Building heat loss troubleshooting & cures:
This article series discusses how to find points of heat loss and air leaks in existing buildings using a variety of tools and inspection methods including infra red, smoke tests, visual inspection, and tests.
This article explains how to survey a building for air and heat loss or gain points and how to correct them. This article series discusses how to find points of heat loss and air leaks in existing buildings using a variety of tools and inspection methods including infra red, smoke tests, visual inspection, and tests.
This detailed article accompanies a building weatherization and energy-savings company through a detailed building inspection for heat loss points and air leaks. The author accompanied Princeton Energy Partners as they used the blower door, thermal imaging, smoke guns, and visual inspection to pinpoint building air leaks, convective loops, heat loss points, air infiltration and air exfiltration on a building.
Green links show where you are. © Copyright 2017 InspectApedia.com, All Rights Reserved.
This article explains how to survey a building for air and heat loss or gain points and how to correct them.
The text below expands, paraphrases, quotes-from, updates, and comments an original article, "House Doctors with Better Medicine" - Steven Bliss, from Solar Age Magazine. Our photo (left) illustrates a step in a project by the website aurhtor (DF) and steps in sealing air leaks around a window in a New York Home.
The author accompanies a building weatherization and energy-savings company through a detailed building inspection for heat loss points and air leaks.
Princeton Energy Partners used the blower door, thermal imaging, smoke guns, and visual inspection to pinpoint building air leaks, convective loops, heat loss points, air infiltration and air exfiltration on a building. The energy sleuth team investigated a ca 1900 home in Swarthmore, Pennsylvania, with the goal of saving the client the most energy dollars possible based on a day's work of building investigation for air leaks, convective loops, and other energy loss points.
The energy-savings crew uses three principal tools: a blower door, an infrared scanner, and a smoke gun. Bit visual inspection also plays a critical role in testing the air leakiness of a building and in setting priorities for sealing air leaks.
The importance of setting priorities for sealing these points of energy wasted is emphasized and discussed, and sketches as well as photographs of common points of building heat loss, or unwanted heat gain, and air leaks are provided.
First the blower door is installed and sealed in a building entry.
The blower door (see BLOWER DOORS & AIR INFILTRATION) uses a calibrated fan that moves a measured volume of air per minute, combined with instrumentation to display the air pressure differences between inside the building and outdoors.
A reading at the blower door gives a measure of building air changes per hour, answering the question "How leaky is this home" to provide a starting point for energy savings.
A repeat of the blower door test after all building energy savings recommendations have been installed will permit everyone to evaluate the success of the building sealing operation.
When discussing saving heating or cooling costs in older buildings we expect to be starting with a rather leaky building where the concern for indoor air quality worries in a "too-tight" house are virtually nil.
For indoor air quality advice for very tight homes that have very low air leakage rates,
see INDOOR AIR QUALITY & HOUSE TIGHTNESS.
For the home studied in this article, the house leaked at 32 air changes per hour (ach) at 50 pascals of pressure. (We need to use a standard pressurization in order to compare leakage rates among homes or within the same home under different conditions such as before and after sealing.)
Just how leaky is that? New energy efficient houses have natural air infiltration rates of 0.2 to 0.5 air changes per hour (ACH). So this 1900's home in Pennsylvania starts with an air leakage rate that is 64 to 160 times as leaky as a new, tight, energy-efficient home.
After sealing the leaks discussed below and before addressing leaky windows - often the major energy loss on older homes - the air changes per hour was reduced from the starting 32 ach down to 24 ach - a 25 percent improvement, for very little materials or labor cost. The crew pointed out that the sealing operations described below were more for comfort than energy savings, reducing drafts, eliminating cold spots in the home.
Following the discussion of building convective air loops, air leaks, & heating leaks below, we discuss the priorities of action in saving home heating or cooling energy costs
Using a smoke gun near a joint in the hardwood flooring on the second floor, and again at various points around a sweeping formal stairwell, the smoke is seen disappearing into the internal structure of the home.
Where would one seal such building leaks? If one simply seals openings around the stairwell, the air leakage simply shifts to the floor or baseboard, and there will be little or no change in the buildings's heating bill.
The energy consultant points out that these openings identify convective air loops in the building.A convective loop describes air moving through buildings due to temperature differences among building areas, bringing warm air out of some building areas while simultaneously bringing cool air into them from other leak points.A typical convective loop in an older home ties into the stairwell, the second floor joist cavity, and probably a number of interior partitions. Sealing at the stairwell would just be treating the symptoms, but ignoring the illness.
Convective loops such as shown here act as a heat pump moving heat out of a building and cooling the interior during the heating season.
The importance of setting priorities for sealing these points of energy wasted is emphasized and discussed, and sketches as well as photographs of common points of building heat loss, or unwanted heat gain, and air leaks are provided. Accompanying text and sketches are reprinted/adapted/excerpted with permission from Solar Age Magazine - editor Steven Bliss.
