EPDM rubber roof installation and repair details (C) Daniel Friedman Eric galowEPDM Rubber Roof Installation & Leak Repair Details
     

  • EPDM ROOF LEAK REPAIRS - CONTENTS: Causes of leaks in a rubber EPDM roof - 14-year EPDM Roof Performance Study. Repair procedures for a leaky EPDM rubber roof that had flashing, ponding, frost damage, EPDM wrinkles & roof seam problems.
    • Rubber roof roof installation, inspection, troubleshooting, repair, life expectancy.
    • Membrane roof materials - Rubber Roofing properties of EPDM roofing
    • Is it really possible to fry an egg on a hot EPDM roof?
  • POST a QUESTION or READ FAQs about EPDM roof installation and repair procedures
  • REFERENCES

InspectAPedia tolerates no conflicts of interest. We have no relationship with advertisers, products, or services discussed at this website.

Leaky EPDM rubber roof repair details:

This article describes an EPDM roof installation study & roof repair history spanning fourteen years, from original rubber roof installation (and the mistakes & shortcuts that led to leaks and trouble) to an extensive tear-off and re-roof repair that was made along the entire problem roof's lower edge.

We illustrate how choice of the wrong roof edge flashing combined with wrinkles in the original EPDM installation led to both frequent maintenance and frequent leaks in the original roof.

Green links show where you are. © Copyright 2015 InspectApedia.com, All Rights Reserved.

Tracing the Life & Performance & Repair History of an EPDM Rubber Roof with Installation Mistakes

EPDM or membrane roof (C) Daniel Friedman

In general we like rubber roofing material. Modern EPDM is very reliable, tolerates sunlight, temperature variations, and properly installed, we have found it leakproof.

But the performance of an EPDM roof can be very different if the installer is not familiar with or does not follow good roofing practices.

Here we provide photos and comments following study of the performance of an EPDM roof during the first 12 years of its life, assaying the effects of mistakes and poor workmanship in the original installation.

Wrinkles in the rubber roof invite future seam failures

EPDM or membrane roof (C) Daniel Friedman

Shown during its 1998 installation above and at left, this rubber EPDM roof was installed on a New York home by a very large and busy Kingston New York roofing company. We followed the life of this roof and its leak and repair history for the ensuing 14 years and describe the results here.

The roofer also may have been in a bit of a rush. EPDM needs to be opened and allowed to relax before it is installed, and care should be taken to minimize the number and size of wrinkles in the roof during the bonding process.

A few small wrinkles in the center of a section of rubber probably won't cause much trouble, but wrinkles near EPDM roof seams are an other story, as we explain here.


Wrong roof edge flashing causes ponding

EPDM rubber roof installation and repair details (C) Daniel Friedman Eric galowThe use of an improper drip edge (gravel stop on a roof that did not use gravel ballast) can be seen at the left side of our photo.

The gravel stop "edge flashing" was nailed on top of rather than below the rubber roof material in order to allow the rubber to be lapped over the roof edge and extended an inch into the gutters (not shown) - which was not a bad idea, though the roof's success then depends on the seam sealing tape (not yet installed here) to prevent leaks at the flashing nails.

The problem with using the wrong roof edge flashing ( a flat drip edge should have been installed) was the ensuing ponding at the roof edge.

In New York where ponding of melting snow later re-freezes, the freeze/thaw action worked open seams near the roof edge, especially where a wrinkle crossed any roof edge seal or seam tape seal.

The EPDM roof shown above leaked in less than five years, and by ten years of age we found recurrent openings and leak risks at several seams in the roof as well as along the lower roof edge where that stupid gravel stop was installed.

EPDM rubber roof installation and repair details (C) Daniel Friedman Eric galow EPDM rubber roof installation and repair details (C) Daniel Friedman Eric galow

Our photos above and at left illustrate another problem with the gravel stop used at the lower edge of this EPDM roof - the metal flashing was not wide enough to reach onto the roof decking - so nails that supposedly secured the flashing to the roof were often nailed into an open space between the roof sheathing edge and the fascia board upper edge - into nowhere.

At above right the original roofer must have figured that nailing six nails into empty air would hold the gravel stop in place.

At left you can see as we lift the roof covering that the nails through that gravel stop didn't catch any wood decking.

This lack of secure nailing allowed the gravel stop to lift and buckle, increasing the roof ponding problem. At re-roof time, selecting a flat drip edge that had plenty of nailing width cured this difficulty, as we illustrate below.

EPDM Wrinkles Extend into Roof Membrane Seams, Aggravated by Gravel-Stop Ponding

Our photos below illustrate what happens when an EPDM wrinkle extends into a roof seam, and as you can see by the water stains, the gravel stop caused excessive ponding that gave frost extra time to work on and push open the seam tape near the roof edge. These seam failures (and leaks) began appearing in the rubber roof in less than five years. The photos below show the roof edge at 14 years of age.

EPDM rubber roof installation and repair details (C) Daniel Friedman Eric galow EPDM rubber roof installation and repair details (C) Daniel Friedman Eric galow

Interim Roof Repairs Avoided a Leak Catastrophe in this EPDM Rubber Roof

We made some interim EPDM roof repairs by cutting out the worst wrinkles and gluing down new sections of EPDM roofing material over the cutout. But as more of the original work deteriorated, by the end of a decade and after discovering carpenter ant infestations traced to leaks near the roof edges, we just didn't trust this roof further.

