Shared chimney flues:

This article describes shared chimney flues, multiple heating appliances, fireplaces, woodstoves all using the same chimney venting path through a building and to outside.

Shared flues can create fire and smoke spread hazards and carbon monoxide hazards in buildings.

Here we outline how to detect shared chimney flues, how they are repaired, and we list the exceptions to the rule, showing when, in some jurisdictions, it is permitted to vent more than one heating appliance into a single chimney flue and when it is permitted to vent both oil and gas-fired appliances into the same flue.

Our photo (page top) shows three heating appliance, each connected by its own flue vent connector to a masonry block chimney. Is this OK? the answer is, it depends. On the chimney flue size and other installation details. Notice too that we are sharing the flue between oil and wood fired appliances.

These articles on chimneys and chimney safety provide detailed suggestions describing how to perform a thorough visual inspection of chimneys for safety and other defects. Chimney inspection methods and chimney repair methods are also discussed.

Shared Chimney & Shared Flue Hazards

A "shared chimney flue" means that the flue or pathway for venting combustion gases out of a building is shared among two or more things that need to be vented, such as a fireplace and a heating boiler.

A "flue" refers to a sealed pathway out of the building to vent combustion gases, such as a metal flue pipe or clay flue tiles stacked up inside of a chimney.

A single chimney can safely have multiple flues inside the chimney, each flue venting an appliance, fireplace, or other device, provided that the chimney was properly constructed, including the necessary spacing or sealant between the individual flues.

Our photo at the very top of this page and repeated here shows an unlined chimney flue which, by luck of illumination from our flash camera, also showed us that a common flue was being used to vent two fireplaces - a fire code violation in many jurisdictions.

You can see that this chimney has two brick flues entering its common upper section.

There is no flue divider in this chimney above the two flues entering in its bottom - shown in the center of our photo.

Dedicated chimney flues are required: Each device that produces combustion gases needs to have its own dedicated flue to vent combustion gases safely out of the building.

[Click to enlarge any image]

Fire spread and combustion gas or carbon monoxide hazards: gases may be conducted from a heating appliance to another area in the building when the flue divider is missing.

For example, dangerous carbon monoxide from a basement gas fired heater or a coal stove may leak into an upper building floor through a fireplace or woodstove connected to the same flue.

As Carson Dunlop Associates [at REVIEWERS] sketches point out (above left), the missing divider from the chimney shown in our photo above and in the sketch at left may permit dangerous flue gases or carbon monoxide to enter the living area through a fireplace.

Proper construction of chimney walls in a modern masonry flue is shown at above right.

Our photo (above/left) shows that the clay flue tiles are just 1.5" apart (left flue pair) and about 2" apart (right flue pair) - too close according to the sketch above.

This is especially the case if elsewhere in the building a gas (or oil) fired heater is using the same chimney.

In the unfortunate fireplace shown below, we see that someone has "fixed" an unsafe shared chimney flue problem.

The fireplace flue was shared with the heating boiler in the basement.

To end this sharing the repairman installed clay flue tiles between the bottom of the fireplace and the upper fireplace flue.

This is no longer a working fireplace. Is it a safe flue?

Examples of Unsafe and Not-Permitted Shared Chimney Flues or Flue Vent Connectors

Photo: a coal stove (a solid fuel appliance) on the first floor of this Poughkeepsie NY home is vented into the same chimney flue as the gas-fired heating boiler in the basement below. This is an un-safe and improper installation.

It was common for chimney flues to be shared in older buildings in the following ways (and probably others you can suggest to us). All of the examples in the following list are unsafe and should be corrected immediately.

• A single large chimney with multiple fireplaces on the same floor - for example back to back fireplaces on the first floor of a colonial home may share the same flue
• A single chimney serving fireplaces on two or more different floors may be unsafe and usually not permitted anywhere.
  
