InspectAPedia®

Wood columns on a neo victorian home, Poughkeepsie NY (C) Daniel FriedmanRound Wood Column Repair / Replacement for Porches
Porch Column Restore or Replace: Assessment of a Porch Repair Durability Over 30 Years

  • PORCH COLUMN REPAIR or REPLACEMENT - CONTENTS: how to diagnose & repair hollow or solid round & square structural & decorative columns, porch column replacement. Causes of column splitting, rot, damage, column venting suggestions. How to repair a lock-joint staved wood column.
  • POST a QUESTION or READ FAQs about the types of decorative & structural porch or interior decorative wood column failure in residential & light commercial buildings
  • REFERENCES
InspectAPedia tolerates no conflicts of interest. We have no relationship with advertisers, products, or services discussed at this website.

Wood column installation, troubleshooting repairs: how to repair or replace a porch column.

This article describes the inspection, repair, or installation of both round and square wood columns often used on porches and sometimes used in building interiors.

Columns that split, lean, bend, sag or rot are often more than a cosmetic problem: often the column is also serving to support a porch roof or other building features. We describe the procedure for repairing porch columns and we examine the condition of the repaired and replaced porch columns at the time of original work and again at the same porch thirty years later in 2015.



Green links show where you are. © Copyright 2017 InspectApedia.com, All Rights Reserved.

Green links show where you are. © Copyright 2017 InspectApedia.com, All Rights Reserved.

Wood Porch Columns: causes of damage, methods of repair or replacement

Wood columns on a neo victorian home, Poughkeepsie NY (C) Daniel Friedman

Causes of Damage to Round Wood Porch Columns

Wooden columns have been used on buildings for centuries; the Poughkeepsie home at 57 South Grand Avenue, shown at left and whose renovation we began in 1985 and whose renovation will be finished when all of the home's owners have died, included repairs to a porch whose roof, columns, floor, and floor structure had been rotted by decades of neglect and of course leaks. That's Laura Waterman and Katie the Certified Environmental Inspector dog on the front porch of this home before repairs were begun in 1985. In 2015 the home stood empty and in need of repairs again.

Here we describe repairs to classical Doric style hollow lock stave wooden porch columns. We describe the original repair work and then we examine the durability of that work thirty years later. This home, originally constructed in 1900, enjoyed a front porch across the width of the building. There from 1900 through the 1940's it was common for Poughkeepsie-ites to relax on the porch in the evening while an occasional car passed up or down Grand Avenue.

By the 1970's the home had been covered by aluminum siding, suspended ceilings had been installed inside, and as part of an extensive renovation, the front porch columns, rotted and split, needed repair or replacement.

Actually a little rot on a round hollow wood post is not the worst problem one encounters. More serious damage to porch columns includes crushing column bases or plinth blocks, damage by rot, termites, or carpenter ants that, when combined with the sloping porch floor and perhaps with a sagging porch structure, places an un-even load on the column from front to back or side to side causing columns to split, lean, or even collapse. .

Choosing Replacement Porch Column Shapes & Profiles: Entasis is important

Because most round wood columns and certainly all of the larger sized columns were used on such homes are hollow they were built using techniques similar to barrel-making and in fact I call them hollow stave columns. Strips of wood with modest tongue and groove sides are glued together to form the column.

Then the column is given entasis - illustrated by my sketch below. Entasis is a colulmn shape or profile formed by a convex curve designed to provide a pleasing form that was originally figured out by the Greeks and shown on classical columns. You'll see that entasis is tricky: it's not a symmetric curve. Yet when viewed from a distance the columns look straight. Entasis was used in the Egyptian pyramids but is most associated with the columns found in the Classical Period in Greece. In China entasis was discussed later, in 1103 by Yingzao Fashi. [Wikipedia at REFERENCES]

[Click to enlarge any image]

Measurements of a hollow stave wood column with good entasis (C) Daniel Friedman

If you actually build a column without entasis, as were the ugly aluminum columns we considered as replacements, the column looks weird when in place - excessively tapered from bottom to top. Kudos to Greece. Of three most column top or capital designs, Corinthian, Doric, or Ionic, the simplest and smoothest is the Doric column design, shown here. Smooth-surfaced Doric columns are the design most commonly found on wood porch columns.

Splits in a hollow stave wood column for a porch can be re-glued (C) Daniel Friedman

Repair or Replacement Procedures for Rotted, Split, or Damaged Porch Columns

Anyhow, a hollow stave column, when exposed to uneven loads by the weight of the roof pressing down on a column that rests on a rotting or improperly shaped plinth block (base) wants to split. So column repairs will include both gluing back the split column staves and cutting/replacing rotted sections. For a wood column that is smashed beyond repair, don't despair.