As we introduced above, in this article the author, Steven Bliss, accompanies a building weatherization and energy-savings company through a detailed building inspection for heat loss points, convective loops, and air leaks.
The author accompanies Princeton Energy Partners as they use thermal imaging, smoke guns, and visual inspection to pinpoint building air leaks, heat loss points, air infiltration and air exfiltration on a building. The importance of setting priorities for sealing these points of energy wasted is emphasized and discussed, and sketches as well as photographs of common points of building heat loss, or unwanted heat gain, and air leaks are provided.
The text below expands, paraphrases, quotes-from, updates, and comments an original article, "House Doctors with Better Medicine, Princeton Energy Partners use the latest diagnostic tools to comb a house for the major causes of heat loss.
Their findings are often astonishing. Their strong prescriptions bring results", Steven Bliss, (see links just above) from Solar Age Magazine and written by Steven Bliss. Discussed here are these building heat loss investigation topics:
The real action is in the building attic - a location where an energy savings/weatherization company may spend half of their time, followed by 30-40 percent of their effort in the building's basement or crawl spaces.
Our sketch (left) shows possible convective loop pathways that may move heat from a building interior upwards into an attic space (red arrows) while bringing cold air down from an un-heated attic space at the same time (blue arrows).
In the attic the weatherization crew scanned the attic floor which is in this home covered with a few inches of perlite insulation (see Perlite Insulation).
The crew moves aside insulation to observe that the building walls are balloon framed (see Framing Methods Age) forming a continuous air conduction channel from basement to attic unless tight fire-blocking was installed.
The crew sealed these openings with stapled, caulked polyethylene.
The chimney chase is sealed with strips of aluminum flashing and caulk.
Where building exterior walls are open to the building's eaves, the investigators determine that moisture is being carried up the stud bays and dumped into the cold attic by convection air currents, contributing to peeling paint on the building exterior.
The emerging picture of the home is of a network of interconnected chambers exchanging air, heat, and moisture, in accordance with shifting temperature and air pressure differences, and the laws of physics (warm air rises, cold air falls, heat moves from warm to cool spaces or materials).
Improper building roof or attic ventilation design, such as installing a ridge vent with inadequate air intakes at the eaves or soffits, or installing only gable-end exit vents in an attic (a very common practice in the 1950's and 60's) is likely to increase an attic condensation problem and will increase building heating costs as well.
and see ATTIC VENTILATION for more details.
For cape cod style homes, also see INSULATION LOCATION for CAPES, CRAWLSPACES.
The energy contractors claim that their work consistently saves the homeowner considerably more money than is predicted by the reductions in air infiltration alone. This seeming magic is attributed to the elimination of "thermal bypasses", that is, the myriad ways heat gets out of the building other than through wall and ceiling components following the rules and regulations of ASHRAE.
Prominent among these heat leaks are convective loops - wall and ceiling cavities that act as room-sized heat exchangers, relentlessly pumping heat out of a building even if there is no direct air leakage from indoors to outdoors.
A related problem is the reduction in building wall R-values if air flows through fiberglass insulation. While this phenomenon has been reported many times in the research literature, it is generally overlooked since it defies accurate prediction.
Our photo (left) shows the black stains deposited by dust particles (this is not mold) when building air leaks past fiberglass insulation, seen from the attic side of a 1960's contemporary framed home with lots of air leaks. In our photo and in many air leak problems at fiberglass-batt insulated cavities, the problem is one of installation and construction leak problems, not a defect in the fiberglass insulating batt itself.
The claim of fiberglass batt air leakage, supported vigorously by the foam insulation industry, is equally vigorously counter-argued by the fiberglass insulation companies who point out that properly installed the air flow rate through the fiberglass itself in fiberglass insulated cavities is very low.
In our forensic lab (DF) microscopic examination of the stained fiberglass material confirmed that the black material was house dust and debris, not mold. The stain pattern itself is suggestive of air leaking upwards from the room below.Air entered at the wall sill plate and as more air moved along the space between the insulation and the studs you can see the black stains extending upwards in that area.
Details are at THERMAL TRACKING & HEAT LOSS.
Fiberglass insulation will not, according to Gadsby from PEP, block these escape routes for a building's heat: Gadsby's view is that fiberglass does not stop airflow in wall cavities. Infrared scanners tell the same story, showing heat loss around and even through fiberglass insulation--even the massive batts in a superinsulated ceiling.
For that reason, the PEP partners prefer blown insulation over fiberglass batts. With loose-fill fiberglass insulation, they believe, the airflow paths are circuitous enough to stop short any airflow.
OPINION-DJF: we pose that loose-fill insulation may do a more consistent job of closing air or thermal bypass leaks that are sometimes left around fiberglass batts - that's the real problem.
