jacket of the wire itself.
But when the amateur electrician wired the receptacle as we found it, plugging anything into the receptacle completes a circuit from the hot side of the receptacle through the powered device (say a vacuum cleaner), back to the neutral side of the receptacle, and through that telephone wire off to the mounting strap which connects to the metal junction box and the BX metal jacket that completes a circuit to earth, rather than through the proper neutral wire.
What happens when you use this unsafe electrical receptacle? Well when that vacuum cleaner is running the return current is traveling on the armored cable jacket - the metal "BX" exterior as well as other components in the electrical system become live.
Just touching the "BX" wire jacket and grounding yourself, say to a radiator, can give a nasty shock - which is how the author discovered this erroneously wired device.
Watch out: The danger of connecting neutral to ground anywhere but in the panel is that when the circuit is active current is flowing on the grounding conductor or for BX / armored cable it's flowing in the metal BX jacket.
Those are not intended to carry normal operating current. Someone can be shocked, even killed from that condition. It's not just theory, those shocks have actually happened, even in cases I've seen personally. - excerpted from InspectApedia.com and private correspondence with the reader 3/29/17
[Click to enlarge any image]
So you are saying this [connecting the neutral to ground at a receptacle] is dangerous?
The neutral is connected to one screw at recept and at the other end in the panel box it’s either connected to the same slot or different one on the same grounding/neutral bus bar.
The ground wire is on it’s ground screw at receptacle with a jumper from the other screw on the same side of recept neutral [shown in the reader's photograph above]
The current will travel first or simultaneously to the neutral and ground bar at box via neutral or ground. Does this pose a hazard while under load with something plugged in and on or not?
Does someone have to touch the metal recept bracket to get shocked, Under load or not? This is scary because I don’t know how many jobs I did this on. There is only that I can recall done just recently.
I don’t think many because I just decided and learned how to do it not so long ago.
The picture [above] is the one that I did at my house.
I took the pic and then decided to undo it and leave it without the neutral to ground jump wire because I could never get a ground continuity beep, it’s buried somewhere in a junction. Iwas unsure. So this would be deemed as a 2 wire 2 prong receptacle, only and should never have a 3 prong installed.
The job I just did I had to replace a GFCI and I did this procedure. Any more help would greatly be appreciated in assisting me to clear up this confusion and get me to go back to that job to correct it for safety reasons. Thank you. - Anonymous by private email 2017/03/29
Yes, connecting ground to neutral ANYWHERE downstream from the main panel (that means not permitted in sub panels)
is dangerous, and is prohibited by electrical codes. The reasoning is as I described.
I understand that it's not obvious to someone not more familiar with electrical wiring codes and principles. I made the same mistake myself back in 1976 during an early wiring job - and I was called to task by the electrical inspector.
It seemed odd that if wires are joined in the main panel, that there would be something wrong with joining them downstream from the panel - until the problem was explained to me as I did to you. And of course later that mistake was underscored when I saw a homeowner knocked right down onto the floor by electric shock from touching the exterior of a BX cable that wrapped exactly such an improperly-wired circuit.
Continue reading at FALSE NEUTRAL Connections explained or select a topic from closely-related articles below, or see our complete INDEX to RELATED ARTICLES below.
Or see AFCI GFCI TESTING & SAFETY
Or see these
Or use the SEARCH BOX found below to Ask a Question or Search InspectApedia
Try the search box below or CONTACT US by email if you cannot find the answer you need at InspectApedia.
Questions & answers or comments about false electrical grounds: definition, detection, hazards, repair methods
Use the "Click to Show or Hide FAQs" link just above to see recently-posted questions, comments, replies, try the search box just below, or if you prefer, post a question or comment in the Comments box below and we will respond promptly.
Search the InspectApedia website