The split shown in the hollow wood column at above right can be repaired but I do not recommend just injecting epoxy into the open joints: you're making the column diameter ever wider and asking for more damage in the future.

Rot and damage to porch columns often starts in the roof or soffits overhead - with leaks (C) Daniel Friedman

A proper repair involves removing the column, opening the joints a bit further and blowing them clean and dry. Then glue is inserted and strap clamps are used to re-clamp the column to its original dimensions.

How to support a porch roof during column repair or replacement (C) Daniel Friedman

At above left you can see that damage to porch columns and often the porch floor usually begins at the porch roof or soffit and box beam that bears on the column tops. Leaky porch roof built-in gutters send water into the box beam and porch soffit where it rots those components as well as leaking into the columns below.
See EAVES TROUGH, INTEGRAL GUTTERS for details of how this porch and its eaves trough gutters were repaired.

Round wood porch column damage repair (C) Daniel Friedman

What Happens When You Wrap a Home in Aluminum?

Round wood porch column damage repair (C) Daniel Friedman

Above you can see at above left the water stains on the soffit and the box beam supporting the porch roof as well as at the top of our round stave wood porch column. Mrs. Perkins, the housekeeper for Mr. Perkins until his wife died, became Mrs. Perkins #2 and lived in this home for ensuing decades. In the 1960's Mrs. Perkins #2 accepted a contractor's offer to cover the entire outside of the home in aluminum: aluminum siding and aluminum wrap covered all of the home's trim from top to bottom.

Wrapping a home in "no maintenance" aluminum was appealing to Mrs. Perkins who was facing a costly home paint job, but if the trim and siding are not properly installed to keep water out of the surfaces they cover (or to let it out if it enters), the result spells trouble for later owners such as Laura and Katie. For example, at the home's front porch the aluminum wrapped around the box beam supporting the front porch acted as a gutter to trap leaks from above around the beam causing both beam rot and porch column rot.

Take a look at the column top (above right) and notice those dark vertical lines: the column staves were coming un-glued. In wider column segments and especially near the column base where water accumulated inside the hollow column these staves separate completely.

At above right you can see the deterioration of the roof cornice trim, soffit and box beam exposed after we finished removing the aluminum wrapper.

Round wood porch column damage repair (C) Daniel Friedman

Above and below are photographs of the rotted and carpenter-ant damaged wood column base.

Round wood porch column damage repair (C) Daniel Friedman

At above right you can see my temporary support jammed under the porch column but more important notice that the column is badly split. Someone had attempted to "repair" the porch column by attaching a metal band around its base.

Water running in the column interior soaked the column base and plinth block, rotted those components, and rotted the porch floor and supporting beam below. The corners of the porch floor structure were supported by hollow brick columns. Water running inside those columns were an engraved invitation to carpenter ants who had moved into the columns too, adding to the excitement.

Repair to brick column supporting porch, flashing details (C) Daniel Friedman

The brick columns (piers if you prefer) supporting the porch were falling apart and needed to be re-built from footings up (above left, 1985). I re-used the original bricks but modern mortar. At the column top, not wanting the carpenter ants to have an easy access into the porch structure again, I installed a solid, custom-fabricated copper column top shown in the photo above. You'll also note that the porch floor repair lumber used treated wood. This was later covered with a fascia trim board for better cosmetic appearance.

57 South Grand Avenue Poughkeepsie NY porch brick column in 2015 (C) Daniel Friedman

At above is one of the same rebuilt brick supporting piers in 2015, three decades later: still intact thanks to that copper cap flashing just visible under the blue trim boards around the porch floor frame.

Watch out: there is no safe way to remove badly damaged porch columns like these without first constructing very secure independent supports for the porch roof - unless you're going to tear off the whole roof structure first. In this case the porch roof structure was salvageable: we just needed to rebuild the eaves trough gutters, soffits, and box beam below. So we supported the roof to permit removal of the damaged porch columns at the left and right porch corners.

Support around porch column so that it can be removed and replaced (C) Daniel Friedman

Above you can see how we supported this end of the porch roof so that the corner column could be removed for repair or replacement. At this point we've also begun repairs of the porch roof gutters and trim. We simply used a telepost (aka "jackpost" that is a telescoping column with a large screw in one end) to jack the roof just enough to permt removal of the old column.

Support around porch column so that it can be removed and replaced (C) Daniel Friedman

Watch out: Bracing and cross-bracing are critial for safety when jacking a porch or removing columns.

Venting Suggestions for Hollow Lock Stave Wood Columns

While repairing the salvageable and replacing the worst wood columns on a Poughkeepsie New York home built in 1900 it made sense to pay special attention to flashing at post tops to prevent water entry from above, venting the hollow column interior to reduce rot and carpenter ant attacks, and to provide a sound and properly set column base or plinth block, adapted to the slope of the porch.