Where air leaks occur around fiberglass batts, look closely: you will probably see that the leaks are at the perimeter of the insulation and at locations where openings in framing, drywall, or insulation were cut to admit recessed ceiling lights, electrical or plumbing penetrations, or similar openings. If airflow were simply through the fiberglass batt in any uniform way, the dust stains on and inside the insulation would also be expected to be uniform. They are not.
We full agree with PEP, however, that predicting air leaks through fiberglass-insulated cavities is very difficult, since leakage depends on the quality of installation workmanship. We have indeed occasionally found workmanship errors that resulted in unanticipated air leaks though foam-sprayed insulation as well, particularly when the insulation (of either type) was installed in a hard-to-access space such as a crawl area.
Our pair of photos above were taken in a tight, hard to enter crawl area where the icynene spray foam insulation was not so carefully applied. Our smoke test found air movement from the damp, occasionally moldy crawl area into an opening in the foam insulating blanket. We pulled a bit of this already-leaky material off to see what was behind and found (photo above right) a leaky metal return air duct. When the air handler was running it was drawing cold, sometimes nasty, crawl space air into the duct system through this leak.
In addition to their effect on energy bills, the impact of convective loops in buildings can be gauged by measuring attic temperatures before and after sealing off thermal bypasses such as chases and wall partitions, or it can be roughly modeled from the temperature difference and the height of the convective loop.
In multifamily and even single family buildings it is common for bathrooms to be "stacked" one on top of the other, forming a giant convective loop.
In many cases PEP (the energy consulting and weatherizing firm in the original article) finds interior partitions colder than outside walls.
Since the cooling effect of a convective loop is only partly due to air leakage, even a completely closed wall cavity such as a (hollow core block) masonry party wall can cause problems.
One cure in the case of a masonry party wall is a solid course of block at the ceiling level, isolating the airflow within the heated space. Of course this is most easily accomplished during new construction.
Details about convective loops in buildings are
at CONVECTIVE LOOPS & THERMAL BYPASS LEAKS.
Energy retrofitting reduces drafts and cold spots and, according to PEP, produces some unanticipated benefits such as fewer rodent problems and fewer frozen pipes. Still, to sell the service to big buyers - the developers, housing authorities, and government agencies - it has to show an attractive return on investment. Says Gadsby referring to conventional weathersealing treatments, "To do a job for $1200. that's going to save $50. a year is just not the way to do business."In some cases the savings have been spectacular. For example in a 1982 retrofit, PEP spent three months retrofitting the 450-unit Glenhardie Condominium Comlex near Valley Forge, PA, for $62,000.
The 20-building development already had its insulation and heating system upgraded when it went condo four years earlier. After three months of house-doctoring, consisting solely of attic work, the annual heating bill was reduced from2093 to 1329 therms of natural gas, resulting in a first-year savings of $40,600, not including the $9,300. tax credit
.More typical was a proposal to the Baltimore Housing Authority, in which PEP agreed to treat apartments for $550. each while they were undergoing rehab. PEP's work was to be staged over two to three visits. With annual heating bills in that housing stock running $1200 to $1300 (1984 costs), the simple payback would be under three years. In terms of air infiltration alone, said Gadsby, recently-built townhouses generally measure in at about 10 to 15 ach (1984 data) at 50 Pascals before house-doctoring and are sealed down to about 6 ach after.
Costs for weatherizing are held down by providing the service in a one-day blitz, or in new construction in a series of quick hits. In general, a weatherization company can do more effective work for less money during construction or rehab than with retrofitting, since the problems are more visible and accessible.
The cost to the homeowner was estimated to be one half to two-thirds what it would cost to retrofit after construction, and you're probably going to save an extra 5 to 10 percent on energy costs as well.Here we include solar energy, solar heating, solar hot water, and related building energy efficiency improvement articles reprinted/adapted/excerpted with permission from Solar Age Magazine - editor Steven Bliss.
This article continues at BASEMENT HEAT LOSS DETECTION
Also see BTU Monitoring & HEATING COST APPORTIONMENT Issues where we discuss BTU usage monitoring & heating cost apportionment methods used in buildings housing multiple rental apartments or other tenants served by a single heating system.
Continue reading at THERMAL IMAGING, THERMOGRAPHY or select a topic from closely-related articles below, or see our complete INDEX to RELATED ARTICLES below.
Or see AIR MOVEMENT in BUILDINGS - When, where, how & why air moves in buildings.
Or use the SEARCH BOX found below to Ask a Question or Search InspectApedia
Questions & answers or comments about how to track down and fix points of building heat loss.
Use the "Click to Show or Hide FAQs" link just above to see recently-posted questions, comments, replies, try the search box just below, or if you prefer, post a question or comment in the Comments box below and we will respond promptly.
Search the InspectApedia website