Damaged fiber cement siding - Rhinebeck NY (C) Daniel FriedmanTips for Removing Fiber Cement Siding

InspectAPedia tolerates no conflicts of interest. We have no relationship with advertisers, products, or services discussed at this website.

Fiber cement siding removal procedures to minimize dust & to permit possible salvage & re-use of the material.

This article describes How to remove fiber cement siding with minimum damage or hazardous silica dust, and why owners decided to remove fiber cement siding from their home and to replace it with James Hardie's HardiePlank fiber cement product.

The article details just how the old fiber cement siding was removed with minimum damage.

We also provide a MASTER INDEX to this topic, or you can try the page top or bottom SEARCH BOX as a quick way to find information you need.

Fiber Cement Siding Removal Procedures

Gaps at butt joints of HardiePlank siding on an 8-year-old home  (C) Daniel FriedmanWhy remove building fiber cement siding?

Generally we do not recommend removing building siding in good condition, even if there are cosmetic issues that need to be addressed.

But if building siding is extensively damaged, or so badly installed that building wall leaks are widespread and damaging the building, one might consider removing and replacing all or more limited sections of the wall siding on the building.

and further
at SIDING, FIBER CEMENT MOISTURE LEVELS we describe a ten year old fiber cement siding installation that came to the building owners' attention because of large butt joint gaps in the lap siding installation.

When owners asked for advice from several building inspectors, industry consultants, and siding contractors, they learned that the product they thought they were buying, HardiePlank fiber cement siding, was not what their original contractor installed.

Watch out: this article describes the removal of fiber cement lap siding - horizontal "boards" such as shown in our photos. These procedures are not suitable for the removal of fiber cement shingles nor asbestos cement shingles. If you are working with those siding shingle materials and need to remove shingles for repair,

Why remove limited sections of fiber cement siding

Damaged fiber cement siding - Rhinebeck NY (C) Daniel Friedman

But even if there is no sound reason for removal of all fiber cement siding from a building, it may be necessary to remove sections of damaged FC siding such as the impact-damaged siding shown in our photograph at left.

Note that that damaged FC siding was at a different property from the "counterfeit" bad siding job installation discussed here and illustrated just above.

The siding damage you see in this photo was caused by a vehicle or by an impact.

Mechanical damage to fiber cement siding is described in more detail at SIDING, FIBER CEMENT DEFECTS.

Visible & Hidden Trouble Points in & Behind the Original FC Siding Installation

Open fiber cement siding butt joint shows no back flashing was installed (C) Daniel Friedman E Galow

Further close-up inspection by the repair contractor, Galow Homes, as well as by the author (DJF) found numerous other siding installation SNAFUS including:

And more FC siding installation snafus were discovered as we began pulling the old material off of the building, including


It seemed likely that had the home been more than just ten years old, more extensive rot, insect damage, wall cavity mold contamination, and lost insulation values would all have accured.

Hardieplank warning about silica dust (C) James Hardie

The owners ultimately decided to remove the siding, thinking that either the material would be salvaged and re-installed correctly, or the "counterfeit" fiber cement siding woudl be replaced entirely with new product.

The contractor at the job we investigated considered the remove and salvage approach, though there would be some lost material due to damage during removal.

A second consideration during fiber cement siding material removal was the wish to avoid exposure to high levels of silica dust. Note the silica dust warning in the HardiePlank® product label shown at left.

Modern fiber cement products do not contain asbestos but silica dust from these products may be a hazard itself. Asbestos from older asbestos cement shingle siding and roofing products is a widely recognized hazards. For information about that different hazard, see ASBESTOS ROOFING / SIDING DUST.

How to Remove Fiber Cement Siding with Minimum Damage & Dust

Since the old counterfeit fiber cement siding was going to be removed anyway, the contractor chose to remove it with care, minimizing the damage, to give the owner the option of re-installing the orignial siding without gaps. (The owner later elected to toss the old siding and purchase new Hardieplank fiber cement siding - a step that was not without its own difficulties -

How to remove fiber cement siding - nail punching (C) Daniel Friedman How to remove fiber cement siding - nail punching (C) Daniel Friedman

Removing and reinstalling building siding, especially over a cosmetic issue, is a very costly approach but makes sense in some installations such as the fiasco of a fiber-cement siding installation job shown at SIDING, FIBER CEMENT GAPS.

Trying to just pull boards off of the building or pry them off will ... well basically it'll destroy the siding, breaking it at almost every attempt. In the photos above you can see how we used a nail punch to drive the siding nails through the siding to permit removal of the boards for possible re-use. After each board is punched and lifted carefully off of the wall we have to also pull all of the siding nails out of the sheathing to give a smooth surface for the next job.

Pulling siding nails out of the sheathing (C) Daniel Friedman Pulling siding nails out of the sheathing (C) Daniel Friedman

At above right you can see the material lost on the back-side of the fiber cement siding boards when nails are punched through.

Fiber cement siding stacked indoors after removal from the building (C) Daniel Friedman Eric Galow

Watch out: when carrying any long fibre cement lap siding board, be sure to keep the board in the vertical or "as it would be on the wall" position. If you carry the board on the flat and it's got any length to it you're inviting breakage.

After "punching" to set the siding nails in through the fiber cement lap siding board, for boards more than about 6 feet in length, two workers should cooperate to carefully lift the board off of the building surface and carry it or hand it down for flat stacking under cover for protection from the weather.

Storing Re-Claimed Fiber Cement Lap Siding

The contractor stored the reclaimed lap siding indoors in the client's garage, stacked flat, and placed on a tarp to avoid picking up moisture from the floor.

Any loose debris was swept or HEPA vacuumed to avoid a possible silica dust hazard indoors, and the stack was also covered.

If the siding were to be re-used the contractor would have a bit of clean-up to do as well, to remove any caulk left adhered to the siding faces or ends. (Photo below).

The contractor would probably not bother to try chipping away at caulk bonded to the siding board ends; rather when the boards are being cut to size for re-use the messy ends will simply be chopped off before the board is cut to the new required length.

Fiber cement siding - used, removed, reclaimed, ends needing caulk removal (C) Daniel Friedman, Eric galow


Continue reading at SIDING, FIBER CEMENT REPAIRS or select a topic from closely-related articles below, or see our complete INDEX to RELATED ARTICLES below.

Or see these

Fiber cement siding articles


Suggested citation for this web page

SIDING, FIBER CEMENT REMOVAL at - online encyclopedia of building & environmental inspection, testing, diagnosis, repair, & problem prevention advice.


Or use the SEARCH BOX found below to Ask a Question or Search InspectApedia


Ask a Question or Search InspectApedia

Try the search box just below, or if you prefer, post a question or comment in the Comments box below and we will respond promptly.

Search the InspectApedia website

HTML Comment Box is loading comments...

Technical Reviewers & References

Click to Show or Hide Citations & References

Publisher - Daniel Friedman