To vent the column I built a custom plinth block of solid treated lumber and cut arches at the sides of the block parallel to the wood grain so as to avoid splitting. I set the columns with base vent openings to the left and right sides of the column so that they'd not be obvious from the street, and I bore my column top vent hole near the column top but on the porch interior side, again for cosmetic reasons. My original sketch below shows where these vent openings were placed.

Venting details for a hollow wood porch column help avoid rot and insect attack (C) Daniel Friedman

At above in my original sketch and below photographed in 2015, 30 years after this renovation, you can see the vent opening at the top of the round hollow wood column.

Venting a round porch column at the column top (C) Daniel Friedman

Back in 1985, after I got sick of repairing the porch roof and gutters (below) it was time to either fix or replace the porch columns whose absence was disturbing everyone else.

Repairing the roof and eaves trough gutters 57 S. Grand Ave. Poughkeepsie NY (C) Daniel Friedman

We removed the scary angled temporary supports and installed temporary wood posts near the porch corners but leaving enough room to install the replacement round wood columns when they arrived.

Poughkeepsie home front porch box beam and columns (C) Daniel Friedman

Above we see that the same home in 2015 needs repairs and maintenance but I was pleased to see that my copper-lined eaves trough gutters had protected the box beam and soffits from water damage for three decades.

Hollow wood porch column replacement brought from Brooklyn in 1985 (C) Daniel Friedman

Above are images of the replacement corner posts that we brought up from the American Wood Column Corporation in Brooklyn, N.Y. in 1985. We matched our original columns that themselves may have come from this company or its predecessor, depending on when the original porch was constructed. American Wood Column Corp. has been in business since 1918.

Lock stave wood porch column from American wood Column Corp. (C) Daniel Friedman

At above right you'll see the deterioration that can appear after 30 years of weather exposure with no maintenance. No one painted these posts after our original installation and paint job back in 1985. This lock-stave hollow wood column is repairable: water has not been running in its interior and I saw no rot on the column whatsoever.

Front porch with bad columns removed, waiting for replacement columns from Brooklyn (C) Daniel Friedman

The center columns at this porch were in better shape and could be re-glued, repaired, and re-used. The corner columns, on inspection, were, well, depressing. We drove down to Grand Street in Brooklyn, New York to buy almost perfectly-matching replacements for two of our Doric columns that were beyond repair. The manufacturer glues up the wood stave column and then puts it on a gigantic lathe to cut the column to a profile with perfect entasis.

57 South Grand Ave, Poughkeepsie NY in 2015 (C) Daniel Friedman

The repaired porch received the new columns at its corners. At above right is the same home photographed in August, 2015. The property is for sale and needs at least a roof and exterior painting, but its Doric columned front porch is still standing. In the ensuing 30 years not one soul has seemed to notice that they are not an exact match for their center- sisters.

57 S Grand Ave porch column plinth block (C) Daniel Friedman

Above left: in 2015 it's time to replace those plinth blocks and some of the column bases, and other column repairs are past due.

57 S Grand Ave porch column plinth block (C) Daniel Friedman

I'd recommend using a pre-formed fiberglass column plinth block to put an end to rot worries and to improve the intake venting at each column base.

57 S Grand Ave Poughkeepsie porch in 2015 (C) Daniel Friedman

Above is the front porch at 57 S. Grand Avenue in Poughkeepsie in August 2015.

Replacement Lock Stave Wood Column Sources & Porch Repair Guides

 

...


Continue reading at COLUMNS & POSTS, DEFECTS for problems with structural wood columns, or select a topic from closely-related articles below, or see our complete INDEX to RELATED ARTICLES below.

Or see DECK & PORCH CONSTRUCTION - home

Or see PORCH CONSTRUCTION & SCREENING

Also see ARCHITECTURE, STYLE, & BUILDING AGE

Suggested citation for this web page

PORCH COLUMN REPAIR or REPLACEMENT at InspectApedia.com - online encyclopedia of building & environmental inspection, testing, diagnosis, repair, & problem prevention advice.

INDEX to RELATED ARTICLES: ARTICLE INDEX to BUILDING DECKS & PORCHES

Or use the SEARCH BOX found below to Ask a Question or Search InspectApedia


...

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Click to Show or Hide FAQs

Ask a Question or Search InspectApedia

Use the "Click to Show or Hide FAQs" link just above to see recently-posted questions, comments, replies, try the search box just below, or if you prefer, post a question or comment in the Comments box below and we will respond promptly.

Search the InspectApedia website

Comment Box is loading comments...

Technical Reviewers & References

Click to Show or Hide Citations & References

Publisher's Google+ Page by Daniel Friedman