  In SHARED CHIMNEY FLUES OK
  
  see TWO FIREPLACES in ONE FLUE
• A single chimney flue serving a basement heating appliance: boiler, furnace, or water heater that is also used by a fireplace on the same level in the building or on an upper floor
• A single chimney flue serving a fireplace on one floor and a woodstove on an upper floor may be unsafe and is usually not be permitted in any jurisdiction.
• A single chimney flue serving a basement heating boiler and a coal stove or woodstove on an upper floor
• Single-wythe thick brick masonry flues and some other un-lined chimney flues:
  
  See UNLINED FLUE INSPECTIONS Safety Requirements for old chimneys - photos, dangerous carbon monoxide and blocked flue case report, chimney flue standards, chimney inspection suggestions
• Single large-volume chimney serving multiple heating appliances that cannot properly vent the smaller gas or oil-fired appliance when the chimney is cold

Shared Flue Vent Connector & Chimney - Soot Blow-back Clue at Water Heater

You can see in our photo of this gas fired water heater (left) that the oil-burner fired heater whose flue vent connector is shared is permitting the oil fired heater exhaust to blow backwards out through the gas fired water heater's draft hood.

It is a sure guess that at least when the oil burner is running, this water heater is not working properly and probably not safely. The underlying trouble could be an inadequate or blocked chimney or flue.

Shared Flue: Heating Boiler & Water Heater Unsafe

First photo: in this Poughkeepsie home a gas fired water heater shares a flue with a large gas fired steam boiler.

These clues confirm that this heater is not venting safely and that there is a risk of carbon monoxide poisoning for building occupants.

1. White salt deposits and corrosion around the draft hood on the water heater indicates back-drafting, failure to vent in some conditions, and corroded, damaged flue vent connector. It is possible that steam boiler combustion products back-flow down and out at the water heater draft hood.
2. Flue gas spillage is occurring at the water heater draft hood, possibly because the heater vents into a very large, tall, masonry flue inside which it cannot establish a functional draft, especially if the steam boiler has been off and the chimney is cold.
3. Unsafe modification of flue gas spill sensors: some fool has bent-up the flue gas spillage detectors / sensors to get them out of the flow path of flue gas spillage, probably because flue gas spillage was causing the water heater to turn off.

Watch out: these conditions are unsafe and risk fatal carbon monoxide poisoning.

They also tell us that someone who is not properly trained or informed in heating and chimney safety and maintenance has worked on this equipment.

Below: my photo shows the "bent-up" flue gas spill detector and the white corrosive salts around the draft hood and the flue vent connector.

Overloaded & Improperly Shared Chimney Flue?

Reader Comment: 09 April 2015 NHFireBear said:

What's the deal in the top photo in this article? [and shown just above]

It appears to show a wood-fired boiler (orange Itasca? WB410) and an oil-fired (green) boiler (and possibly the blue, oil-fired water heater) venting into the same flue (i.e., one connector entering above the other).

This would be a violation of both the oil-burner code and the wood-burner code. You cannot generally have any solid-fuel burning appliance venting into the same flue as oil or gas burners. NFPA 31 (2011): 6.5.25, NFPA 211 (2010): 9.8.2.

I have a recent photo of a single-wall oil vent from a floor heater to a masonry wall, having only 2-inch clearance from combustible structure, if you would like a copy to post.

Shall I email you a jpg? I have marked the problem with red arrows. It is 120 dpi and sized at 6.4 inches wide, 4.8 high.

Reply:

NH

I'd like to see and if OK with you use your photo as well: our email is at the CONTACT link at page top or bottom.

The page top photo on this article is indeed an illustration of a fiasco - I agree with you and that's why we published it. I'll add your comments for emphasis.

What's interesting is the wood-oil combi boilers that I've seen with only a single flue-vent connector and thus by definition sharing a chimney.

WOOD-OIL COMBINATION HEATERS

There are exceptions allowed in some jurisdictions that permit separate oil and wood fired devices to share the same flue.

Details are at SHARED CHIMNEY FLUES OK

There, citing appropriate US codes, we note that when a gas fired appliance is permitted to be vented into the same flue as an oil fired heating appliance the smaller sized gas appliance is connected above the oil fired appliance flue vent connector.

I [DF] think the reason for that code specification or requirement is the need to avoid possible back-drafting out through the gas appliance draft hood of the combustion products from the more-powerful draft created by the oil fired appliance.

Worse, such back-drafting could cause fatal carbon monoxide poisoning by interfering with the exhaust of the gas appliance.