We inspected this roof every year, sealing suspect seam edges by cleaning the plies and applying rubber roof seam sealer. But as our photo at below left illustrates, it was an endless task, exacerbated by that damnable gravel stop. At below right shows another of the original roofer's ideas for roof-wall flashing: "run it up the wall and glue the top edge of the rubber to the wood siding" - not a reliable installation and one that required constant attention.

EPDM rubber roof installation and repair details (C) Daniel Friedman Eric galow EPDM rubber roof installation and repair details (C) Daniel Friedman Eric galow

Pounding the gravel stop "flat" to allow the roof to drain provided emergency relief to slow the frost working away at seams near the roof edge, but it left a horrible, ugly, and equally stupid roof edge flashing installation.

Beneath a section of garage roofing installed by the same contractor we found leak stains during interior renovations (below right) that were traced to a roof edge (and thank you gravel stop) leak that was hard to spot from outside. At below left I'm pointing to the soil staining in this small ponding area right over the leak shown at below right. We found a nice nest of active carpenter ants (photo) in the wall structure in this area. Leaks into an enclosed roof cavity mean that the space stays wet for a long time - a standing invitation to wood destroying insects and sometimes mold contamination as well.

EPDM rubber roof installation and repair details (C) Daniel Friedman Eric galow EPDM rubber roof installation and repair details (C) Daniel Friedman Eric galow

Finally we just gave up on the annual cut and patch job on this roof. In 2012, after 14 years of cut and paste interim repairs, a better solution was provided by our associate, Eric Galow, of Galow Homes.

Preparing an EPDM Roof for Repair

EPDM rubber roof installation and repair details (C) Daniel Friedman Eric galow EPDM rubber roof installation and repair details (C) Daniel Friedman Eric galow

Galow's crew cut and removed the EPDM and ugly gravel stop from the entire lower roof edge, cleaning and blowing off all loose fragments of debris (below left) and peeling back a 6-inch section of the original roof that we would glue-lap over a new EPDM section of roofing along the roof's now exposed surface. (Photo, far left).

Eric also installed the proper drip edging, of adequate width to nail to the roof deck back from the edge, with a flat profile - no more raised edge gravel stop to cause roof edge ponding. (Photo at near left).

The new sections of EPDM were opened flat and allowed to relax in the incredibly hot sun (photo below left). The new material was fully adhered in place (below right) gluing half of the length of rubber at a time then gluing and smoothing into place the second half, working with care to avoid wrinkles.

EPDM rubber roof installation and repair details (C) Daniel Friedman Eric galow EPDM rubber roof installation and repair details (C) Daniel Friedman Eric galow

Keeping the EPDM Roof Smooth and Wrinkle Free During Installation

EPDM rubber roof installation and repair details (C) Daniel Friedman Eric galow

Notice how nice and smooth the installer has made the new EPDM? No wrinkles in this fully-adhered rubber roof repair.

At the right side of this photo you can see the second segment of rubber roofing half-bonded in place and with end seam overlap primed and ready to adhere as well. We used bricks to hold back the to-be-overlapped width of original roofing during this application so that all final seams would be lapped and glued in the proper direction.

EPDM rubber roof installation and repair details (C) Daniel Friedman Eric galow

Above Ron is bonding the lap-over length of original roofing onto the upper edge of the new EPDM that has been run along the roof edge. That extension cord visible in the left photo was powering the leaf blower used to keep debris off of the to-be-glued surfaces.

Can You Really Fry an Egg on a Hot Roof?

Below you can see the scientific mind of the crew at work - it was so hot on this roof that several of us thought you could "fry an egg" on the roof surface. So we tried it.

EPDM rubber roof installation and repair details (C) Daniel Friedman Eric galow

Keep Debris Off of EPDM Roofing During Bonding

That extension cord visible in the left photo was powering the leaf blower used to keep debris off of the to-be-glued surfaces. At below right you can see we used our bricks to hold the overlap seam of original EPDM down flat onto the new EPDM repair-surface during glue drying time.

EPDM rubber roof installation and repair details (C) Daniel Friedman Eric galow EPDM rubber roof installation and repair details (C) Daniel Friedman Eric galow

Following this EPDM repair we visited all of the existing seams on the remaining original roof (upper slope sections), cleaning and re-sealing any seams that appeared at all suspicious. We also closed and sealed (or re-sealed) all of the EPDM seam edges with EPDM lap sealant as a final step.

Key Articles About Low Slope & Flat Roofs

 

Continue reading at EPDM, RUBBER, PVC ROOFING or select a topic from the More Reading links shown below.

Or see DEFECTS LIST - ROOF LOW SLOPE

Suggested citation for this web page

EPDM ROOF LEAK REPAIRS at InspectApedia.com - online encyclopedia of building & environmental inspection, testing, diagnosis, repair, & problem prevention advice.

More Reading

Green link shows where you are in this article series.

INDEX to RELATED ARTICLES

ARTICLE INDEX to BUILDING ROOFING

OR use the Search Box found below at

Ask a Question or Search InspectApedia

...




Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Click to Show or Hide FAQs

Ask a Question or Search InspectApedia

Use the "Click to Show or Hide FAQs" link just above to see recently-posted questions, comments, replies, try the search box just below, or if you prefer, post a question or comment in the Comments box below and we will respond promptly.

Search the InspectApedia website

HTML Comment Box is loading comments...

Technical Reviewers & References

Publisher's Google+ Page by Daniel Friedman

Click to Show or Hide Citations & References