Question: should shared chimneys have an air vent to prevent condensation

5 April 2015 Arthur said:

Four gas fire flues emerge from a brick chimney on the roof, not sure whether it is a shared chimney or not.

Two ground floor gas fires and one on the first floor are still in use, the remaining gas fire on the first floor has been removed. The builders opening has been sealed by a registered gas fitter.

Should this chimney have an air vent to prevent condensation occurring ?

But where the flue vent connector run-length is abnormally long or tortuous it may be difficult to get good draft, or where the chimney size itself (to which the flue vent connector joins) is too big or too small, the use of a draft inducer might be permitted.

Watch out: the connection of smaller and larger diameter flue vent connectors together ahead of the chimney such as shown in this photo is unsafe and improper.

The larger appliance vent may overpower and cause backdrafting at the smaller gas fired water heater at the lower right in our photo.

Reply:

Arthur, if there is condensation in a chimney at levels sufficient to cause damage, the solution is not to add an air vent - a step that could be very dangerous as doing so can prevent adequate chimney draft - but to review the chimney size, height, insulating properties against the input BTUh of the appliance being vented.

Proper chimney design and sizing is what are required.

For a complete explanation see

CHIMNEY WET TIME

Also see CREOSOTE FIRE HAZARDS

Photo: a tankless heater vented using plastic connected to a metal B-vent that is badly rusted. This is an unsafe installation. [Click to enlarge any image]

 

 

 

Shared Chimney Hazard Research

• Momen, Ayyoub Mehdizadeh, Jeffrey David Munk, and Patrick Hughes. Condensing Furnace Venting Part 2: EVALUATION OF SAME-CHIMNEY VENT SYSTEMS FOR CONDENSING FURNACES AND NATURAL DRAFT WATER HEATERSs [PDF] ORNL/TM-2014/656 (2015).

...

---

---

ADVERTISEMENT

---

---

Reader Q&A - also see RECOMMENDED ARTICLES & FAQs

On 2019-11-25 by (mod) -

""Cleared Obstacle in flue but need to repair another Unit (mine) for my water heater and boiler "piping into it"."

sounds dangerous to me; a foul-up on vents, chimneys, combustion air defects all risk potentially dangerous, even fatal carbon monoxide poisoning;

At the very least be sure you have properly located, installed, tested fire, smoke & CO detectors while you wait for repair.

On 2019-11-24 by Melinda

Dear danjoefriedman, Thank You for your response. By saying my water heater, (natural gas) keeps blowing out, to clarify, shuts off and flame/pilot goes out.

I have to keep resetting - pushing in starter and click until red light blinks to relight. I do have a Carbon Monoxide detector near it (3' away - on table in condo), have tested it and does not go off. Upstairs condo Unit natural gas boiler had continued to stay off until Chimney Sweep supposedly per Prop Mgr stated, "Cleared Obstacle in flue but need to repair another Unit (mine) for my water heater and boiler "piping into it".

I will get more Clarification and Demand Prop Mgr look into this thoroughly. The condo buildings have always had 1st and 2nd floor separate Condo Units piped in together. Thank You.

On 2019-11-23 by (mod) -

Melinda

I agree that the situation that you described sounds as if there's something unsafe perhaps quite unsafe. However I can't really make sense out of the explanation in the conditions you describe so what you need is an on-site expert who you can trust. I don't know what you mean by water heater blows out for example.

Sounds also is if the people talking to her not being quite clear on exactly what conditions exist where and what repairs are needed.

Get that clear. In the meantime if there's any question about any heating equipment or chimneys that are unsafe it would be smart to leave them off rather than risk of fire explosion or carbon monoxide hazard.

On 2019-11-23 by Melinda

Live in first floor condo - water heater, natural gas, boiler, natural gas. Water heater continually blows out and have to reset. 2nd Floor condo, above me, natural gas, boiler blew out. Contacted Condo Property Mgr. We share venting, stack and flue.

Chimney Sweep person came out and inspected.

Found crushed flue, per son HVAC Tech with communication to Chimney Sweep. . Property Mgr when asking what Chimney Sweep said: Quote: " They cleared the obstruction and need to make a repair due to another unit piping into it"

.I replied to her, this is the original internal construction, 1986, of all of these condo buildings. It appears Property Mgr is having both units pay for all expenses

. Nothing is noted in Condo documents that we have to pay. We have 128 Units, each condo building has 8 units, built in 1986 with same internal set up. Live in N.H.. Any advice would be appreciated. Thank You.

On 2019-10-04 by (mod) -

Julie

If the two heating appliances are on separate floors they need separate flues.

Otherwise, depending on flue size and the input BTUH of the two appliances, they may be able to share a common flue.

On 2019-09-29 by Julie

Recently found out we need a chimney liner. We have two flues in one chimney. One used for gas furnace other for gas water heater. My question is do we need two separate liners or can they be connected somehow?

On 2018-02-03 by (mod) -

No, IMO sharing a flue with oil and coal/wood is unsafe for a variety of reasons: igniting creosote deposits, chimney fires, difficulty regulating draft, possibly openings on different building floors, and of course running afoul of your local building code or fire inspector. I would provide a dedicated flue or if necessary entire chimney for each.

On 2018-02-02 by Tom

I have an oil furnace and a coal/wood furnace on the basement of the home we purchased. They share the chimney. Is this a safe condition, and if not, what is the fix?

On 2016-10-06 by Chris

@Chris,

Can you vent an oil fired furnace and natural gas fired hot water tank in the same masonry chimney?

On 2016-03-14 by Adam

Hi,
Can I connect two gas heater flues to a chimney on the same floor (grand floor) back to back. the chimney is between two rooms.

Thanks,

Adam

On 2016-01-07 by (mod) -

Liliana, normally each fireplace or heating appliance should have its own individual flu.

Trying to share flows between heating appliances including fireplace inserts is asking for trouble such as back drafting smoke down drafting out into the non burning fireplace, and unsafe conditions.

On 2016-01-06 by Liliana

Hello and Happy New Year !
We are in the midst of planing the construction of our house...and we are trying to do the right /safe thing re: wood burning fireplaces.

So... we understand that two solid fuel fireplaces can not share the same flue; however, our house will have the following situation : 3 fireplaces (36 " inserts ) grouped as follows:

two (2) back to back (no see through) -one in living room, one in bedroom -both on the same floor ,and third one -on the second floor bedroom .

Please guide us towards obtaining the appropriate and safe chimney layout to accommodate the three flues .Thank you in advance , Liliana

...

Continue reading at SHARED CHIMNEY FLUES OK where we describe circumstances under which a flue or flue vent connector (stackpipe) can be shared - maybe, or select a topic from the closely-related articles below, or see the complete ARTICLE INDEX.

Or see these

Recommended Articles

• CHIMNEY INSPECTION DIAGNOSIS REPAIR - home
• CHIMNEY CODES & STANDARDS - home
• CREOSOTE FIRE HAZARDS
• DRAFT INDUCER FANS

Suggested citation for this web page

SHARED CHIMNEY & FLUE HAZARDS at InspectApedia.com - online encyclopedia of building & environmental inspection, testing, diagnosis, repair, & problem prevention advice.

Or see this

INDEX to RELATED ARTICLES: ARTICLE INDEX to CHIMNEYS & FLUES

Or use the SEARCH BOX found below to Ask a Question or Search InspectApedia

Ask a Question or Search InspectApedia

Try the search box just below, or if you prefer, post a question or comment in the Comments box below and we will respond promptly.

Note: appearance of your Comment below may be delayed: if your comment contains an image, photograph, web link, or text that looks to the software as if it might be a web link, your posting will appear after it has been approved by a moderator. Apologies for the delay.

Only one image can be added per comment but you can post as many comments, and therefore images, as you like.
You will not receive a notification when a response to your question has been posted.
Please bookmark this page to make it easy for you to check back for our response.

---

 

IF above you see "Comment Form is loading comments..." then COMMENT BOX - countable.ca / bawkbox.com IS NOT WORKING.

In any case you are welcome to send an email directly to us at InspectApedia.com at editor@inspectApedia.com

We'll reply to you directly. Please help us help you by noting, in your email, the URL of the InspectApedia page where you wanted to comment.

Citations & References

In addition to any citations in the article above, a full list is available on request.

---

ADVERTISEMENT

---